Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Sharpening Question

Posts

Sharpening Question

#1

Sharpening Question

Pete (Stafford VA)

>Hi Ladies and Gents � I have a theoretical question about sharpening. I was at the local woodworking show and stopped by to look at the Tormek demo that was going on. When the guy was done I felt all the turning tools and was very, VERY impressed � they were razor sharp; I can NEVER get my tools that sharp by using a slow speed grinder (especially the skew). When I stopped by another vendor�s booth (one that I buy most of my supplies from online), I asked them what they thought of the Tormek vs grinding (since they sell both) and the guys told me that the serrated edge sharpened by the stone will cut smoother and much longer than the super sharp edge created by the Tormek. He said Tormek sharpened tools need to be sharpened MUCH more often than tools sharpened on a grinding wheel.

I�m just a beginner, so I have no reason to doubt him; I�m just not sure I fully understand. I know there are those of you that love your grinders and those that love their Tormek�s, but what do you all think about what I was told? Will the super sharp edge created by a Tormek dull faster than a sharp serrated edge created by a grinding wheel?? And if yes can someone explain?

Thanks!

Pete

Re: Sharpening Question

#2

Re: Sharpening Question

Greg Haugen

>First of all, I caught something in your post. A skew is never sharp enough directly off of a grinder. Look into a some "fine" grit diamond hones. Most every turner that uses a skew will tell you it has to be hone off of a grinder. Watch either the Skew Video-sweet side and the dark side from Alan Lacer or watch the AAW sharpening dvd on skews. Now, I have had a Tormek. It is nice, yes. Part of the issue I had was the speed of it. It's such a finer grinder if you or the jigs are off slightly you can spend 10 minutes or more getting them reset. I also had the "turning tool" setter and didn't like it. It works well if you only use their preset angles. Which mine are not those. For me the 10-20 sec to redress a grind on the grinder compared to the hassle of the Tormek I got rid of it. Razor edge to serrations?? Depends on the skill of the turner. IF the bevel is rubbing/floating the edge will last longer. Than if a gouge or another tool is used improperly and it's more of a scraping or unsupported cut the edge will wear or roll over.

My thought-buy a 8" slow speed grinder with decent wheels, don't have to be 120 dollar wheels either. Also get a fine diamond hone for your skew. A good system like the Wolverine is priceless. If you still want to spend the remaining 400 dollars that the turner's package would cost, buy an extra chuck and some more tools or wood. Or even take a class with the 400. I would not "recommend" a Tormek. And yes my views have changed since previous posts. And yes this will start a huge war for dry grinders and wet grinders.

In the end, its price and personal preference.

Greg

Re: Sharpening Question

#3

I have both

TDaniel

>I have a Tormek and a 1750 rpm 8" grinder with 100 grit wheel. I have done this comparison many times and I am with the guy that you just talked to. My gouges cut better from the grinder. Now other than the gouges the Tormek will do a better job. If "sharp" was the only thing that was important then there would be no steak knives or bread slicing blades or for that matter, bandsaw blades with teeth. I used to work in a plant where we had to slice paper towels. That took a very sharp bandsaw blade with no teeth. My packaging machines used a wavy toothed blade for some materials and a 14 tooth blade for others. Bread cutting blades are 2 wavy teeth per inch. In a nutshell, there will be times that a gouge sharpened and honed on the Tormek will outperform a gouge sharpened on the grinder, but it won't be often.

Re: Sharpening Question

#4

100% correct Greg

TDaniel

>

Re: Sharpening Question

#5

Richard Allen

Re: Sharpening Question

Richard Allen

>I did a four month test between the Tormek and an 8" half speed grinder.

I found that the woodturning experience, using the Tormek, was degraded.

I found the cutting action of the tools sharpened on the Tormek the same as the tools sharpened on the grinder. I was unable to find a preference in tools based on the sharpening method.

The degraded turning experience was from the effort in prepping the Tormek and in cleaning up the Tormek.

The point is that all the "theory and "Science" doesn't account for a hill of beans compared to the way a particular sharpening impacts your turning experience.