Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Small Hollow Form

Posts

Small Hollow Form

#1

Small Hollow Form

Donna Banfield

>I'm not exactly a lurker, but have never posted photos of my work before. That's because my skills as a photographer (studio, anyway) are poor.

I've created a Phrugal Photo booth, and took some photos. This one is a small hollow form, 3" high, yew, with natural edge bark 'collar'. It's not very thin, because it sheared off as I was working down toward the bottom.

Please feel free (wait, let me slip into my thicker skin....o.k., ready ;^) to comment and critique on the turning and the photography.


img

Re: Small Hollow Form

#2

Re: Small Hollow Form

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hi Donna,

I really like this little pot. These aren't easy to make with the skinning necks. Congrats on maintaining the bark at the opening! It's got a nice, plump shape to it. I'm no expert at the photography part either, but I think you may have gotten a little clearer picture with a tad more light on the object. Other than that...great job!

Jennifer

Re: Small Hollow Form

#3

Steve Kubien

Re: Small Hollow Form

Steve Kubien

>I agree with Jennifer. I little more light would really highlight what seems like a wonderful piece. I love the shape. Looks like it wants to be picked up and held.

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: Small Hollow Form

#4

Re: Small Hollow Form

Donna Banfield

>Thank you Jennifer and Steve. Your critques are appreciated, and I see what you are referring to about the lighting.

Jennifer, I've been a (silent) fan of your work for at least three years, and love your new website. So much so, that I'm seriously considering using the same guy to redesign my site.

Thanks again.

Re: Small Hollow Form

#5

Nice hollow form...

Dave Belser

>About the photo, it seems a little out of focus to me. Are you using your camera in aperture/manual mode and setting the aperture to the highest (f stop 6 - 8 or more) it will go? This will give you a much deeper depth of focus. The downside is that you will need to take long exposures, often 2 seconds or more. This will also require a tripod and either a remote shutter release cable or use of your delay timer.

When I shoot, I don't worry about the quantity of light so much as how it falls on the piece. With the camera on a tripod I can take long enough exposures to end up with a picture that is bright enough.

Hope that helps... Maybe one of the pro-photographers will check in

- Dave

Re: Small Hollow Form

#6

Re: Small Hollow Form

Bruce Forrest

>I like the wood, and it appears to be well executed. However, I would suggest that the shape be adjusted a bit by placing the maximum diameter a bit closer to the top. Also, at the top, the bark portion seems to be a bit wide in proportion with the size of the rest of the piece. Just a couple of points to consider or ignore as you see fit.

Re: Small Hollow Form

#7

Re: Nice hollow form...

Donna Banfield

>Hi Dave

Yes, I was using the manual setting on my camera, Aperture priority, and the f-stop was either 7.1 or 8 (I know 7.1 sounds weird, but that's what the digital readout gave me). I also use a tripod, and set the camera for a 2 second delay after tripping the shutter.

I think that this piece was set just a bit too far back in the 'booth', because larger pieces that I shot that same morning have more light. As for focus, it is possible that I didn't pay close enough attention. I was zooming in with a macro setting, and if I zoom too close, the camera will tell me that it's not autofocusing on the subject (with a little AF! in red letters). I was getting that message a few times, and that particular photo might be one that I forgot/ignored?

Thanks for your tips.

Re: Small Hollow Form

#8

Re: Small Hollow Form

Allen Neighbors

>Nice work, I like the way you managed the bark, too. The form appears to be intentionally symmetrical... more of a profile would show it better.

The golden mean (loosly described) calls for the widest diameter to be either 1/3 down from the top, or 1/3 up from the bottom; but that is meant as a guide for pleasing the eye. However, if you want to deter from the golden mean, you can (potter and clay, so to speak) ... depends on what you want. It seems to me that it's intended.

Won't comment on the picture... since mine always stink. :o)

Re: Small Hollow Form

#9

Re: Small Hollow Form

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Donna,I like this turning very much--nice curves all around. Just one thing about the shape, a minor point, is the vertical symmetry (aside from the top "collar") is a bit disturbing to my eye. It needs a little bit of imbalance, which I think could have been achieved by giving more fullness to the bottom curve after it goes around the midsection, instead of a straight (sort of) line. Then that lower curve would naturally be able to tuck itself under without the corner at the foot. Gee, I sound like an art critic but honestly, I'm just a Regular Guy who never even went to collidge (hmm, why is there a red line under that word?)

;)

Re: Small Hollow Form

#10

Re: Small Hollow Form

Bill Stehman

>Hi Donna,

I like your HF. It is well executed and if we all followed the rules then everyone would be making identical turnings, how boring would that be?.. chuckle. Few understand how difficult extended necks are to turn. You did good. I will trade turnings with you anytime... keep up the great work and

Thanks for sharing.

Bill

Re: Small Hollow Form

#11

Re: Small Hollow Form

Donna Banfield

>Thank you Bruce, Allen, Ken and Bill for your helpful comments.

The 1/3 2/3 rule, or golden mean, is a concept that I do understand, and one that I try for. Sometimes I succeed, sometimes, not. But in this case, the round 'sphere' had already been formed. I received this small piece of Yew from a club member that tried to turn a sphere, and tossed it because of a couple cracks. I was able to turn the cracks away, and because it still had some bark on one side, I decided to try the small hollow form.