Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

'nother lathe question

Posts

'nother lathe question

#1

'nother lathe question

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>Bet y'all be glad when I finally get one.

Yesterday I made the long drive to Wood Werks in Columbus, OH with hopes of being able to compare the two Powermatic lathes side by side. They didn�t have the 4224 but they did have the 3620. Best of all, purely by accident, the local turning club was in action in part of the building. Watched a lot, asked a few questions, learned a few things. My interest was rewarded with a roughed out cherry bowl that now resides in a paper bag waiting for the arrival of the lathe that will be big enough to finish it.

There was a lot of praise from several of the turning club members and the owner of the store for the 3620. They even joked about not knowing that Powermatic made another model. The storeowner said the drawback to the 4224 was lack of a sliding headstock. He acknowledged that yes, you can turn outboard on the 4224 but you will be doing it backwards.

Stupid question of the day.

So what?

The memory is a little fuzzy after more than 37 years, but I know I turned outboard in high school shop class and I can�t recall any special problems. Besides, since the lathe can be run in reverse it seems to me that outboard rotation could be whatever works best.

Off the subject, anyone within a few hours of Columbus who has never been to Wood Werks should check the place out. They have some really neat toys and decent prices. I wish they were a little closer to where I live. One of the highlights for me was seeing a tool like one that I bought in a box with a bunch of other stuff. I�ve wondered for a couple of years how it was used. Now I know.

Re: 'nother lathe question

#2

Re: 'nother lathe question

Bob Fawcett

>Turning outoard in the normal forward direction is the unscrew direction for right hand threads, the more common thread. If the 4224 is threaded right hand on the outboard spindle you risk having whatever is screwed to it coming loose unless it has a set screw or some other locking mechanism. Some lathes have left hand threads to prevent this, but then you have to hunt for left handed accessories or inserts.

If you run in reverse, you need a little more space around the lathe to allow turning from both sides of the lathe.

I love my 3520 and would still choose it over the 4224 even if they were the same price.

Re: 'nother lathe question

#3

Re: 'nother lathe question

john lucas

>Randy I have the 3520 and think it's a great lathe. I'll try to answer your other questions. One reason outboard turning can be difficult is that the thread size is different and often left handed so your normal chucks and faceplates don't work. If you do have right hand threads and you reverse the lathe the chucks may come spinning off. Some of the lathes have a recessed area behind the threads on the spindle so you can lock the faceplate on with a setscrew. I don't remember the 2442 having that option but I haven't used one in a while.

That's why the rotating and sliding headstocks have become so popular because you can use the same threaded attachments.

If your looking for lathe in the price range of the 2442 look up the Robust 16 and 25 inch lathes. The 16 is probably in your range and it has a sliding and rotating headstock and also a removeable bed section for larger turning. It is one sweet lathe and it ain't made in China.

Re: 'nother lathe question

#4

Re: 'nother lathe question

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>In answer to both you and Bob....

I would certainly make sure before buying, but it is my understanding that the 4224 has a groove similar to a keyway cut into the spindle to recieve a setscrew preventing the faceplate from parting company with the lathe when turning outboard.

Re: 'nother lathe question

#5

Re: 'nother lathe question

john lucas

>Randy My 3520 doesn't have threads for a faceplate on the outboard side. It does have some threads but they are for tightening the spindle in place. the handwheel has a setscrew to tighten it down. I am interested in whether or not the 2442 has a faceplate thread on the outboard side. Of course how often will you be turning more than 24".

Re: 'nother lathe question

#6

Re: 'nother lathe question

Allen Neighbors

>Just another two cents worth... well, one anyway... :o)

It's not on a Powermatic, but I turn outboard, and offside, just about as much as I turn onside.

I turn offside quite a lot, but most of the time, my lathe is spinning forward... thus, the forces in play are natural.

The only thing needed for outboard turning is a groove or indentation on the spindle in the exact spot necessary for the set-screw to lock a chuck or faceplate on when you reverse the lathe. This is my only complaint about my Oneway 1640. The collar on both, inboard and outboard spindle, is just that - a collar - which allows a chuck or faceplate that is locked on with a set screw, to rotate just ever so slightly when it tries to come off. I mean, 'ever so slightly' before the set screw does it's job. But that minute, slight amount is just enough to loosen the chuck from the shoulder of the spindle.

All this is of course moot, if the outboard threads do not match your accessories.