Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Alan Lacer's article on box making

Posts

Alan Lacer's article on box making

#1

Alan Lacer's article on box making

John Lucas

>Did anyone see the article on box making. I think it was in American Woodworker. He must be selling tools. :) He uses at least 7 tools to turn a simple lidded box. I use 2 most of the time but sometimes as many as 5. I use a spindle gouge and parting tool. Sometimes I'll use a rough out gouge to rough it out and will use a skew on some to get the outside shape better. I have a screwdriver I ground as a scraper for fine tuning the fit on some lids.

Re: Alan Lacer's article on box making

#2

Re: Alan Lacer's article on box making

Gary Ratajczak

>I've seen his live demos, and he dosen't use that full bag of tools. Most with a skew, and a hook tool that he makes.

Re: Alan Lacer's article on box making

#3

Re: Alan Lacer's article on box making

John Lucas

>Gary I was just kidding. Alan's a good guy.

Re: Alan Lacer's article on box making

#4

Re: Alan Lacer's article on box making

Gary Ratajczak

>Agree - he's a great instructor. I have his videos as well.

Re: Alan Lacer's article on box making

#5

Re: Alan Lacer's article on box making

Russ Fairfield

>John,

You do bring up a point about demonstrators and tools. They use a lot of different tools for no other reason than because they have them, or too often because they are selling them. I prefer to see a demonstration brought down to the level of the skills, tools, and equipment available to the target audience; and that means making a lidded box with a gouge and a parting tool.

Re: Alan Lacer's article on box making

#6

Re: Alan Lacer's article on box making

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I agree...case in point. Many of you have seen the video done by Del Stubbs back in the 80's. It's still a great video but Del uses far too many tools. I've watched Del turn a number of times and he didn't use half of those tools.

Del was a great turner and demonstrator, but unfortunatly Del quit turning and went off into something else.

Wally

Re: Alan Lacer's article on box making

#7

Re: Alan Lacer's article on box making

Philip Duffy

>Funny, I had the same reaction! I kept looking at all those tools and wondered what they were for, but then, who am I to criticize as the end products look pretty wonderful to me. Philip

Re: Alan Lacer's article on box making

#8

Re: Alan Lacer's article on box making

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I think part of the demo intent is to show how to use a variety of tools. I have 4 or 5 skews and no hook tools. Someone else may have several hook tools and no skew. If they show how to use a wide variety of tools most turners will have enough tools on hand to do the job. Several paths can bring us to the same end.

Re: Alan Lacer's article on box making

#9

Re: Alan Lacer's article on box making

John Lucas

>It was the first article or even demonstration where I saw someone use the point nose scraper. My best friend uses one but he uses it like I use a skew. He claims he can't use the skew but he rubs the bevel and undercuts the bottom of goblets etc using the edge the same way I use the point of the skew. anyone else ever see someone use that tool.

Re: Alan Lacer's article on box making

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Alan Lacer's article on box making

keith tompkins

>Hey Russ, you've seen MY demo tools...including the craftsman skews...I'll keep using them until there's nothing left but a nub...or til I find new ones at tag sales!