Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

High Speed Steel question

Posts

High Speed Steel question

#1

High Speed Steel question

Joe Donohue

>I would like to purchase some 1/8" flat stock to cut up for cutting bits. The MSC catalog lists oil hardening, water hardening and pre-hardened 4142 stock. Are these considered high speed steel? If not, what is the correct terminology?

Re: High Speed Steel question

#2

Re: High Speed Steel question

Chuck Engstrom

>Hi Joe -- I am no expert in metallurgy but my understanding of these matters goes like this:

"High speed steel" (HSS) is called that because its recipe of ingredients (so to speak) allows it to keep its cutting qualities at the higher temperatures generated by high speed cutting operations in working metal. Most common varieties of HSS seem to be M-2 (most woodturning tools), M4, and M-42. Heat treatment of HSS requires pretty sophisticated equipment and controls impractical for typical DIYers.

The oil-, air-, and water-hardening steels are more amenable to home heat treatment, especially oil-hardening. But even so, they will not give you tools that hold up to woodturning the way HSS tools do. I don't know anything about the 4142 but suspect that it would fall into the same category.

Beyond HSS, there are the fancy particle metal steels like the A10 and V15 of the Glaser tools, the 2030 and 2060 of the Hamlet line, and Crown's Pro-PM. These involve sophisticated production and heat treatment processes but they do give tools whose edges will last longer than standard HSS.

The MSC catalogue spells out much of the composition and heat treatment information for M2 as well as those you mentioned. You may have to poke around a bit to find it all; for the M2, look up "drill rod" in the index. My MSC catalogue is several years old so my page numbers probably wouldn't be current.

Best--

Chuck Engstrom

Re: High Speed Steel question

#3

Re: High Speed Steel question

Lan Brady

>Joe,

Look under "tool Bits".

This is probably what you are looking for.

You will not find 36" pieces but they are already hardened and tempered.

They will ship it in 2 days! good people.

Lan

Re: High Speed Steel question

#4

Re: Joe and Lan..........

Allen Neighbors

>Joe, I just placed an order with wttool.com for some cutters that are supposed to be harder than M2 steel, that contain 5% cobalt.

Product number:2219-0005 1/8" x 1/8" x 2.5" 5% cobalt, Ground Square Tool Bits... $1.50 each.

Lan, the drill rod I ordered is 3/16"dia x 36"long, and is untempered. They told me that the tempering instructions accompanied the rod. I hope so. I think it can be tempered in our Kitchen Oven,and quenched in oil. Don't know for sure.

Re: High Speed Steel question

#5

Re: Joe and Lan..........

Joe Donohue

>Thank you for that information.

It seems that HSS tool bits are mostly square or rectangular in cross section. I was hoping to find 1/8" HSS flat stock to use in my Basham tools.

I have been cuting up jointer and planer blades to make the scrapers and that works fine. I was looking for a generic way to buy flat HSS. - Hoping they would be a bit less expensive than packaged planer blades.

Joe

Re: High Speed Steel question

#6

Leo Van Der Loo

some planer knives make good tool bids !!

Leo Van Der Loo

>

Re: High Speed Steel question

#7

Re: Joe and Lan..........

eliot d

>I picked up a used jointer blade with the intent to make some shear scrapers. But now I realize that I have no idea how to cut it up. How is it done? Can I score it on my grinder and break it along the score line?

Re: High Speed Steel question

#8

Re: Call Frank Lynn at (360) 425-4649

Russ Fairfield

>Frank is in Kelso, WA, and he has been selling HSS planer blades and tools for many years. Give him a call. You will be glad you did.

Re: High Speed Steel question

#9

Re: Joe and Lan..........

Lan Brady

>Joe,

My second place to buy flat stock is Harborfreight.com

I buy this group(ITEM 40641-2VGA) of bits to use in differnt ways. The flat piece is 3/32" though, so it may not fit your needs.

Good luck, Lan

Re: High Speed Steel question

#10

Steve Kubien

Have you considered...

Steve Kubien

>...annealing and old file, shaping it the way you want it to be, hardening it and then tempering it? Done right it may make a serviceable tool for you at next to no cost. Might be an option and you get to play with open flame too!

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: High Speed Steel question

#11

Re: Planer Blade cutters

Andy Blackwell

>Joe:

The Basham cutters used to be made from planer blades. I used the tools while working with Bill Johnson. Upon returning to VA I had a metal shop write a program for me that allowed them to take my used planer blades and laser cut blanks to fit the Basham tool. You can grind the blanks to the shape that you like for the turning you are doing. 6 planer blades produced a lifetime supply for me.

Re: High Speed Steel question

#12

Re: What is a Basham tool??

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: High Speed Steel question

#13

Re: What is a Basham tool??

Jim Terry

>Jamie, They are tools made by Al Basham, a woodturner from NC. Go to:

http://www.albasham.com/catalog/

Jim

Re: High Speed Steel question

#14

Re: Joe and Lan..........

Joe Donohue

>Lan, that's a great lead for HSS blanks. We have a HF here in Reno and I'll pick up a set or 2.

The Basham tool takes 1/8" thick stock though. I might be stuck with cutting up planer blades. My miserly heart was looking for a cheaper alternative.

Joe

Re: High Speed Steel question

#15

Re: Joe and Lan..........

Joe Donohue

>I have had luck just scoring them and breaking them off in a vice. To be safe, I cover them with a towel. I'm sure small pieces could fly off.

Joe

Re: High Speed Steel question

#16

Re: Call Frank Lynn at (360) 425-4649

Joe Donohue

>I'll call him in the morning Russ. Thanks for the lead.

Joe

Re: High Speed Steel question

#17

Re: Joe and Lan..........

Bart Castleberry

>Get a cut off wheel for your grinder Norton A60 OBNA2 1/32 or 1/16 Get them at MSC, WT, etc Not my idea, Bob Vaughan's but they work really slick for cutting steel, esp HSS.

Re: High Speed Steel question

#18

Re: Call Frank Lynn at (360) 425-4649

Joe Donohue

>Russ, thanks for this great lead.

Frank is a great guy to work with and I'll probably do business with him. Unfortunatley, his HSS is thicker than 1/8" and won't fit the Basham tool.

Guess I'll just go back to 1/8" jointer and planer blades.

Joe Donohue