Turning Posts - a long, personal observation
nailshooter
>Hmmm...
Years ago this was a vibrant community of turners of all stripes and experience level. I am not sure what name I posted under then as I have changed ISPs a few times, and the old names wouldn't work for some reason that now escapes me. I posted a lot then and enjoyed the comraderie and the great exchange of information.
Other interests and many health issues with ailing parents chewed up all my free time, and my turning went to just about zero. So when things stabilized with them around the fall of this last year, I thought I would turn up some well seasoned wood and once again present Christmas ornaments, clocks, ring trees, mallets and all the other easy to turn stuff I used to give as gifts.
So I remembered how great this forum was years ago, and how much fun it was to participate and I thought I would reaquaint myself with the group. It was apparent that things had really changed. Reading a few hundred posts to catch up, it was really obvious this group has become quite clanish. While some responses are still great, many are quite curt. And if you are an unknown here, you are easily ignored.
To drive this point home to me, I was disgusted with the tone taken by many on the turning exchange this last year. I couldn't believe the discussions about who was worthy of what work, who should actually get it someone else's work, what quality should be sent, etc. Questions were asked along the lines of "if someone doesn't post a lot, how serious could they be towards the group?" and "how do I know how serious they are about woodturning?" They were obviously more worried about their finely crafted work falling into the hands of some beginner than thinking that it could be a prized and treasured piece that could inspire for years.
Cutting through all the bogus reasoning, the message was clear: we only want to trade with those that are our known friends that will send us something of equal value. I was thinking while reading this, why don't the organizers make the participants submit samples, judge the quality of work and the value of the piece and then categorize them so that the clan folks would only get something from the other clan folks. My goodness, you would hate to get something that someone worked their butts off on that you considered not worthy.
As for me, with all the things I have turned, sold, and gifted, I have something that I got from a turner in Houston in 1997 at the old Texas Turn or Two. Having no luck with the skew at all, he worked with me diligently for about an hour and a half. I hadn't been turning but for about a year or so, and before that it was well over 20 since I turned candlesticks in high school. Together, we made a whistle. The long kind mimicing the old Bobbies whistle. We turned it smooth with him at my elbow lifting the whole way, and I turned a ball on the end. And you know what? It is my most prized turning. I could turn one now in literally 5 minutes on any of my lathes. But that one is special... that one inspires good work and good treatment of others along this path.
If you want to really pull into focus how hard the winds of change have blown, search the archives and see how many familiar names you see that post here now. Look at the articles and reviews - how many familiar names do you see? How many have stuck around? Not having stayed with this group over the last couple of years, it was a real surprise to see how much the overall tone of the group had changed since I didn't see it develop, I got it all at once.
Rather than the old spirit of really helpful encouragement, it was quickly obvious that a smaller, tightknit group of people have formed a mutual admiration society that isn't really too interested in new faces or the work of others. Sadly, like all newsgroups or forums, without that new blood it will die. New faces mean sometimes exciting ideas and techniques. They provide the satisfaction of passing along some of the things that were learned at the hands of others as well as by personal experimentation. On the turning NG, there was a neat little post on how to make a homemade steb center for about 3 bucks. Right now it seems that the group regulars kindly tolerate the work of others (although there are still some great folks out here), and simply gush when one of theirs post something.
And have you noticed how all here seem to strive for the same shapes? There are accepted shapes with some variations, and the clan pretty much turns within those confines.
I see a more free exchange of ideas and thoughts on the newsgroups. There I post freely between the woodworking and woodturning groups, shoot pictures of work to others, and get some back in exchange. It is a less polite group at times, but I like the open door policy for all skill levels alot. I have been a professional speicalty carpentry contractor for about 30 years, most of that self employed. And yet, I still learn from some of my guys that have been doing it for a couple of years (read: noobs or lesser skilled - hint, hint). They discover new processes simply because they don't know how to do something the "accepted" way or because their enthusiasm leads them to a whole new technique or idea. And it seems a little silly to me to see attitude, spoken or unspoken from some here I can recall as "just starting the addiction".
Last year I posted about 600-650 messages to just two newsgroups, and not sure how many this year, so participation in these venues is a hobby of mine and something I enjoy. The woodworking group alone gets somewhere in the many thousands of messages every month, and you read the threads you are interested in, or when you can offer help to others. Yup, some politics, some OT discussions, but they are usually well marked (and good to stay away from!). The point being there are lots of interested folks out there exploring all the different crafts, so I think the group's destiny is actually in its own hands. The environment here will certainly be the key to that.
It will be interesting to see where this forum ends up.
Robert L. Witte