Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Lathe article in FWW

Posts

Lathe article in FWW

#1

Lathe article in FWW

Mark Wollschlager

>I am sort of surprised that no one has mentioned the 'Heavy Duty Lathes' tool test article in the May/June '07 Fine Woodworking.

The Powermatic 3520B was rated the best overall. Followed by the new Nova 1624-44 ( and DVR ) rated best value.

What surprised me, and was all the buzz on the Stubby list was the lack of some other brands.

The article mentioned that Oneway did not make a lathe comparable in size and price, and that Delta was unable to provide a sample for testing.

It seems that all of the bigger lathes were for pro use only. ??

Some of the test were sort of interesting, but of questionable value.

Any comments?

Re: Lathe article in FWW

#2

Totally agree

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>I read that article with some interest. While I've never had the chance to test multiple lathe like this guy did, I'm not sure I agree with the testing methods. The tool rest on my Jet never moves once I tighten the knob. Of course, if I hit it with a sledge hammer, it WILL move! It's not welded in place!

I also noticed the lack of certain well known names in that test.

To be honest, I don't thing ANY tool review in a magazine should be taken for gospel. It's all subjective and you have no idea if there is an "agenda" or not. If you can you should try the tool out for yourself. Then make your choice based on your observations.

Re: Lathe article in FWW

#3

Re: Lathe article in FWW

John Lucas

>I haven't read it yet and agree with thier two choices in the particular price range. I would certainly put the Oneway 1640 in that group unless it was above thier price range. This is a magazine that regularly runs articles on very high end flat working tools. You would think they would do one on lathes that fit the Stubby, Oneway, Robust, Vicmarc price range.

Re: Lathe article in FWW

#4

Lost faith in FWW years ago..

Gerry Meekins

>

Re: Lathe article in FWW

#5

Steve Kubien

Re: Lathe article in FWW

Steve Kubien

>When I am in the market for a new tool of considerable $$$ I read many of the reviews to get some idea of what is out there. I do not have the ability to test-drive many tools because we do not have Woodcraft (or anything really similar for power tools) around here (Toronto area). I tend to look for trends in findings and weigh all of the +'s and -'s. I do not accept one mag's results as gospel for fear that there may be an agenda or simply a bias on the part of the writer's/editors. This way of looking at things has served me well in looking at biscuit joiners, mid-size routers (man I love my Bosch 1617EVS!) and high-end smoothing planes. I will be checking out the FWW article with great interest as the Nova 1624-44 is likely next on my hit-to-the-pocket-book list.

Thanks for letting us know about it.

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: Lathe article in FWW

#6

Re: As usual

Russ Fairfield

>Another magazine tool review that has nothing to do with the reality of real life, and which I disagree with almost everything they say.

These articles are just as much a personal opinion with all of the same built-in bias and prejudice as this message that I am writing here on this forum. The difference is that they have a larger audience, the perception of more authority, and advertising dollars to protect.

Use it as a guide, not the final word on making a tool decision. There is no better source for information than from those who are using the machinery. The members of your local woodturning club are a better source for making a buying decision than any magazine article could ever be, and they will give you a chance to see the lathe being used.

Re: Lathe article in FWW

#7

Re: Lost faith in FWW years ago..

Mike Cunningham (Cape May)

>When Readers Digest took over American Woodworker it went to hell in a handbasket in a hurry. Fine Woodworking, though not owned by RD has slowly been following suit. Both were excellent magazines at one time, though FWW always a step up.

I still subscribe to FWW primarily because I have every issue from #1.

The so called test was really lacking, for more reasons than the heavyweights were omitted. Wouldn't it be nice to see these tests performed by a panel of 3 or 4, noted in their field.

Mike

Re: Lathe article in FWW

#8

Re: Lathe article in FWW

Ralph

>Well, yes... First, given the lathes they reviewed, is there anyone that can honestly disagree with their bottom line. The Powermatic is was heck of a good lathe (and I don't own one)

Next, they obviously put a price ceiling on the cost, just guessing but it looks like under $3000 (US). Which means there is not a Oneway, Robust or Stubby that both meets their requirement (16x40) and was under $3000. Why the Longbed Vicmarc 200 was not included would be a question. The great "heavy" lathes from all of these sources crowd $5000 real hard, which puts them in a completely different price class.

As to the testing methodology, would you rather they used some subjective "feel" test, or a repeatable test that you could do. Me, I know which I prefer. If you can think of a better test for stability then putting the SAME blank on each lathe, and measuring the movement, I could like to hear it. The same can be said for the stall test. Now I might be able to come up with a better objective test for testing the tool rest, but at least it's a repeatable test.

I particularly liked their dissection of various lathes, knowing the Grizzly has such a wimpy belt drive and the GI uses a reducer on it's drive shaft are useful data points.

Is there a Nova owner out there that doesn't weight the base? I certainly don't know of any (and I own one)

As reviews go, it wasn't that bad. A nice follow up would be a review of the real monster lathes out there. The Robust, Vicmarc 300, Oneway 2436 and Stubby 750 would make an interesting read.

Re: Lathe article in FWW

#9

Re: Lathe article in FWW

Rob Steine

>Concur with previous comments�

Fine WoodWorking�s cover definitely caught my attention with the caption� Heavy-Duty Lathes, head to head. Even though the caption read� Heavy-Duty - I didn�t really expect the review to include lathes in the $4,000 plus price range, and most likely short bed lathes would be excluded.

Given their outstanding reputation for unbiased reporting, and attention to details, I figured this should be an outstanding review including - Oneway, Robust, Stubby, Vicmarc, Powermatic, and other major players.

However, I was extremely disappointed to discover that Fine WoodWorking�s editorial staff allowed the review of Heavy-Duty Lathes to exclude Oneway; stating� �Oneway wasn�t represented because it doesn�t make a lathe comparable in size and price with the others I tested�.

Certainly Oneway�s 1640 with 16� swing, 1 � HP, 40� Bed, and $3575 (catalogue list) is �comparable against� the Powermatic 3520B for $3,200, which was included.

OK, If you�re comparing lathes at $1,200; a price difference of $375 represents a significant 31%. However, the same $375 difference between a 1640 and a 3520B is less then 12%. That�s not much of an issue when you take into consideration � Mfg/Dealer Support, Quality, Features, Options, and other factors.

Fine WoodWorking�s position on this issue clearly represents a grave injustice to their subscribers, the woodturning community, Oneway, and other manufacturers intentionally excluded from the review. Establishing �cutoff criteria� that excludes Oneway by such a narrow margin shows extreme bias on their part, and significantly tarnishes their reputation and credibility.

I feel Fine WoodWorking has an obligation to the entire woodturning community to correct this injustice by publishing part 2 of this review within the next 3 to 4 months; not some nebulous response like� �Additional models well be reviewed in upcoming issues�.

Re: Lathe article in FWW

#10

Re: Lathe article in FWW

Ralph

>Bob

Might I recommend the you shop with a sharper pencil for the PM3520. Both Amazon and Craft Supplies list it at $2800, not $3200, so the price between a Oneway 1640 (@3575) and the PM 3520B is a little greater then you suggest

Re: Lathe article in FWW

#11

Re: Lathe article in FWW

Jason Clark

>I don't have the article in front of me but I believe the $3200 figure included the cost of the bed extension and one other accessory not included in the base package @ $2800.

Jason

Re: Lathe article in FWW

#12

Re: Lathe article in FWW

Ralph

>Jason, I have it here, and yes that could explain the cost. But comparing some other prices... The Nova 1624-44 is supposed to include the bed extension, but the price shown is about $100 less then the best price I know about. The Nova DVR-XP is shown with the out-board extension, but is certainly not priced with it (unless they got one heck of a deal).

Re: Lathe article in FWW

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Lathe article in FWW

keith tompkins

>I can't comment on the omission of certain lathes, but I can attest to the qualifications of Andy Barnum , who conducted the tests. I first met Andy through Brookfield Craft Center, where he ran the turning program for seventeen years. I have great respect for his turning skill, a great bowl turner and a master of the skew. Content to work behind the scenes, Andy was instrumental in the founding of the AAW, and organized one of the first (if not the first) AAW symposium at SUNY Purchase School of Art. He is a faculty member there as well. Anyone who has attended an Alan Lacer class has probably met Andy as well, as they are good friends and work together frequently. I wouldn't be a bit surprised if Andy taught Alan how to use the skew in the first place. Qualified? If Andy tells me something....I listen.

Re: Lathe article in FWW

#14

Re: Lathe article in FWW

wilbur

>Rob,

I'm not sure I would agree with your assessment of the Oneway 1640 being in the same class and price as the Powermatic 3520B. For the model that runs $3575, for the extra $375, you get 4" less swing and 1/2 less HP. The other 16x40 machines in the test were all in the $1600-2100 range, which is at least $1475 less than the Oneway.

If you move up to the Oneway with equivalent capacity and HP to the 3520B, you're talking about the Oneway 2036, which is $4945 with the 2 HP motor, which is $1745 more than the 3520B.

Now, I have no doubt that any of the Oneway models would be a better performer than the Powermatic. But it's not a fair statement to say that the two are in the same class and price range.

Re: Lathe article in FWW

#15

Re: Lathe article in FWW

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Ther AAW symposium at SUNY was in 1993 and was the seventh annual symposium.

Wally

Re: Lathe article in FWW

#16

"Heavy duty"?

Peter Teubel

>In addition to all the comments so far, I would add that I don't consider the Nova line of lathes "heavy duty". I've owned a DVR and used a 3000 extensivly. Fine lathes, to be sure, but I would classify them as medium duty lathes.

Re: Lathe article in FWW

#17

Re: Lathe article in FWW

Rob Steine

>With Ralph and Jason�s point noted - $3,200 is the price listed in the review for the Powermatic 3520B.

Perhaps the article should have been titled� Medium-Duty Lathes, head to head

I often find there are two thoughts or perspectives when evaluating products or tools� (Simplified something like�)

A) These are the Features or Specs I would like to have� So, what do I get by spending more money�? Better Quality� Other considerations� Etc.

B) I have this much money I can afford (justify) spending for this� What kind of tradeoffs are there between �feature specs� and other factors and considerations�?

I concur with Wilbur� The �specs� (Swing, HP, etc) for a 1640 and a 3520B are not exactly comparable, and I didn�t mean to imply they were in the same �Feature Class.� What I said was� �comparable against� By that I meant� I think it�s fair to compare a $3,200 lathe against a $3575 lathe, here�s why.

Is there a price difference� � Yes, but not that much of one. Are the �capacity specs� the same� � No, as Wilbur pointed, out most readers wouldn�t consider them in the same �Feature Class.� But these are easy to identify differences, that any reader can quickly determine from the manufacturer�s literature or web site.

For most of us, money is an object. So, other factors and tradeoff�s come into play. What are the differences in Warranty, Manufacturer Tech Support, availability of Parts, Quality, Fit and Finish. Optional feature available now, or those which can be added at a later date.

For example � Do your really think that all 2 HP (or all 1 � HP) motors from different manufacturers will perform �essentially the same�?� What about� Country of Origin; Warranty; Service Factor; Thermal overload protection; Variable speed controller; Controller programming and feature options, etc. �Claimed HP� vis-�-vis the �Effective Power� available for turning�

With these items and considerations identified, a consumer can make a more informed decision regarding the tradeoffs between �similarly priced� systems.

Re: Lathe article in FWW

#18

Re: A broad comparison study is ....

Jamie Donaldson

>... worthless without well defined parameters, and this is what was lacking in the FWW article. They should be inclusive of all available lathes within a category in order to draw relevant conclusions, especially when they are making recommendations of products based on their reputation as experts within a field.

Re: Lathe article in FWW

#19

Re: Lathe article in FWW - Did it's job

Patrick D

>Yeah, I have to take the other side of the coin here.

I wonder how the article would have come out if they

compared the given lathes with a high-end lathe like

the oneway. On a spec-for-spec vs cost basis, it would

be a hard sell. On long term quality, precision, etc

it might have won out, but those qualities are hard

to document. Lets see: Grizzly vs Oneway?

Before this article came out, I was all set to get the

Jet 1442 on sale last weekend. After reading this, I

"upgraded" to the Jet1642 mainly because of the variable speed

feature. For a cost(on sale)/feature perspective this came

out on top for me. The only "feature" I see missing is

a method for external tool rest for large turnings.

The review on this site, also helped me make the decision.

So coming at this from the "bottom feeding" point of view,

I found the comparison useful. I also considered the NOVA,

but couldn't justify the price given that I would want the

variable speed, extra bed, etc etc etc.

Should have it by the weekend, so I let you'all know

how it works out.