Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

Posts

Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#1

Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

Stephen Gehres

>I'm sure this is a really dumb question, but it's something that's been stuck in my craw for quite some time. Here goes...

You have a really expensive, exotic bowl blank that you're planning to make a nice bowl from. When "I" look at that blank, I see 10 beautiful pen blanks just sitting in the middle staring at me. And they're taunting me with "You can't get me... You can't get me... Na na na na na!" Then I turn my bowl (which I still haven't attempted yet) and all those beautiful pen blanks get sucked right down into the dust collector.

What does everyone else see? Is there a way to get at these little devils without degrading the quality of the bowl you intend to make with it?

Still a newbie,

~Steve

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#2

Yes, sort of.......

Barry Irby

>This is what the various center saver or coring systems are all about. There are at least four or five versions out there and maybe a dozen. They are all based on some version of a curved knife that the system holds and you guide it into the wood while the lathe spins it. Oneway has one and McNaughton a considerably differnt version that are often discussed here. These may be the most popular, but there are others too.

I have the McNaughton. It has a number of curved "parting tool" knives available and a post or a gate that holds them and prevents them from twisting while in use. Basically, you pick a knife that matches the diamter of the blank you want to core and slice the center out of the bowl. This system is both loved and hated because it is somewhat more "free hand" than the Oneway version. With care, you can slice three or four concentric blanks out of the center of a larger blank. Without care and patience, you can turn your blanks into funnels. Or, YOU could take a fairly large blank out of the center and cut it into pen blanks. People that own these systems find all kinds of clever uses for them and can save a considerable amount of (expensive) wood from the dust collector.

I tried to post a link for you but mine is not workiong at the moment. Check out the Kel NcNaughton Comapany.

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#3

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank? *LINK*

Tommy Holmes

>You can core the bowl blank and either make more bowls or suppose could make pen blanks. Oneway is one version. Their website has video instruction.

Craft Supplies carries 3 different types/brands.


Oneway Easy Core

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#4

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

Stephen Gehres

>Ouch!!! Thanks for the answer. You provided exactly what I asked for... But, I looked at the sticker $, and then at my wife. I don't need to tell you who won this round... I'll need to sell quite a bunch of items before one of these gems makes it's way into my little shop.

~Steve

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#5

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

John Lucas

>Stephen that's exactly why I don't buy the expensive bowl blanks. Sure it would be nice to turn wood like that but I can't justify the price of the coring tools, my market won't buy the expensive woods and I hate to waste whats in the middle.

It's easy enough to make a slicer tool which would allow you take a pretty good V shaped cut out of the middle. They are fairly inexpensive. You don't get nearly as much usable wood out of the blank but at least you aren't wasting in all.

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#6

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

Allen Neighbors

>If you live close to NW Texas, I've got the Kelton (Kel-McNaughton) Rig you can try out, to see if you like it. :o)

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#7

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

Stephen Gehres

>John,

Please tell me how...

The problem I'm having right now is that I'm just learning how to turn, and *ALL* my wood (blanks or flat lumber) is purchased from the lumber yard. I haven't quite figured out where to look for 'found' wood without risking getting shot by some angry landowner. I did drag limbs over my back fence from a dead cedar tree in the neighbor's back yard. The grain in it looks somewhat like the Bethlehem Olive Wood I purchased. I'm thinking of making a covered box for Mother's day.


img

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#8

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

Stephen Gehres

>Allen,

I'm in Grapevine.

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#9

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

John Lucas

>Kevin Move to Tennessee. There's tons of free wood here. Seriously though when I first started turning I had the same problem. Fortunately I got into turning because I was into woodworking and had a table saw. I started making laminated projects which eventually led to doing stack lamination and stave lamination pieces.

Eventually I bought a chainsaw and started getting wood from lumber piles and neighbors that had a tree coming down.

My best advice is to find a club near you. We always have free wood at the club meetings. Most everyone will offer to help you find wood. Once you get into it and start asking around you will find more wood than you can handle. I would say having a chainsaw is a must for free wood. Either that or a friend who has one.

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#10

Free Wood

Al Kapocius

>After a while, you develop a knack for spotting free wood sources. Check Bill Grumbine's post on burls down a ways. Lottsa my wood was found at night, at the curb, with a truck with good pickup.

There should be public works sources that cut or trim or accept trimmed trees near you.

Al Kapocius

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#11

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank? *LINK*

Brodie Brickey

>If you're cutting your blank on a bandsaw, you can also use the corners for bottle stoppers or knobs.

The McKnaughton is kinda like a large diamond parting tool that took a turn. You can probably make one from steel and just sharpen it a little more often. The only problem is that you need to slow your lathe down below 500 RPM when you're using these kinds of tools. That generally means a more expensive lathe.

You should be able to find wood a the local dump or talk to one of the large parks in the area. Construction sites also have scraps that are very useable (just look at Ian's bowl further down the page: http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/turning.pl?read=146255 ).

Regards,

Brodie


http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/turning.pl?read=146255

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#12

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

Fog Tanner

>Steve,

I use the McNaughton system to core all the bowls I do. Recently on a 19 Pecan bowl I got 4 bowls (6"-19"), 4 more off the corner offcuts and 6 box blanks. I don't even think of turning a bowl without coring the center. When I was where you are now, I thought everybody had a coring tool so I got one - only to find a handful in the club had them and fewer that actually used them. Back then I was happy to get two bowls from a 10" blank - now I would get 4.

The Mike Mahoney DVD on using the tool is a great learning aid. We recently had Mike in for an all day demo and later one day hands on. Now all the other people that had coring tools are actaully using them. It can be intimidating and is best if you can get help if you are new to turning.

I don't know what lathe you have, but you need at least a 1 1/2hp motor - 2hp is better. And a VS drive is really more than a niceity. I usually core at 600-800 depending onm the blank, but turn it down to under a 100 when I get towards the bottom. I started on a 1 1/2hp 16" Delta and now have a 2hp Vicmarc - both of them can handle coring - the Vic will just do it faster. Speed comes with practice, which just mean turning a lot of wood. Which certainly doesn't hurt the learning curve.

As has been mentioned the best thing you can do is join a local club and you will find leads to more wood than you can probably use. I got over 3000lb of mesquite from central Texas thanks to one of the club members and a several thousand more of pecan from another. The pecan we got through some land being cleared for a high rise. You can get in on some of these types of club outings and walk away with a share of wood as long as you have a strong back. A good chain saw will also help, but normally there are a couple of guys that just want to run their saws and it becomes a communal effort to load the wood into the trailers and trucks.

Since you are in Texas, there are a number of species of Mesquite across the state. The ranchers hate the stuff and are gald to have you cut it down and haul it off, just takes a little driving around and asking. Just be sure you have a chain saw and two spare chains, it will dull the chains. And a trailer is good too, preferablly a dual axle 16' with 2' sides. And then a bigger lathe would also help......its a never ending cycle, but well worth the journey.

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#13

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

Allen Neighbors

>Shoot, that's only a 3.5 hour drive. Take 114 West to Rhome, then 287 North to Childress. I'm in the phone book. Bring a blank, and you can take the Kelton rig for a spin on my 1640.

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#14

Re: Better yet, I've got some blanks...

Allen Neighbors

>you don't need to bring one. :o) We can cut you a large chunk of Sweet Gum, or Aromatic Cedar, or English Walnut... your choice. Think it over. Let me know.

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#15

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

Stephen Gehres

>Time to start going out late at night...

I've got a decent chainsaw, an SUV (no trailer), and a wide open schedule (I'm retired). But I'm not too mobile in the woods though. I've been on crutches for 10 years now. I'm pretty sick and tired of them, but they say "forever" means "FOREVER". I got 2 new knees in 2005 so that helps at least.

I keep planning on visiting the "North Texas Woodturners" club, and the "Golden Triangle Woodturners" club but every time the schedule comes up I'm having a bad day. I'm gonna keep trying though. Even 10 pounds of free lumber will make it worth my trip.

Thanks for all the tips,

~Steve

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#16

Re: Better yet, I've got some blanks...

Stephen Gehres

>Allen,

I just might take you up on it. It will do me some good to get out of the house for a change. It also would do me some good to watch someone who knows what they're doing. I was turning my 2nd project today, and after taking out 4 chunks from catches it's about ready to toss out.

I'll email you when I know what I'll be doing.

Thanks for the offer,

~Steve

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#17

Re: Sounds good. Email sent.

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#18

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

Fog Tanner

>I can emphathize on your crutchs. I was on some for part of a year when I dropped a bullet through my foot. But sounds like you have an excellent opportunity to practice spindle turning and make yourself a set of turned ones. Would definately be novel and classy. I have seen a number of turned canes, but never any crutchs, so you might have a "first" at the very least a "limited edition".

Both those clubs you mentioned have a bunch a great guys more than willing to help you learn. And you will learn more in a shorter time than doing it off on your own. Hope you have an "up" day and make one of their meetings. Were you in the Houston area, you would be more than welcome to join our club. A lot of our members are retired and have their down days as well. But, they tend to have more up days being involved in making things round. One of our members still gets his own wood, and he is over 80 somewheres. Its keeping him young and going for sure - well at least going, he's past that senior "stuff", just happy to be old and still turning.

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#19

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

Stephen Gehres

>I don't know about unique turned crutches.... But I took a trip to Alaska in 1998 and got quite a few looks from people who saw me crutching up to the top of a glacier... 3 days later I was on a cruise down at the opposite end of Alaska and people were still coming up to me stating that they 'saw me climbing'. My friend (who just passed away) made me some 'custom glacier climbing crutch attachments' as a going away surprise. He just 'whipped them up' the night before I left. He was a jack of ALL trades! And my hero.

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#20

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

Charles Jennings

>Hi Stephen, you mentioned sources for wood in one of your responses, I have found new construction sites great sources for all types of wood. Most site superintendents are pleased to give it to you to get rid of it. I have also found that as strange as it may sound my church has been a great source for wood. Someone is always having a tree removed for some reason and if you let it be known that you are interested in obtaining wood for woodturning, you will get called. Having a chain saw is essential, but returning a small bowl or platter to the provider as a token of appreciation will work wonders for future calls. I have cedar, osage orange, walnut, and magnolia that were all from calls to see if I wanted it. Regards, Charlie

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#21

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

Stephen Gehres

>Thanks Charlie. I'll check with my church.

I took a drive around the neighborhood the other day to see what I could find laying around. There's been a bit of street construction going on and I thought it might be a good place to check. Maybe it's just me, but I didn't feel right snooping around while workmen were busy. I checked a couple back area streets, and you're right about the chainsaw. I either found small branches, rotted trunks, or logs so huge that no one else wanted to attempt to haul them out either. I thought it'd be crazy to try to get in and out with crutches and a chainsaw without getting in trouble. I'll feel better if I can go somewhere where I have permission, and don't have to hurry as it takes me longer to do the heavy work.

I thought a good source would be to find where the tree trimmers dump their waste. I printed off a list of 26 that serve our town and I'm gonna give some a call. Oddly, 3 years ago (before I took up woodworking, and more recently turning) I paid a crew $1100 to cut down and remove 9 huge trees, mostly as tall as 80 feet. Now I'm really kicking myself. Now I wish I had the foresight to know I would take up this hobby. The trees were all willow (not weeping) and 2 chineese talon. Don't know if this would have been good for turning anyway. They were all VERY fast growing trees, so I imagine they would be softwood and loose grained.

Re: Wasted wood from a bowl blank?

#22

This stuff grows on trees.....

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Juat turn it Stephen! We've all done the same. There's more where it came from.

Jen :)