Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

steel sharpness

Posts

steel sharpness

#1

steel sharpness

eliot d

>Will some of the newer steels that retain a sharp edge longer also take a sharper edge? Or does there tend to be an inverse relationship between how sharp you can get the edge and how long the edge will last?

Re: steel sharpness

#2

Brad Vietje

Re: steel sharpness

Brad Vietje

>Eliot,

My research into this suggests an inverse relationship, due to the "flakiness" or "graininess" of the crystalline structure of the different alloys... However, this is of very limited usefulness, for a very keen edge that lasts just a few passes may not be as useful as an edge that's nearly as sharp, but lasts 4 times longer. I admit to keeping a small carbon steel gouge for very fine detail work, or more difficult woods that don't cut smoothly. Might be mere superstition, though...

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: steel sharpness

#3

Re: steel sharpness

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>This is a good question... as of right now no one has made public the results of any testing. Off the grinder the new steels will hold an edge many times longer. When honed to a sharp angle the it might be different... I don't know.

Re: steel sharpness

#4

Re: steel sharpness

Gordon Seto

>I am interested to know whether there is such a relationship also.

But I think this won�t matter as much in turning tools as compared to the hand tool application. When we are turning a 3� round branch at 2~3000 R.P.M.; our tool has covered couple thousand feet of cutting in a minute. A lot of time, it may even include the abrasive bark. Our cutting width may not be as wide as the hand plane shaving, but they are a lot thicker. I think toughness and wear resistance properties are more important when we consider turning tools.

The best hand carving tools are still carbon steel that most turners have abandoned long time ago. A Pfiel carving chisel probably won�t last cutting a pommel as a turning tool.

Gordon

Re: steel sharpness

#5

Steve Kubien

Re: steel sharpness

Steve Kubien

>Hi Eliot,

There has been much debate over this sort of thing on the various handtool forums. Old Stanley irons vs O1 vs A2 vs who-knows-what. The debate gets deeper when people of speak sharpening techniques. Waterstones vs scary sharp vs Shaptons and I think that is where you need to look for sharper turning tools.

A gouge (or skew or whatever) sharpened on an 80 grit wheel will be "X" degree of sharp. At 120 grit, you got "X+y" degree of sharp. The steel doesn't matter at this point because it is the abrasive scratch pattern determining the level of sharpness. If you want a visibly sharper tool you must use a finer sharper medium (a 240 grit wheel, 1200 grit diamond hone for your skew etc). Think about a mirror-like reflection in the steel after you have honed and you are getting really close.

As Gordon said, an object can be turning at a lot of rpm's. On an 8" diameter bowl spinning at 500 rpm's, it is the equivalent of planing 1000 (!) lin ft of material (or there abouts. There is probably a mathematical equation which clearly defines this). Most neanderthals would gladly get 1000 lin ft of action out of their shoulder or block plane. On hard and tricky wood (birdseye maple) they would often be happy with 100 feet.

I think for most turners would benefit from edges which hold up longer. If you want an ultra-sharp (whatever that means) I would suggest have a dedicated gouge set aside for just that task (finely honed with a finer medium), kinda like a finishing plane. There may be a strong relationship between the newer alloys ability to retain and edge and take a finer edge but I doubt it is useful to turners. Curious? Yes. Useful? I doubt it.

My $1.25

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: steel sharpness

#6

Re: steel sharpness

John Lucas

>eliot I'm still trying to figure out a good test for this. I now have one of the Thompson powdered metal gouges. It used to be the thought was that the PM steel wouldn't sharpen as good as HSS or High carbon steel. My initial tests say that the Thompson steel will sharpen as good at least for turning purposes. I'm still testing mind you so don't use this as gospel.

I sharpened the 2 gouges on a 100 grit wheel and the HSS gouge defintly cut better. This last week I sharpened both on a 240 grit sanding belt. They both cut the same.

If I have time in the next couple of weeks I'm going to build a jib to use the wolverine on my sander and run the test more accurately and hopefull turn with each tool until it gets dull. I'm hoping to learn something from this. Until then the Jury is still out for me.

What I think I'm seeing so far is that the tools seem to sharpen equally well for turning applications but may need different sharpening grits to achieve the same results. This most likely has to do with the make up of the metal.

It has been proven that you can't sharpen carbide to the same level as HSS but that's a totally different material than powdered metal which has many different formulations and how it's made also affects all of it's parameters. So if my results are useful at all, they will only tell the story of one type of metal made by one guy.

Re: steel sharpness

#7

Re: steel sharpness

Bob Fawcett

>I think some of it has to do with your method of sharpening. This is the subject of another endless debate.

I have several gouges made from the newer steels, a Crown Pro PM, a Glaser, and a Thompson. I sharpen all my tools on an 80 grit Norton SG wheel. I haven't done any type of testing, but I don't percieve any difference in sharpness between M2 and any of the powdered metal tools. I can tell a difference in how long the edge lasts.

When it comes to the ultimate sharpness of the edge, you will find that knifemakers have a similar debate. They have devised numerous tests to decide which steels give the best edge. All of this is probably irrelevant to turning tools. As was said we cut thousands of feet in a turning session, and have very different requirements than other tools.

Re: steel sharpness

#8

Re: steel sharpness

Barry Turner

>I don't have any real evidence, but I swear I can get my new generation CET Glaser 5/8" bowl gouge sharper than any other gouge that I have. It is V-10 steel.

Barry

Re: steel sharpness

#9

Re: steel sharpness

Bob Fawcett

>Barry,

My Glaser is an older one that Jerry made so this may not apply, but I found that the sharpening angle on the cutting edge is more acute than any other I own. I measured it at about 25 degrees between the inside of the flute and the side of the gouge. I think this is why it seems sharper to you. Most of the others I have are around 30 - 35 from the maker.

Re: steel sharpness

#10

Mike Hunter

Re: steel sharpness

Mike Hunter

>I would like to challenge you on the sharpness of carbide tools. If you send me an email with your address, I will sent you a carbide cutter that is sharper than any HSS tool you have.

The tool is specifically designed for hollowing ... I'll sent you a tool for an evaluation.

Mike

Re: steel sharpness

#11

Re: steel sharpness

Russ Fairfield

>I will vouch for the sharpness of the carbide in Mikes tool. This ain't your normal grade of machine tool carbide. It is very sharp and very durable. How durable?? I used it for hollowing 31 goblets before Christmas last year and another 17 since then and haven't rotated the cutter because it is still sharp. How sharp is it? I can get a finish on dry figured Maple that is smooth enough most of the time to start sanding at 280-grit. Other than that, it cuts pretty well.

Re: steel sharpness

#12

Re: steel sharpness

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Cool, give us some information. I bet it's easy to use too.

Re: steel sharpness

#13

Re: steel sharpness

Fog Tanner

>I would have to agree with your statement. I worked in a shop which made carbide cutting tools. We mixed the carbide, pressed the powder into billets and then shaped the cutters before the firing. Afterwards these were ground on a surface ginder to dimension. I ran all of the various machines at different times and got to see the oepration. When I ran the surface grinder I could put a razor edge on the cutting tools with no problem. But I was using a diamond wheel, the only thing harder than the carbide. If you want to grind it in the shop, you have to have a "green" wheel to do any good and a diamond would be the best.

As far as the powder size, it was way finer than any grit you will find in a home workshop. The diamond wheels that we used were finer than the typical 80-100 grit in home use. The bits were already "shaped" when they were in the pressed powder form, and all that was required was shapening and the final thickness. I think it is just a matter of using the right equipment to achive a given edge.