Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

Posts

A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#1

Steven Antonucci

A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

steve antonucci

>In seeing Ed's haul below, and knowing what my pile looks like and what I have coming (more later), I ask the following question:

Is there any such thing as too much wood?

I have more wood than I have time, and I expect that I could have 10x the amount that I have if I was so inclined. I have access to an endless supply of Ash is I wanted it (I have enough, so I don't). I live 2 miles from a sawmill and the owners throw pieces on the side for me that won't fit/have metal/aren't straight.

My sister in law is having a large mystery tree cut down in a few weeks. The main trunk is 4-5' in diameter and it's huge. I have to go, since I suspect it's a black cherry tree, but how much is too much? If I took the "whole thing", it would take me a month of Sundays just to move it to my place.

So I ask- how many of you have too much wood?

Steve

P.S. Not meaning to gloat, but really asking if some of you have stopped collecting unless something spectacular presents itself.

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#2

A theoretical answer.

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>No.

I always tell people at the shows:

1) You can never have too much wood.

2) Wood is much, much cheaper than psychotherapy.

Gary

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#3

Yes

Ron in Drums PA

>Share the wealth ;)

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#4

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much w

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>Steve,

I'm in the same boat as you. I have too much wood. I give it to turners that stop by, or burn it, which ever comes first. I turn down more than I get. The stuff grows on trees! I have been getting better lately and turn down a lot. I have tried to limit it to highly figured. I have thought about this a lot and have come to the conclusion that I like searching for good wood about as much as I like turning so I end up with too much wood. I was out in the woods today looking for more.

Gary

Gary

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#5

Theoretically no, reality yes

John Lucas

>Not having a good place to store it I get tired of mowing around it. It's kind of an ugly pile if your not a turner so I try to keep it to a minimum so the neighbors don't talk. Like you, if I really wanted I could get all the wood I'd ever need. Not necessarily great wood, but plenty of ordinary stuff.

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#6

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much w

Bart Rhoads

>The way I see it, I dont think so. Wood is biodegradable (sp). I try to get as much as I can. You never know when you might need or want that particular piece that you left back there. I have plenty of room to store it and when I die my son doesnt have to worry about trying to get rid of it. He can just leave it out in the woods and it will go right back into the ground. Unlike metal or rocks which will never go away or it will take many years to rust away. So I say bring on the wood. I just hate to see a tree just go to waste. I would rather turn a piece of wood into blank than let go to a land fill and rot away. Guess that is why I have probably a couple of thousand blanks sitting around that I will probably never finish turning. Just my thoughts.

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#7

Yes, it can go "bad" before you can turn it

Greg Haugen

>

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#8

Re: A theoretical answer.

Thad in Wartown, GA

>I spend my days in psychotherapy, and I must say that w/o the knowledge that there is more than enough wood for me to turn my troubles away, I would be the one on the couch.

However, couples therapy may be in store if I don't find a better way to organize my stash.

~ Thad

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#9

Ain't Nuthin' The-o-retical

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>About it.

I'm booking the sawyer to come slice up this walnut a'for it goes bad. Had some nice 24" Hackberry but it "went" bad before I could get to it.

[then I can start all over again |;-}}} ]

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#10

too much wood? with picture

jared

>I hope this is a picture of my woodpile taken in December. Some of it has disappeared but there is still a lot left and I added some more here and there. Mostly Ash, some walnut and a little birch. I have wondered what people that live in town do with there logs. that would really cramp my style. NO YOU CANT HAVE TOO MUCH WOOD. Jared


img

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#11

This topic brings a tear . . .

Verne in snowy Nevada

>Living out west in an area where what "found wood" there is, is pine, fir, or an occasional cottonwood (when you can find it); where every tree trimmer has a list of pleading turners and any downed hardwood has a frantic turner sitting on it with a shotgun desperatly trying to figure out how he dare put the shotgun down long enough to get it cut and in his truck! Too much wood?? . . . That's like too much money . . . which is another thing I know nothing about!

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#12

Re: too much wood? with picture

Mac

>You got a lot of field left there to fill......

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#13

Steven Antonucci

Illustrating my point exactly

steve antonucci

>Thanks to the folks that have contributed to the thread so far.

My point was, as some have alluded to, that you can have wood "go bad" to cracking, bugs, staining... before you get to turn it. That stuff gets split and burned at my house.

As far as this picture shows, I've probably walked away from that much in the last year. I know where a 200 year old white oak is laying, a huge bunch of spalted maple, and at least 10 70' tall ashes that were felled a few years back, but I just don't need any more.

There was a time when I'd take it simply because it was there. Now if I had a place to stack logs like this and the equipment to move them and Mark's sawyer coming, I might start collecting again...

Steve

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#14

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much w

eaglesc

>That's like asking a flatworker can you have too many clamps or too many routers.

Some of the clamps are better than others but you have em when you need em

Same thing with routers.

Nice thing about wood for pens is it can be smaller pieces.

Bad thing about wood for pens is just about every scrap is useable.

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#15

Mike Stafford

S A B L E

Mike Stafford

>Stash Above and Beyond Life Expectancy....

I have not reached that point yet but my stash is approaching the limits of my storage facility. I just cannot say no to a pretty piece of wood...

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#16

That's not a theoretical question, it's RHETORICAL

Molly Winton

>

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#17

I have to show this one off.

jared

>This is a walnut log that I rescued from a burn pile. The guy I got it from has a small bandsaw mill and cut the lower portion of the trunk into boards and was going to trash this piece. The tractor is a 1968 International 856. It comes in handy for hobbies like turning. I have some forks for it that I used to unload my 3520 when it was delivered. The good thing is that it is all farm related equipment so is all deductable and depreciable.

I do feel really fortunate to live where I do and have the time and facilities to play around with hobbies like this. I am thankful. Jared


img

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#18

I'm in a Wood STEP program

Charlie Anderson

>Sure, Take Every Piece!

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#19

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much w

Mike B

>Gary

If you are serious about having too much wood I would be glad to help you out. I'm in Fayetteville NC and the pickings here are limited to oak, pine, and an occasional bradford pear. I consider a nice piece of maple as "exotic".:)

Have trailer and chainsaw and willing to travel.

Mike

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#20

He who dies with the most wood wins

John Veerkamp

>

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#21

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much w

Barry Turner

>Women can never have enough clothes........

or, a house that is big enough......

Men never have enough tools........and

"No", you can never have too much wood.

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#22

How long are you going to live?

Mike Brazeau

>My wife looked at my pile in the yard last spring and said "How long do you think you are going to live?" Guess what. It is just as big this spring, few additions, few deletions and some biding its time and spalting.

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#23

Free Wood Is Good Wood 

gil Jones

>


img

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#24

Re: Ain't Nuthin' The-o-retical

Jimiles-Charlotte, NC

>Mark: Don't worry about Walnut going bad. I recently go a log of Walnut that had been cut and lying on the ground in the woods for 10 years. The bark & white sap wood were gone but the dark "walut colored" wood was just as solid as it could be.

Re: A theoretical question:can you have too much wood?

#25

Re: I have to show this one off.

Fog Tanner

>That is the only way to move wood around. Mine isa Kubota nd a 2006 model with only has a five or six foot bucket on it, but will still move a lot of wood around and really saves the back. If I would move a few things I could drive it through my garage and workshop and into my studio and up to the bandsaw really saving the back (10 foot ceilings). Like you I have several acres I am trying to cover, have a running start with mesquite and pecan, about like yours only cut into shorter pieces I can handle without the tractor.

As far as too much wood, I have some flat stock that my father and I cut 20-25 years ago, that I got when he died. He used about half of it and I am down to the last couple of thousand board feet. I am trying to use it up before I die, if I see that I can't - I'm making a thick walled cedar coffin and takin it with me.....