Re: High Speed Steel question
Chuck Engstrom
>Hi Joe -- I am no expert in metallurgy but my understanding of these matters goes like this:
"High speed steel" (HSS) is called that because its recipe of ingredients (so to speak) allows it to keep its cutting qualities at the higher temperatures generated by high speed cutting operations in working metal. Most common varieties of HSS seem to be M-2 (most woodturning tools), M4, and M-42. Heat treatment of HSS requires pretty sophisticated equipment and controls impractical for typical DIYers.
The oil-, air-, and water-hardening steels are more amenable to home heat treatment, especially oil-hardening. But even so, they will not give you tools that hold up to woodturning the way HSS tools do. I don't know anything about the 4142 but suspect that it would fall into the same category.
Beyond HSS, there are the fancy particle metal steels like the A10 and V15 of the Glaser tools, the 2030 and 2060 of the Hamlet line, and Crown's Pro-PM. These involve sophisticated production and heat treatment processes but they do give tools whose edges will last longer than standard HSS.
The MSC catalogue spells out much of the composition and heat treatment information for M2 as well as those you mentioned. You may have to poke around a bit to find it all; for the M2, look up "drill rod" in the index. My MSC catalogue is several years old so my page numbers probably wouldn't be current.
Best--
Chuck Engstrom