Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

Posts

OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

#1

Steven Antonucci

OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

steve antonucci

>I've noticed over the past few weeks, that the initial flurry of activity from the "Great Lurker Debate" seems to have died back down. In the days of yore, it was almost impossible to respond to every topic as everyone began posting their work and questions, but now it seems tere might be 5-8 new threads per day only.

In looking over many of the posts, as well as my prior post w.r.t. the my sister in law's "enormous ash" (tee-hee, she'd kill me if she knew I said that!), I've noticed the following:

1.) If you want to get a lot of people to view your post, put a picture on it. People will click it to see what you've posted, regardless of the topic or their intent to contribute. My ash post had 600+ views, but only ~5 comments.

2.) If you want someone to comment on you posts, you almost need to comment on all of theirs as well. I attribute this the fact that no one likes to be ignored, and if we post and don't get a conversation started, then it's almost like saying that the topic is unimportant. If tangents happen, or if it gets heated, so what. The value of the forum is that we all learn- I learn nothing by talking, and everything by listening.

Now, I've been busy the last week or so, but I've got to go leave some comments on some of the pretty pictures I've seen...

Steve

p.s. observation #3 is that when the pot gets stirred, everyone's a chef...

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

#2

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controvers

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>Another observation, Steve.

What's a lurker to do when everyone lurks and no one posts!

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

#3

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controvers

Carole Valentine

>With my current situation (family illness) I barely have time to check in once in a while, much less post. Turning? What's that? Also, this time of year is historically slow on the boards.

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

#4

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controvers

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>We're glad when you pop in whenever you do, Carole. I was responding to Steve's numbers about 600 views and 5 posts. Another way to look at that is that 595 people were interested enough to read the post, wise enough to know they had nothing to add, and so posted nothing. The other 5 had something to add and probably something of value to add as well.

Frankly, if I got 600 posts back on one of my posts, I wouldn't get anything else done! :)

You mind your Mom. We'll be happy when we hear from you.

And Steve, many happy returns! :)))

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

#5

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controvers

Mike Cunningham (Cape May)

>I think your observations are correct. I would also add that there are 8 or 10 people that always post replies to one anothers messages, regardless of the topic and often ignore, well don't respond I should say, to others. I don't know that this impacts upon what lurkers do, but I think that it does have an effect on those that are sometime regulars or have attempted to become regular posters.....just an observation.

Mike

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

#6

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controvers

Troy German

>I just assumed that because the weather is breaking around the country that people are spending more time in thier shops and have less time to post. Still, I'm continually impressed with the liveliness and helpfulness of this forum.

I know I feel priviliged every time some shares thier pictures, questions, comments or thoughts.

Thanks for your thoughts,

Troy

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

#7

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controvers

Rick Davenport

>I find WoodCentral to be a valuable learning resource and will continue to enjoy its benefits.

But I won't post any more pictures.

Even with specific requests for comments and hundreds of views and responding sincerely to each comment, I consistently get only 1 or 2 comments per post.

I hate indifference.

I will continue to watch and learn.

Thank you to everyone who participates.

We all benefit.

Rick

"Life shouldn't be dull."

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

#8

Re: Rick- by not posting photos.you..

Jamie Donaldson

>... are contributing to the indifference you hate! Where would WC be if everyone shared your indifference??

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

#9

Re: Rick- by not posting photos.you..

Rick Davenport

>I contribure and make comments when I can.

I just don't post my work here any more.

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

#10

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controvers

Mike Cunningham (Cape May)

>Hi Rick,

See my reply just above. I know several people who have not only stopped posting photos, but have stopped posting altogether for the reason that you mention here and that I touch on above.

Mike

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

#11

Re: Lurker Opinion

C.W.Stivison

>I don't post many photos because latley they have all been ending up in the firewood box but if it will help my image I can post a picture of the firewood box (LOL)to show that I've have been trying turning things.

I don't respond to most post but I am on WC every day. It is a great place to learn. If I see a post by Mr.Lucas, Jamie or one of the WC ladies I will always read those, but I don't read every post.Heck I have even been in the chat room.

Lurking In southern Ohio.

CW

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

#12

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controvers

Kirk (KC) Constable

>Your comments can be observed at woodworking site. I've noticed it as well.

KC

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

#13

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controvers

Troy German

>Rick,

I searched for your last picture post and believe that you have a legitimate grievance. It�s too bad that your natural edge, nested, burl bowls only got one response. I would like to apologize for my part in that. I enjoyed viewing that picture when you posted it, and although I wasn�t able to post a thoughtful response at that time, I could have at least thanked you for posting. I�m sorry.

Also, I would like to urge you to reconsider your choice not to post more pictures here. I enjoy seeing your work, and the forum is richer for having it.

Thank you for you thoughts,

Troy

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

#14

Turning Posts - a long, personal observation

nailshooter

>Hmmm...

Years ago this was a vibrant community of turners of all stripes and experience level. I am not sure what name I posted under then as I have changed ISPs a few times, and the old names wouldn't work for some reason that now escapes me. I posted a lot then and enjoyed the comraderie and the great exchange of information.

Other interests and many health issues with ailing parents chewed up all my free time, and my turning went to just about zero. So when things stabilized with them around the fall of this last year, I thought I would turn up some well seasoned wood and once again present Christmas ornaments, clocks, ring trees, mallets and all the other easy to turn stuff I used to give as gifts.

So I remembered how great this forum was years ago, and how much fun it was to participate and I thought I would reaquaint myself with the group. It was apparent that things had really changed. Reading a few hundred posts to catch up, it was really obvious this group has become quite clanish. While some responses are still great, many are quite curt. And if you are an unknown here, you are easily ignored.

To drive this point home to me, I was disgusted with the tone taken by many on the turning exchange this last year. I couldn't believe the discussions about who was worthy of what work, who should actually get it someone else's work, what quality should be sent, etc. Questions were asked along the lines of "if someone doesn't post a lot, how serious could they be towards the group?" and "how do I know how serious they are about woodturning?" They were obviously more worried about their finely crafted work falling into the hands of some beginner than thinking that it could be a prized and treasured piece that could inspire for years.

Cutting through all the bogus reasoning, the message was clear: we only want to trade with those that are our known friends that will send us something of equal value. I was thinking while reading this, why don't the organizers make the participants submit samples, judge the quality of work and the value of the piece and then categorize them so that the clan folks would only get something from the other clan folks. My goodness, you would hate to get something that someone worked their butts off on that you considered not worthy.

As for me, with all the things I have turned, sold, and gifted, I have something that I got from a turner in Houston in 1997 at the old Texas Turn or Two. Having no luck with the skew at all, he worked with me diligently for about an hour and a half. I hadn't been turning but for about a year or so, and before that it was well over 20 since I turned candlesticks in high school. Together, we made a whistle. The long kind mimicing the old Bobbies whistle. We turned it smooth with him at my elbow lifting the whole way, and I turned a ball on the end. And you know what? It is my most prized turning. I could turn one now in literally 5 minutes on any of my lathes. But that one is special... that one inspires good work and good treatment of others along this path.

If you want to really pull into focus how hard the winds of change have blown, search the archives and see how many familiar names you see that post here now. Look at the articles and reviews - how many familiar names do you see? How many have stuck around? Not having stayed with this group over the last couple of years, it was a real surprise to see how much the overall tone of the group had changed since I didn't see it develop, I got it all at once.

Rather than the old spirit of really helpful encouragement, it was quickly obvious that a smaller, tightknit group of people have formed a mutual admiration society that isn't really too interested in new faces or the work of others. Sadly, like all newsgroups or forums, without that new blood it will die. New faces mean sometimes exciting ideas and techniques. They provide the satisfaction of passing along some of the things that were learned at the hands of others as well as by personal experimentation. On the turning NG, there was a neat little post on how to make a homemade steb center for about 3 bucks. Right now it seems that the group regulars kindly tolerate the work of others (although there are still some great folks out here), and simply gush when one of theirs post something.

And have you noticed how all here seem to strive for the same shapes? There are accepted shapes with some variations, and the clan pretty much turns within those confines.

I see a more free exchange of ideas and thoughts on the newsgroups. There I post freely between the woodworking and woodturning groups, shoot pictures of work to others, and get some back in exchange. It is a less polite group at times, but I like the open door policy for all skill levels alot. I have been a professional speicalty carpentry contractor for about 30 years, most of that self employed. And yet, I still learn from some of my guys that have been doing it for a couple of years (read: noobs or lesser skilled - hint, hint). They discover new processes simply because they don't know how to do something the "accepted" way or because their enthusiasm leads them to a whole new technique or idea. And it seems a little silly to me to see attitude, spoken or unspoken from some here I can recall as "just starting the addiction".

Last year I posted about 600-650 messages to just two newsgroups, and not sure how many this year, so participation in these venues is a hobby of mine and something I enjoy. The woodworking group alone gets somewhere in the many thousands of messages every month, and you read the threads you are interested in, or when you can offer help to others. Yup, some politics, some OT discussions, but they are usually well marked (and good to stay away from!). The point being there are lots of interested folks out there exploring all the different crafts, so I think the group's destiny is actually in its own hands. The environment here will certainly be the key to that.

It will be interesting to see where this forum ends up.

Robert L. Witte

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

#15

Re: Why is it controversial??

Russ Fairfield

>Why is it controversial to point out that this forum has changed over time? If it hadn't changed, it would no longer be here. The fact that it is still here is a testament to its being a dynamic forum that could adapt to the changing times and changing people.

Rather than micro-manage the numbers, look at the overall growth of this forum. 7 years ago this forum was lucky to have 5 messages on a good day, and weekends were read. I remember being ecstatic when we reached a goal of 50 messages in a single day. Look at the "Top 10" list. That list has changed. The people who were at the top of the list last year are no longer there. I would guess that the list will change in another year, just as the names I see here every day are constantly changing.

Of course there is a core group who has been here longer than anyone else. Of course they tend to gather around and talk to each other. That is the very nature of any social group. If we want a different group, we can join a different forum. At last count there were 17 of them to choose from.

Enjoy the change. Without it, there would be no Turning Message Board here on Wood Central.

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

#16

Give me a break !

Ron in Drums PA

>

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

#17

ebd

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controvers

ebd

>I'm glad you posted this. I for sure don't read every post and I only respond when I have something to add, which isn't often. I seldom notice who originates the post. The subject draws my attention. One thing I don't think I've ever done is post pictures of my work. I guess there are a few reasons. While I handle criticism well I have a hard time with compliments. Also, posting pictures of what I've done makes me feel like I'm "showboating". I've never been one to go out of my way to get attention. After reading this thread I've come to the conclusion that perhaps I should try to get over it and start posting some pictures. I'll post a picture of my favorite piece in another thread.

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

#18

Thanks Troy

Rick Davenport

>

Re: OT:Turning Posts observations(maybe controversial)

#19

Re: Very interesting, Robert.

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks for posting. Could be that this thread might spark some changes for the better on this forum, and I, for one, appreciate your opinion.

Just getting everyone to really think about their contributions to WC's turning forum could improve things somewhat. When the thread you mentioned about the turner's exchange was started, it was without malice, (I'm positive of that) but it did get some things out into the open, and it did get some of those who mostly just lurked to make some posts, and that in itself has contributed to the betterment of the craft/art, and this forum. I've learned some things from, and have been inspired by, some of those new posters.

Blessings to you.

Allen Neighbors