Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

finial, collar or nothing?

Posts

finial, collar or nothing?

#1

finial, collar or nothing?

john lucas

>I'm trying to decide whether to put something on this vessel. The iniside is turned very poorly. I just haven't turned enough vessels of this size to turn the inside cleanly. The hole is too small to sand through. I think a finial would take your eye away from the figure in the wood but I'm leaning toward something that doesn't look like a knob or your typical Cindy Drozda finial.

The other option would be to add a small collar. However the piece warped quite a bit and I don't know for sure that I can make a collar fit without looking jury rigged.

It is difficult to see inside but turners will always look which is why I'm wanting to cover up my mediocre hollowing.

What do the wise people of WC think.


img

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

#2

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

Barry Irby

>That's a good looking finial on that fence post. (Sorry, Couldn't help it.)

I'd go with a collar. Black. Not fancy.

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

#3

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

John Pickett

>collar or nothing

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

#4

Bob Moffett

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

Bob Moffett

>That is a beautiful piece on it's own. If it makes you feel better about it put a collar on it. I think it would be great either way.

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

#5

Mike Stafford

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

Mike Stafford

>Perhaps a note for the inside that reads, "What are you looking at? The outside is what is important!"

I vote for a small unobtrusive collar...

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

#6

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

Bob Fawcett

>John,

Terry Daniel would fill the vessel with rocks and tumble them for a day or 2. He had a tumbler that turned at slow speed and just let the rocks polish the inside. Can you still mount it?

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

#7

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

jeff myroup

>I vote for a small black collar.

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

#8

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

john lucas

>Bob Rocks will make the inside smoother but won't get rid of the ridges. If it was perfectly straight inside I wouldn't worry about it. I've got to get more comfortable with my larger hollowing tools. Iffel like I'm making this nice smooth cut down the inside and I get done and look in and it looks like waves.

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

#9

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

john lucas

>Barry I think I'll put those on fence posts all around the yard.

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

#10

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

john lucas

>I'm really leaning toward a very small collar. One that doesn't stick up more than 1/8" if that much.

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

#11

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

Bob Fawcett

>I can't comment on that as I have no experience with hollowing large vessels or much small for that matter. Just seemed like a good idea.

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

#12

Looks like the collars have it. It's high enough

adrien

>

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

#13

Dick Hines

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

Dick Hines

>John, a collar would be nice. If you can return the HF to get the shape back in order would help you with fitting the collar. If it still wet and changing shape I think I would let it be as is.

Do you use a laser on your hollowing rig? That will help you get the waves out.

You could always use some of that artist black stuff on the inside. That would make it hard to see inside.

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

#14

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

Leppikallio

>Or even use some of those "structural paints" (paint with sand) and if color is black it will eat light and feel funny but hide most imperfections. Probably two layers would be needed and of course it could be good idea to put sealer coat first just to make sure there won't be black outside (and paints are water based also so to prevent warping I would put that sealer too).

Everyone has said "yes" to collar but... I also think it would be good to define that opening little more. Either if there is enough room for that Ellsworth style opening (in "Homage" series) or perhaps with woodburner burn and carve that opening little. It won't raise the opening but it would allow you to make it look like "knot hole" or something like that? Just some thoughts...

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

#15

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

john lucas

>I'm going to make some more of these. I feel that accurate hollowing of larger pieces is something missing in my skills so I plan to practice. I will probably try different lip treatments. Of course the goal is to get the inside so perfect it doesn't need any cover up.

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

#16

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

Leppikallio

>Shear scraping seems to be the answer. What a difference does it make. I got my new hollower and shear scraper head for that and now I can remove waste amazingly quickly, take light cut or two and then shear scrape. Of course that surface quality would still look horrible outside of vessel so there is still much work to do but I'm getting closer... :)

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

#17

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

John Lucas

>I've thought about making one of those shear scraping tools that is square but has a bit mounted at a shear scrape angle. I still wouldn't be able to clean up the area from the lip back with that setup.

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

#18

Re: finial, collar or nothing?

Leppikallio

>Something like Munro or Woodcut shearscraper head works well. I have that Munro head (mini) and it works like charm. Of course it has much to do with size of the opening but this could be something to consider. Design is quite simple too so it would certainly be possible to build something like this...

Still of course this is kind of slow way to go as you probably have to tweak setup as you go, turn the blade etc. But it helps much anyway.