Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Turning Post Observations

Posts

Turning Post Observations

#1

Keith Tompkins

Turning Post Observations

keith tompkins

>As the turning site moderator, I've been following the "observation" thread with some interest. Some valid points have been raised, and I offer a few suggestions that may be helpful.

First, if you post a pic of your work, especially if you've been a lurker, tell us a bit about yourself.....share your feelings about the piece being posted...what part gave you the most trouble, for example. Ask for a critique....many contributors on this site, including myself, won't get involved in "way to go!" or "good job", "I like it!" kind of reply. If you ask for a critique, in most cases you will receive a thoughtful reply. All too often, I see photos posted with several responses, yet the original poster doesn't even reply....opportunities to open up meaningful dialog are lost, and the chance to get to know some of the "regulars" is missed. If you don't care for the opinions you receive in a critique, share your feelings and opinions in a respectful manner...personal attacks have no place on this site, and won't be tolerated. A simple acknowledgement or word of thanks at the end of a post will go a long way to encourage future responses to your posts.

It is a fact that many of us here actually know one another. Not only do we communicate at this and similar forums, we see each other on a regular basis at symposiums, meetings, etc. Personally, I've known many turners who frequent this site for several years, and communicate with them on a regular basis. We all started as strangers, with different backgrounds and beliefs. What has brought us together was a passion for turning.....I've met some good friends through this site.

Sometimes, even people with similar interests will disagree....for example the "art v. craft" debate will fuel some heated debates. We must respect the opinions of others on this site, even if we totally disagree with their viewpoint. All turners are welcome here, newbies, lurkers, professional turners, even artsy turners who insist on painting their work.

Should we avoid the sticky topics? The emotional topics? The controversial topics? Absolutely NOT. If we choose to post only the "safe" questions, we will stop growing. Anybody who's posted here for a while remembers when the most controversial question was "what lathe should I buy?" Personally, I don't want to go backwards. Replies requested!! Come on, get involved!!

Re: Turning Post Observations

#2

Re: Turning Post Observations

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Keith,

Well stated and I for one can say that even though I do not post a wide variety of turnings (Mostly a variety of pens lately) that I do enjoy reading this and all the other forums on WC.

The turning commuinity is unique in some ways, the dialog I read here is helpful for me and I find also the directions that people take once they have become engaged at the site is always in a positive direction.

If I look back at some people's first posted works here and see where they are now I know that the support and encouragement through constructive critiques and requests for help have proven benificial to all who have looked in.

I think that as all forums change with time some things grow and it's always a chance to learn, even for those who have many more years at the tool rest than I do for sure....

Even friends can disagree on details and topics...but we can all learn that each has value and respect the differences.

A timely post Keith, hope all is well in your neck of the woods.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Turning Post Observations

#3

Re: Turning Post Observations

John Veerkamp

>I agree Keith. Even though I don't post many pics(limited speed dial-up} I enjoy the forum and learn a lot from informed critiques.

On a related subject, we need to get some more participation and re-vitalize the turning chat. Last Wed there were only a few of us and that petered out within 1/2 hour. I know getting a moderator is a problem, but maybe there is someone out there who can step in for a term.

JohnV

Re: Turning Post Observations

#4

Re: Turning Post Observations

Ed Moore

>Hi Keith,

I began by reading your post and its replies and then I read the entire Observations thread. And my conclusion is that "nailshooter", or Robbert Witte, said rather well what I have thought. There is a clique which dominates sometimes and is rather self-contained. And what was intended as a harmless question about the gift exchange and lurkers really did some damage and hurt some people. (Not me, because I don't deal well with inequities or one way streets, so I chose not to participate.)

For me one of the stickiest wickets is good turning versus embellishments. Let me say at the outset that I love your circle of fish, the work of the late Frank Sudol and of Binh Pho, the mineral inlays of Stephen Hatcher, the painting of Susan Rosand on Bob's work, and the many pieces with vibrant colors on them by several people. But I am developing a problem with over-carved pieces that show no indication of having been turned. Such pieces seem to evoke lots of Oohs and Aahs while some beautiful well-executed pieces which are not embellished get no response. In other words, I think we have earned some of the criticism of being snobs that gets mentioned in hushed tones.

Ed

Re: Turning Post Observations

#5

Re: Turning Post Observations

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Keith, that was certainly well said; thank you. :-)

Re: Turning Post Observations

#6

Steve Kubien

Re: Turning Post Observations

Steve Kubien

>Some excellent points Keith. I especially like your suggestions for us when we post a picture. I for one will try to follow that example. As far as "sensitive" debates are concerned...I usually follow them somewhat but try not to get involved. Being politically correct without getting right in someone's face is not my strongest suit.

Cheers,

Steve Kubien

Re: Turning Post Observations

#7

Re: Turning Post Observations

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>All very well said Keith. I for one, don't post nearly as much as I once did. Fact is, I was often in the "top 10" of posters. Like you, I seldom get into the "attaboy" posts on pics unless it's something unusual that I really like. More than once I've had a bad reaction when I really offered a critique on a piece that I didn't like. I sometimes offer a critique via email rather than pick a piece apart in a post.

I do enjoy following some of the lengthy threads on a controversial subject. I sometimes offer an opinion but usually don't.

I think that my pet peeve is the person who asks a question or asks for an opinion then is never heard from again. If people take the time to answer a question, sometimes in lengthy detail, they should at least receive a thank you.

Keith, when you welcomed all turners "even artsy turners who insist on painting their work", I assume that was tongue-in-cheek. I seem to recall some painted fish a while back. I would love to see posts by some of the best at coloring their work, such as Don Derry, Giles Gilson or Andi Wolfe.

Wally

Re: Turning Post Observations

#8

Our turning club has the same bias

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Ed,

You mentioned the response that embellished turnings get. It is exactly the same way in our turning club (Badger Woodturners). It is especially noticeable when there is a challenge and people get to vote for their favorite turning. The more embellished the turning, the better chance it has of winning. Form seems to count for nothing unless the shape is absolutely awful.

Re: Turning Post Observations

#9

Re: Turning Post Observations

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>There may be a clique here on WC but I really don't see it that way. If the people who are regularly in the "top 10" stopped posting there would just about be no action here at all. If that happened most of us would stop visiting and the whole thing would fall apart. After a period of time the frequent posters seem to nearly disappear and others take their place. Most of the frequent posters today are fairly new to WC.

I attended the very first AAW symposium in Lexington, Ky. in 1987. Nearly all of the pieces in the instant gallery were plain open bowls with quite a few natural-edge and just a few simple hollowforms. What has evolved since then is nothing short of incredible. When I walk through an instant gallery today I'm amazed at what I see. I don't necessarily like all of the pieces I see, but I still have to admire the inspiration, the planning and the skill that it took to produce them. I do tend to nearly overlook some of the beautiful but more traditional pieces simply because I've seen them all before. The changes will continue whether we like if or not.

Wally

Re: Turning Post Observations

#10

Steven Antonucci

Since I originally stirred this pot up...

steve antonucci

>I agree with everything you've posted. My original intent was to "bring back the masses" that seemed to be around during the "Turning Exchange debate", since the flurry of activity seemed to have subsided.

We all have something to contribute. My point was that if you want to have input, you need to have output. I too tend to shy away from the "attaboy" posts, but every once in a while, I'll say one when I truly have nothing else to say.

Case in point- Bruce (forget the last name) recently posted a hollow through the bottom thin neck piece, and I loved it, but had a question/comment about the photo. If I didn't have that question, I probably wouldn't have said anything.

Paul Porter recently posted a NE hollowform where all I had to say was "Wow". Different day, different mood. We can't all comment on every post, but we can all contribute something to the Forum.

Let's not be too busy to make this a better place.

Steven

Re: Turning Post Observations

#11

Brad Vietje

Re: Turning Post Observations

Brad Vietje

>Well said, Keith,

I have been away from turning a lot lately, leaving one career and starting another -- plus it's still acting like winter here, and my shop area is still unheated. Reflecting on the comments below, I'm especially struck by the comments of Screwshooter, Rick Davenport, and Russ Fairfield. Since the thread has essentially jumped here, I'll respond here as well.

I think in some ways, Screwshooter is right that there has been an evolution here, even over my 4-year (?) tenure, but I certainly don't think it has become an elitist back-slapping clique, or that all the changes have been for the worse. I have noted a few people using a pretty abrasive writing style, however.

I'm saddened to read that Rick doesn't want to post his work here. I've been away so much that I missed the nested bowls referred to in the discussion, but having searched them out, they are pieces I'd be very happy to own, and very nice work !

Russ, as usual, hits the nail on the head. Our lives ebb and flow, and so does our participation on the WC turning forum. I have been in the "Top 10" (based on # of posts, I gather) quite a few times in the past 3 years, but I've recently opened a business and changed careers, so I have not had the time for turning or on-line turning groups that I once did. If turning was my livelihood, or if I were retired, I might have been around to comment a lot more.

Glad to have a few hours to catch up with some turning friends,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Turning Post Observations

#12

Brad Vietje

Nuther thing...

Brad Vietje

>I just scrolled down and looked at a few more posts, and realized that I almost never reply to a post involving segmented work. Since I don't do that sort of work, I don't feel I have anything helpful to add, other that the occasional "ohmygodthatsfabulous" sort of awe-struck comment. I don't even really understand how most segmented pieces are made... I'm also pretty confident that Malcolm Tibbets will be fine if I don't critique his latest piece -- and I'm happy to learn from those with more intelligent comments than mine.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Turning Post Observations

#13

Brian and Wally ...

Ed Moore

>The AAW Forum, WC, and WoW tend to run together a little after awhile and I may be extrapolating a bit and ascribing characteristics of one or more to all. Don't get me wrong - I like most everyone I encounter on these forums and have a lot of respect for most. We have all seen some really nice work get ignored and have seen Oohs and Aahs over work of questionable value. This happens. But a recent posting of an overcarved piece somewhere that in no way resembles or should be regarded as turning got a lot of attention. While I am a strong believer that there should be lots of room at the table, I feel that calling this piece a turning requires a logical stretch that is beyond my capacity. Okay, I'm off the soap-box.

Smith Mountain Lake Woodturners was at the embryonic stage around the beginning of 2004. Contributions at SMLW Christmas parties in 2004, 2005 and 2006 have shown a very satisfying improvement in the level of turning each year. So I can relate to Wally's comments about the Instant Gallery at the AAW - which I saw for the first time in Louisville last June. Incredible.

The social dynamics of a forum will probably make a great thesis for some student sometime somewhere. I regard Keith's comments as being directed towards encouraging lurkers to toughen up a little and become contributors. And I support his efforts. My comments were intended to remind us that not all of the problems will evaporate just because we want them to do so. Strong friendships are the normal product of such activities. I regard the cliques that I observe on WC as loosely formed, benign, and not malicious.

Ed

Re: Turning Post Observations

#14

Re: Turning Post Observations

john lucas

>I agree Wally. I've seen so many hollow forms and bowls I'm simply kind of bored with them. I still look, and can really appreciate one that has the perfect form that works with the figure in the wood.

I like to look at the new work because it's fascinating. I like to try and figure out how it's done. If it has a theme enjoy learning what the turner has to say, even if it's mostly carved.

I don't always write about every piece that is posted simply because I don't always have anything to say or I'm just to busy to stop. I do look, and I do enjoy them. I try to remember the names so I can look at thier new work later and see how it changes. Even new turners have someting to say with thier work. We just have to be open to what they have to say.

Re: Turning Post Observations

#15

Re: Just remember that friends and ....

Jamie Donaldson

>...family should not debate religion or politics!!!Most everything else is fair game!

Re: Turning Post Observations

#16

And to some, turning and carving are ...

Ed Moore

>religions. ;^D

Ed

Re: Turning Post Observations

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Turning Post Observations

keith tompkins

>Thanks everyone for your responses. It's easy to see from just a few responses how varied our interests are. I think the most important consideration should be...am I happy with the turnings that I produce? If not, how can I improve? Am I willing to stick my neck out to attempt something new and different?

There seems to be a growing conflict between the artsy turners and the pure bowl turners. I don't know the solution to the problem, but we should all learn to appreciate each other's work. Personally, many of my pieces are criticized by others as NOT being turnings...they believe pieces such as the ones I create have no place in displays of turnings. I'll leave that arguement for another day, but I am content knowing I'm using all of the skills I've developed...the lathe is not the only piece of equipment at my disposal. Yes, too many embellished turnings seem to get all the attention, while great pure turnings languish on the sidelines. Any one in the position of judging events where the pieces are grouped together should understand the basics of good design. An embellished form with poorly executed design should be judged very harshly.

When I talk about design considerations in my turning demos, I refer to some turnings as having a dynamic quality about them. These are the pieces that generate interest, and inspire others to try new ideas. That's the way things work, and this site is no different. If we don't advance, try new ideas, move forward, we will stagnate. If we all rejected change, there would be no computers, no air travel, no television, no advances in medicine. We would all still be turning only bowls and chair spindles. Or clubs.

Re: Turning Post Observations

#18

Bill Blasic

Re: Turning Post Observations

Bill Blasic

>I do not understand why this fraternity of turners feels compeled to label those who do not contribute on a daily basis as LURKERS. I personally feel that this is a dirty word. Just because a person does not jump in at every turn does not mean that they are not learning something every time they sign in to this site. Makes no difference to me if it is plain wood, colored wood or carved wood, they are ideas and inspirations from which I learn. Just because a person is not commenting on every subject does not mean they are not participating in the ebb and flow of this site. I don't believe a label furthers the goals of this or any other site. When a picture or a topic stirs the fires people will respond, giving them labels retards any output.

Re: Turning Post Observations

#19

Re: Turning Post Observations

Ron in Drums PA

>Lurker is not a dirty word.

It's been used a long time on the internet for someone who just reads and rarely posts. don't take offense.

---Trivia---

The word geek (as in computer geek) originally was a person who bit heads off chickens in a carnival show.

There was a time that being a nerd wasn't cool.

Re: Turning Post Observations

#20

Re: Turning Post Observations

Don O.

>As usual Keith, another thoughtful, thought-inspiring discussion topic. I agree with your take on this. I don't respond to very many posts but I check into the site nearly every day. It has been quite a resource for education, inspiration, motivation, perspiration and more. While I don't really embellish my pieces, I can appreciate the time, talent, skill, planning, etc. that are involved in producing the more elaborate pieces. Maybe someday I will be inspired to try and incorporate some of the techniques I see here and on other sites. I also very much appreciate a well turned bowl or hollow vessel or box or pen or whatever. I don't usually offer comments because I don't feel qualified as a critic. I also don't really like to just respond with "Nice", or "Good Job". I don't think it really helps anyone. I'm still working on producing consistently good form myself but have a lot to learn yet.

I think the most important point you make is to be respectful and polite in our posts. So much of our society has lost those concepts. The internet seems to give some people artificial courage to bash others needlessly. I have no problem with different opinions, that's how we learn. How we present them in a thoughtful, respectful, polite manner can make all the difference in how they are percieved. This a great site and a wonderful forum and it is up to us to keep it that way. Aren't we all here for the same reason-we love turning wood and seeing turned wood and learning ???

And thanks for your efforts on our behalf. I know you have had to deal with some less-than-pleasant issues.

Re: Turning Post Observations

#21

Old Saying

Jimmy Edwards

>man don't know what a man don't know." Therefore, the vast importance of these forums. I don't think anyone could just go buy a lathe and some tools and turn out beautiful work. Each beginner must have information to go the distance. These forums are the ultimate source of that information. I've learned from chainsawing to finishing from these forums, and everything in between. Every question I've asked on a forum have had multiple responses and solutions. What I need now is the how to on posting pictures. Once I learn that I'll go from a lurker to a bona fide participant. P.S. We should post pictures of our screwups as well as the good results. Thanks a million you guys.

Re: Turning Post Observations

#22

Re: Old Saying

Jimmy Edwards

>Should read granddad used to say "A man don't know what a man don't know". A Confucious type thing.