Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

stihl poll

Posts

stihl poll

#1

stihl poll

jared

>Hello I know that the chainsaw preferences get beat to death here but?????? I am going to buy a new saw and have pretty much settled on a Stihl [local dealer, good value, etc]. He has three models, all priced with 20 inch bars:

MS 290 for $360

MS 310 for $400

MS 390 for $480

At the moment I am leaning towards the 310. The difference in price is not importent to me. I would rather spend a few $$$ more and get the right saw than try to skimp. I have done that in the past, bought used stuff, etc. and I am fortunate to not have to do that anymore.

What is the consensus on this one?

Thanks in advance Jared

Re: stihl poll

#2

Re: stihl poll

Kurt Rosenzweig

>I have the 310 and am more then happy with it! Just make sure you use Stihl oil mix! I just had to rebuild my 066 that I use on my sawmill due to cheap oil! It really makes a difference!

Re: stihl poll

#3

Re: stihl poll

Mark Strang

>I bought the 310 2 years ago after owning a series of other name brands over the years. It is a super saw. I've taken down 30" trees

with it and have had no problems at all.

I bought my son a 290 recently. It is fine for what he does with it around the yard on light duty work etc., but it doesn't compare to the 310. It's not my money but I vote for the 310.

Re: stihl poll

#4

Richard Allen

Re: stihl poll

Richard Allen

>Those are all terrific home owner saws. The Stihl pro saws tend to be with numbers like 260, 361, 440. These saws are lighter, with more HP, and stronger part which last longer. So if money isn't the deciding factor then weight, power, chain speed should be of concern. You can put a 20" bar on the 440. It will have enough power to slice through the toughest woods (like white oak) with ease when fitted with a 20" bar. Yet you can load the saw up with a 36" bar when needed an expect great performance. The 440 is a heavy saw if you aren't going to cut wood bigger than 20". The 260 is the lightest saw at about 15 lbs with bar chain oil and gas. That light weight will make using the saw for hours a lot more pleasant.

I would recommend the 440 because you are not likely to use the saw for more than a couple of hours at a time. The weight is an issue but the extra power will forgive many mistakes like a less than sharp chain like when you let the chain touch the dirt. Or like when you need a bigger bar on the rare occasions when you come across a really big hunk of wood. That is $720 with a 20" bar. (the little 260 is $470 with a 20" bar).

Good Luck

Re: stihl poll

#5

Re: stihl poll

Ed Moore

>I bought a 310 four years ago. It recently broke down and because the Stihl dealer went to bat for me Stihl replaced it. In the interim I bought a 361 and now I have two brand new saws. I use them both, but the 361 is the better saw.

I was going to sell the 310, but since I seem to rip a lot of wood I plan to keep them both. When ripping I plan to alternate saws to avoid overheating one saw. Something in Jacques Vesery's article on chainsaws resonated with me and alternating seems right.

Ed

Re: stihl poll

#6

390

Peter Teubel

>Since price is not an issue, it's really quite simple. All weigh the same (according to the specs), but the 390 has more power. That's the reasoning I used after using a friend's 290 for a week straight. Awesome saw. You will not be disappointed.

Re: stihl poll

#7

Re: stihl poll

Cyril Griesbach

>I'm going to weigh in here even though all the votes seem in favor of the 310. I've got a 290 and it's older twin designated the 029. These saws both have 20" bars and have cut MANY tons of wood over the last 10+ years with NO problems. I have to attribute that to Sthil and not the model of the saws and the fact that I take reasonable care of them. Now I do wish I had a lighter saw for limbing but price is an object for me so I'll just continue to take more breaks as I age along with the saws.

Cyril

Re: stihl poll

#8

Re: stihl poll

Brodie Brickey

>I have the 290 with a 20" bar. It cuts beautifully for what I need. I don't drop trees, just raid the local dump for logs and slice them up into bowls.

Brodie

Re: stihl poll

#9

Re: stihl poll

Barry Turner

>It's not one of your listed choices, but consider the Stihl 361. It's beyond your listed price range at about $600, but you get what you pay for. It's at the lower end of their professional line of saws. I bought one a couple of years ago and love it. It's a 58cc engine with a 20" bar. It has plenty of power, has a better air filter and better vibration damping than some of the lesser Stihls. It has compression release to make starting easier and is a bit lighter than some of the other saws of the same power range.

Re: stihl poll

#10

Re: stihl poll

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

>MS 260 because I just want to make bowl blanks not cut down a forest. My club has some opportunities for wood rats like me. Most of the time the tree(s) has already been felled and we just need to slice it up. So, I went with the weight to power ratio.