Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

Posts

Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

#1

Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Maple with lots of pyrography. It's 5 inches dia. x 6 inches high. I'd appreciate comment on my finial design.

Wally


img

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

#2

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

John Lucas

>Wally I like this one a lot. All the lines seem to work well. Is the wood that white under the burning or is just the photo that makes it looke that way?

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

#3

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

Mac

>I believe the finial fits the piece to a "T"......I really like this giraffe series you are doing....FWIW...Mac

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

#4

The finial is perfect

Cyril Griesbach

>

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

#5

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

Troy German

>The finial looks great. I especially like the maple ring that you left untextured around the finial. If this was my design (and I would be very proud if it were) the ONLY area I MIGHT play with is the disk just under the sphere (by the way, great job executing a near perfect sphere). I�m not sure what I would do differently, if anything, but when thinking about redesign possibilities that�s the only area that I would even consider changing.

Thanks for showing,

Troy

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

#6

Finial is perfect!!!

jeff myroup

>

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

#7

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

David Walser

>Wally,

I'm really enjoing these. I think this one may be perfect.

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

keith tompkins

>Hi Wally, the finial fits the form very well. I can't tell you anything you don't allready know about collars....but, to anyone who's struggling with finials, the collar will make or break any finial design. Yours fits the form, and leads up to the finial, tying the whole piece together. This is a good piece to study.

Your finial is well-proportioned, is the right color, and the slanted tip adds just the right amount of flair. Personally, I'm not too crazy about v-cuts in spindle work...I'd like to see a a classic cove beneath the ball in the finial, with a couple of filets to make things stand out. It may be fun to draw one out to see if you like it.

Another thought...a giraffe could benefit from a L-o-o-o-o-g finial, in keeping with the theme. Great work, as usual.

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

#9

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi Wally,

Lovely piece! I've actually copied your giraffe design and tried it on a hollowform myself. I think it turned out ok, but my technique needs some practice.

Keeping in my mind that my opinion is worth what you've paid for it, but I honestly think that this finial is too big for the piece. Actually, just too tall, not too wide. I really like the slope to the very top, but I think that the upper section could have been shorter while keeping the sloped part and it would have been ok. Also, while I am being honest and opinionated :), I really love the body and giraffe design and think that overall the finial is too complicated for this piece. The giraffe pattern is really striking and I like the ones you've done like it with the plain collars so that the highlight of the piece is the body and burned pattern.

It's not that I don't like the finial, I really think it is wonderful, I just would prefer it on a different body.

Again, worth what you paid! :)

I hope things are well in Arizona. I've been trying to do 3 hollow forms for each open bowl this year and so far I am ahead of that game. I'm really enjoying the challenge of getting a good shape and form with the vessels, but I'm not anywhere near your thinness!

Take care,

Mike

Two maple hollowforms into the drying bags today in Apex, NC!!

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

#10

Thanks For Your Comments Folks...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

#11

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

bowlman

>As always, Wally, you humble us with another gorgeous piece!

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

#12

Very Smooth!

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Wally,

I think you nailed the finial on this one, the look and the flair at the top would make any Giraffe proud!

I enjoy seeing your development of this new direction you are exploring!

I hope both Jane and yourself are having a fine day.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

#13

Bob Moffett

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

Bob Moffett

>I like the shape of the whole piece and really like the finial.

Re: Another Smoky Giraffe...w/ Finial...

#14

Re: Me, too, Wally... What Bob said.

Allen Neighbors

>You give us all the incentive to do better. Thanks for sharing your talents.