Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Turning true

Posts

Turning true

#1

Turning true

eliot d

>I tend to use fairly good equipment like my Powermatic 3520A and Vicmarc chucks. Yet I nearly always notice what looks like very slight out-of -true wobbles --even on small diameter stuff. I set up a micrometer gauge to measure any runout at the spindle, and it appears acceptable at around 2 thousandth inch. I was watching Lacer's Son of Skew video yesterday, and I could see the same thing right on the video. BUT ... not long ago I had a chance to turn on a little Jet mini lathe, and it ran so true that I thought it was not even on!

Somewhat puzzled in Maryland.

Re: Turning true

#2

Re: Turning true

Bill Howatt

>My General 260 is about 0.0002 on the spindle where the threads end near the shoulder. The shoulder itself is about 0.0004. I think the shoulder measurement is the more important one at least for faceplates and chucks. These are static measurements and when the spindle is spinning a load then bearing play could make a big difference.

Remember that 0.002 play is scaled up by the radius of the workpiece.

Bill

Re: Turning true

#3

Re: Turning true

Robert Henderson

>I saw a TV show once on boat building. They trued the sides by eye. It was pointed out that the human eye can preceive differences of less than .002". .002" may be an acceptable runout, but you can still see it.

Re: Turning true

#4

Re: Turning true

eliot d

>When you say. 'static measurement', do you mean that you slowly rotated the spindle by hand and watched the gauge? When I took the measurement, I had the lathe running under power. The runout with the lathe turning at normal speed would seem to be the more important measurement. Also, can you throw any light on why the Jet Mini seemed to be turning with no perceptible runout? I mean, in contrast to my Powermatic, I could not detect any "wobble" on the Jet.

Re: Turning true

#5

Re: Turning true

Bill Howatt

>Yes, my static measurements were done by slowly turning the spindle by hand and also yes, the behaviour when the lathe is running with a load on it is most important. Normally, when people post numbers they are static measurements so I assumed yours were.

Did you note the number of decimal places in my numbers?

What are your static measurements?

How did you do the dynamic measurements? I turned my lathe on and ran the speed up a bit and the shoulder measurement was no worse but this doesn't have any weight on it.

Bill

Re: Turning true

#6

Re: Turning true

Longhair

>I guess I don't see the point of concern? Any wood will move more than that just because of humidity change alone.

Re: Turning true

#7

Re: Turning true

eliot d

>I don't believe a small , dowel -shaped, piece of fairly dry wood will move hardly enough to measure due to humidity. As I said, when I had a chance to turn a small item on a Jet Mini, it turned remarkably true with no visible movement. I'm fearful that my (much more expensive) Powermatic doesn't turn as true.

Re: Turning true

#8

Re: Turning true

Bob Fawcett

>I have not tried to measure my Powermatic or my Jet, but I don't percieve any difference. The PM should be equally true.