Re: Lathe article in FWW
Rob Steine
>Concur with previous comments�
Fine WoodWorking�s cover definitely caught my attention with the caption� Heavy-Duty Lathes, head to head. Even though the caption read� Heavy-Duty - I didn�t really expect the review to include lathes in the $4,000 plus price range, and most likely short bed lathes would be excluded.
Given their outstanding reputation for unbiased reporting, and attention to details, I figured this should be an outstanding review including - Oneway, Robust, Stubby, Vicmarc, Powermatic, and other major players.
However, I was extremely disappointed to discover that Fine WoodWorking�s editorial staff allowed the review of Heavy-Duty Lathes to exclude Oneway; stating� �Oneway wasn�t represented because it doesn�t make a lathe comparable in size and price with the others I tested�.
Certainly Oneway�s 1640 with 16� swing, 1 � HP, 40� Bed, and $3575 (catalogue list) is �comparable against� the Powermatic 3520B for $3,200, which was included.
OK, If you�re comparing lathes at $1,200; a price difference of $375 represents a significant 31%. However, the same $375 difference between a 1640 and a 3520B is less then 12%. That�s not much of an issue when you take into consideration � Mfg/Dealer Support, Quality, Features, Options, and other factors.
Fine WoodWorking�s position on this issue clearly represents a grave injustice to their subscribers, the woodturning community, Oneway, and other manufacturers intentionally excluded from the review. Establishing �cutoff criteria� that excludes Oneway by such a narrow margin shows extreme bias on their part, and significantly tarnishes their reputation and credibility.
I feel Fine WoodWorking has an obligation to the entire woodturning community to correct this injustice by publishing part 2 of this review within the next 3 to 4 months; not some nebulous response like� �Additional models well be reviewed in upcoming issues�.