Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Maple Burl

Posts

Maple Burl

#1

Maple Burl

craneman54

>Hello people.I haven't posted here in a while,so I thought I might put this up for some advice.

I'm not sure I like this form.

Let me know what you all think.I can take it.


img

Re: Maple Burl

#2

Re: Maple Burl

jeff myroup

>Craneman,

I like this piece. I think the form and neck are very nice and I love the natural edge. I am still undecided about the foot. I think it might look better if the curve were carried through to the base. But I like the added stability of the foot. Overall very nice.

jeff

Re: Maple Burl

#3

Re: Maple Burl

craneman54

>Thanks for the compliment.

I almost didn't leave a foot,but felt it wood be too unstable without one.

Also after posting this pic on another forum and getting good feedback,maybe the opening should have been smaller.

Re: Maple Burl

#4

Re: Maple Burl

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>I really like this piece. The natural edge opening is a great contrast to the smooth lovely curve of the body. I think I agree with Jeff though, that the foot may have looked better removed and allowing the curve of the body to just continue and tuck in nicely at the bottom. You'd be surprised at how stable even a 1" base can be. I don't think is piece would be used to hold anything such as dried flowers or what not...so I think just looking pretty on display the diameter of the base (minus the foot) that you have there would be fine. I actually like the larger opening too. It invites us to want to look inside. A tiny opening kind of says....stay out. In my opinion.

Just my 2 cents worth :)

Over all I really like it! Nice job!

Jennifer

Re: Maple Burl

#5

Re: Maple Burl

craneman54

>Thanks,I may just have to put it in the vacuum chuck and take the foot off.

Maybe that is what is throwing it off balance in my minds eye.

Re: Maple Burl

#6

Re: Maple Burl

Terence Rice

>As I downloaded the pic on my super-slow dial up connection I thought it was really an outstanding piece and then the foot came into view and suddenly it was not as appealing.

Re: Maple Burl

#7

Re: Maple Burl

RevDoug

>Hate to echo what everyone else is saying, but this time I have to. The base just doesn't work with the composition. What you have isn't bad at all. I just believe that the overall balance would be quite a bit better if the foot were gone. You mentioned the throat of the piece. Jen talked about the large opening. I'm not sure, but I believe that the larger mouth like you have, narrowing down to a narrower throat might have also given a more pleasing look. The larger mouth that you have does, as Jen said, invite the holder to look inside. A smaller throat would keep too close an inspection and would lend an air of mystery as well.

Nice piece, but a few changes would make it great.

Turn 'em round,

Re: Maple Burl

#8

Re: Maple Burl

craneman54

>Thanks for the input and the compliments folks.

I agree with what has been said about the foot.

I discussed it with LOML,she said "If you touch that vase I will cut off something you don't want cut off." I'm thinking she don't mean my toe nails.LOL

So needless to say the foot stays.LOL