Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Shop Cooling

Posts

Shop Cooling

#1

Shop Cooling

Philip Morris

>I am trying to figure out how to cool my shop and was interested in others experience who share warmer, humid environment.

Recently moved to Jackson, Mississippi. My shop is an attached double car garage. I don't think that the subdivision's home owners association will allow a window unit air conditioner. Have been considering one of the big portable air conditioners or a mini-split system. Does anyone have any experience with one of these systems or can offer another alternative that may not be obtrusive to the neighbors?

Shop description:

- approximately 400 sf, with 8' ceilings

- wall attached to house is insulated as well as garage door

- two uninsulated walls are finished with brick on exterior and drywall on the interior

- attic has 9" of blown in insulation

Re: Shop Cooling

#2

Re: Shop Cooling

Gil Jones, Lake Seminole, GA

>My shop is 1664 sq ft, with 1450 sq ft of that heated and cooled. Insulation is thermo pane windows, insulated doors, R-19 (2x6) walls, and R-30 ceiling. I bought and installed a used 2-ton Carrier split-system heat pump, and it does a fine job of keeping the place comfy. I reckon that proper insulation and moisture barrier is very important.

Gil

Re: Shop Cooling

#3

Re: Shop Cooling

Jimiles-Charlotte, NC

>Wonder if you could install a window unit without it sticking out the window. Maybe sitting on a platform inside the garage and the hot air going out the window?

Re: Shop Cooling

#4

Re: Shop Cooling

Rick Allen

>I have a window unit. The dust makes a mess of the cooling fins quickly. The filter on the window unit is a joke. But a window unit is cheap compared to an installed system. Circuit city (and I am sure other merchants) sell 5 yr no questions asked warranties. If the home owners association has a problem with the window unit, perhaps it is because the unit sticks out the window. Perhaps if you made a box to put the unit in so that the unit didn't stick out the window but was primarily inside the shop you wouldn't cause them any grief. The box would need to be big so that air could get around the unit. But what grief could they give you for an open window?


img

Re: Shop Cooling

#5

Dick Hines

Re: Shop Cooling

Dick Hines

>This idea does not cool my shop but it cools me. I hang a 19" box fan from the rafters and direct it on my. It also works as a dust extracter.

Re: Shop Cooling

#6

JL

Re: Shop Cooling

JL

>They installed a mini split system at my old church in the sacristy (they sort of forgot to run the duct work until it was too late in the planning process). The room size is maybe 200 sq. ft. It seemed to work okay. I don't know the particulars. This is in Metro Atlanta.

Another thought (much more expensive). How old is your heat pump? Do you have zone capabilities on your HVAC system? Could you add a zone?

Re: Shop Cooling

#7

Re: Shop Cooling

Barry Irby

>In addition to the things already mentioned, I would be concerned about those two uninuslated walls. If the sun hits them they are going to collect and retain a lot of heat. My father�s house sits out in the open, not shaded by trees and is red brick and it is insulated. The sun cooked the south end and west side so badly the house was miserable with out AC. The heat worked its way through by late afternoon and was impossible until the middle of the night. He tried a whole house fan, but when its 95 outside there isn't any cool air to pass through the house. I'd say you have a problem specially if either of those walls faces south or west and does not have excellent shade.

I have about half the shop you do and cool it with a very small window AC. I put an additional filter in front of it and use my DC and Ambient Air cleaner. The AC makes a huge difference. I take the cover off the front several times a summer and vacuum the coil. If You could put one on the back of your house I would and I might even screen it or put a planter box or something in front of it. I would not ask the neighborhood committee. Their job is easy, they just say no. I would argue that it is temporary and does not affect property values anymore than those stupid tents people put up for parties now. (If I got busted)

Re: Shop Cooling

#8

Re: Shop Cooling

Barry Irby

>I would be very leery of using the house's system for cooling the shop. Several issues. Very difficult to keep it from transferring dust into the house. Any air it blows into the shop has to return to the system, either through a return or by going back to the house and then to a return. The dust will go with it. Also there are Building Code issues about fire separation between the house and garage. The system will "penetrate" the drywall that separates the house and garage and could literally suck fumes (shop fumes, dust, and Fire fumes) back into the house. The Code forced your builder to Drywall the garage to cut down on fire spread, but it does not force him to insulate walls in unconditioned spaces. Too Bad.

Re: Shop Cooling

#9

Re: Shop Cooling

don lewonczyk

>Plilip Morris, any connection to the tobacco Morris? Just kidding, if you were you wouldn't be living where you have to ask if you could put a n A/C in your shop window! If you could afford the heat pump go with it, I have a split system in my shop and one on an addtion to my house 450 sq ft. No insulation in ceiling was an open poarch closed in and no reasonable way to insulate the ceiling. Costs a little more to operate but it's comfortable. Its a 2 ton unit. The one in the shop is 3 ton with 14' ceiling works okey but still gets warm in the shop on 90 degree days but not that you can't work in there. The best thing about the units are I have no tools in my shop rusting (ever) unlike a 24'x90' hog barn I converted to a shop until I could afford a real shop. I was forever steel wooling all my tool surfaces and waxing them, thats the pits, I live on the TN/AL state line 6 miles west of I-65 and the humidity is about the same as MS. Good luck let us know what you come up with, im lucky I have no neighbors I can see and no one and no one to tell me what I can't do, hmhm except my dear wife, the boss, the slave driver, the first sargent, maybe I need neighbors! Take Care DonL

Re: Shop Cooling

#10

Re: Shop Cooling

John Lucas

>We don't have a homeowners association in my neighborhood other than try not to do anything that brings the police.

I have a 2 car garage and live in middle Tennessee. It gets mighty hot in the summer so I insulated and put a small window unit in. It's pretty quiet and I don't see why it couldn't be mounted flush with wall on the outside as long as you make sure the condensation has a place to run. You wouldn't want it to rundown the wall.

It's a really small unit and I have to run a fan directly on me during the really hot humid days but it's very tolerable and all I could afford for now.

Re: Shop Cooling

#11

Re: Shop Cooling

Wilford Bickel

>Phillip,

Don't know where you moved from but the secret to cooling an area in central Mississippi or Alabama is INSULATION! I would insulate those two walls before anything else and then a small window unit will efficiently cool the area. My shop is a small metal building and we put R16 in ceiling and walls - I have never regretted that work! Next time we come over to Jackson for cattle shows, rodeo, etc. I'll try to remember to give you a shout and maybe we can get together.

Wilford

Re: Shop Cooling

#12

Re: Shop Cooling

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>Most window units have outside louvers on the side. The condensor air is sucked in thru these and blown out thru the coil at the rear. You can't cover these up.

Bill in WNC mountains

Re: Shop Cooling

#13

Re: Shop Cooling

Tony - Memphis

>I just bought a GE for my shop that has heat and cooling. The housing is only open on the back - that was a surprise to me. The unit I replaced had louvers all over it. My shop is 320sq ft, 10' ceilings, and well insulated. This unit is just under a ton I think. Really too big, but I needed it for heat as well and this was the smallest I could get. Anyway, mine doesn't sit in a window, it is in a hole in the wall and out of view. I assume I could have mounted it further in and decorated the box such that it looked nice. Unfortunately, my hood has no rules and we have window units hanging out of so called "bonus rooms" all over the hood. Looks really nice!

Tony

Re: Shop Cooling

#14

Geo Thermal

John Lucas

>You need to switch your house over to Geo Thermal. That way you'll save enough in 10 years to pay for it all. With all the caves in my area I might just be able to dig a hole in the backyard and tap into a cave. Then I'd start heating and cooling the house with 55 degree air.

Re: Shop Cooling

#15

Re: Geo Thermal

Philip Morris

>John,

Thanks for your responses. I just made a major career change (with associated salary cut) as part of the move to Mississippi. I tried to convince my wife that the low salary would justify me taking a year off and building an inground house (no utilities, no exterior maintenance (other than mowing the roof), no insurance, no worry from tornados/hurricanes)...she didn't buy it.

PC

Re: Shop Cooling

#16

Re: Geo Thermal

Bob Fawcett

>I live in Savannah GA. Plenty hot and humid here. My dad put 2 of the mini split systems in for his porches. This is 100 year old southern house with porches all the way around 3 sides of the house. He had enclosed the porches with sliding glass doors the previous year. It is amazingly comfortable. The porches are at least 800 square feet and all glass except for the house walls.

My house is ICFs(insulating concrete forms) and the shop is in the above ground basement. Stays cool with no AC :-). If you ever build a house ICFs are the way to go. Insulating is over R50 for my walls and my heat and cooling bills show it.

Re: Shop Cooling

#17

Re: Shop Cooling

Philip Morris

>Rick,

Thanks for the response and diagram. There actually are packaged units out there like what you have drawn. They refer to them as "thru the wall". They are similar to what you see in hotels. They have no vents in the sides so they do not have to stick out past the exterior wall.

The main rub is that they have limited cooling capacity of about 14000 Btu/hr and their expense can rival that of split units of larger capacity.

PC

Re: Shop Cooling

#18

Bob, That's My Dream. NM

Philip Morris

>

Re: Shop Cooling

#19

Re: Shop Cooling

Philip Morris

>Barry,

Thanks for the response. I have also used the auxillary filter over a window unit intake with good success.

And, yes, one of the uninsulated walls faces west. Fortunately, my next door neighbor's house is only 15 or 20 feet away. But you are right that brick has some thermal mass and radiates quite a bit of heat back into the shop. Unfortunately, I don't even have any windows in the garage, so to cut a hole in the brick for a window unit will be hard to defend as temporary.

If I wasn't on such a tight budget I would just install a separate split system like on the main house. I am considering going with a 16000 BTU portable (which equates to a 12000 BTU window because all the hot internal components are inside the cooled area). I typically spend most of my time by the lathe which is usually separated from the rest of my equipment with a tarp. So maybe the separation will serve to contain the cooler air around my primary workspace.

PC

Re: Shop Cooling

#20

Re: Shop Cooling

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>If you have Home Depot they are selling a portable unit that sits on the floor and has a tube, 4 in. or so, that feeds the hot air outside. I think they are about $ 400.00.

Remember that heat seeks cold. You will need extra fans to circulate the air in the shop or you will have hot spots.

If you need more info on the units just let ne know.

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.