Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

Posts

How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

#1

How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>Last Saturday I spent the afternoon in the basement of the local Art Association picking up a few pointers from a longtime turner. When I mentioned that I was planning on a major step up from the current Delta Midi, he said something that I have read both on this forum and others.

�Try out several before you buy one.�

Now I have to admit that on the surface this sounds like good sound advice, but for many, including myself, it isn�t all that practical.

My plan from the beginning was/is to decide what features are important to me, read owner reviews on the net, compare specs of the lathes that make the short list, and read owner reviews on the net.

When I first started thinking about adding a full size lathe to the shop my first consideration was the Jet 1642. The price was in my range and I could not find the first negative comment on it from present or past owners.

Then two things happened.

The first was a stop at the Fairfield, OH Woodcraft where there was a 20� General VS on sale for three grand. Gee, four more inches of swing would be nice. Unfortunately I didn�t have three grand to spare so the General stayed there. So did the first place status of the 1642.

The next thing was the discovery that there is going to be a little windfall come October and I can look at some of the high end machines as something within my reach.

The General is now a distant third primarily because of the inboard and outboard spindles being different size threads. This is a minor issue, but it is a non-issue with choices #1 and #2.

The top two choices are the two offerings by Powermatic with a strong leaning towards the 4224. It�s another case of four more inches would be nice. I would seldom if ever need the capacity of the 4224 but it�s nice to know it IS there if I need it.

Oneway is still out of reach and hence stricken from consideration, and I want as much between centers as I can get so I�m not looking at any bowl only lathes. �Sides, they all seem out of my range as well.

So with the list down to two, how important is a test drive? When it is between two lathes that seem to have universal praise from those who own them, what can there be that would make me regret the purchase down the road? I don�t see any point in trying out some of the smaller lathes, because as good as any of them may be, I want something bigger. I want this to be the last lathe I will ever buy with nothing to �trade up� to.

If anyone has a �I wish I�d known about that before I bought it� stories I�d like to hear them. Particularly if it involves either of the two on the short list.

BTW, even with just the Delta Midi I can seen a storage problem in a year or so as bowls of all shapes keep appearing. This turning thing is fast becoming a compulsion. I can�t believe how long that thing just sat there unused.

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

#2

Re: Ask yourself several questions......

Jamie Donaldson

>... such as am I going to turn bowls, hollow vessels, table tops, baseball bats,etc. Many novice turners dream of having the biggest stud lathe to turn pieces much larger than they ever have before, and in reality it seldom happens. I recommend looking at the sliding headstock feature on the Powermatic 3520 so that the lathe can be more comfortably used as both a long bed and short bed bowl/vessel lathe, an option not available on most other lathes. It's nice to dream about lathes that can swing table tops, but in reality do you have much wood available in such sizes-not likely! When cost is a consideration, test turning a variety of lathe candidates is the best policy before jumping in over your head for features you don't need.

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

#3

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

john lucas

>Randy Personally I think a test drive would be great. I've never met a lathe that I didn't find at least one feature I didn't like or at least found awkward to use or wish it was designed differently for may tastes. However I will agree that unless you live near one of the big clubs like chicago you probably won't be able to test drive the lathes of your choice.

Many of us get hung up on the specs. That how Craftsman sells all the crap that they put out. They put fancy numbers and bells and whistles on everything. We start saying this lathe has one more inch of swing and 1 more inch between centers etc. In actual use its the things like horsepower, ease of speed adjustments, how well the tailstock locks, is the spindle lock easy to use, are the spindle threads a common size and othe small things that make a good lathe.

My favorite lathes right now in the midprice range are the Powermatic 3520 (which I have), the Robust sweet 16, Oneway 1640. I've played on all but the small Robust. I did get to play with the big Robust and it's a sweet machine.

For bigger lathes It's hard to beat the Stubby, Oneway, Robust, and Vicmarc. The powermatic 2442 is a nice lathe and probably about the same as the Vicmarc but lower in price. (at least the last time I looked).

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

#4

Richard Allen

Oneway 1642

Richard Allen

>Oneway 1642 has 24" swing outboard for around $4,000.

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

#5

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long *LINK*

Bob Fawcett

>Don't forget that the 3520 can have a short extension mounted to a leg and with the banjo extension it increases outboard capacity to over 30".

When I bought my 3520 a year ago, I got the short extension and the banjo part as well as a remote switch and another tool rest for bowls in a package for just over $3000. Check this link.


Osolonik

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

#6

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

Rick Davenport

>You are in the same situation I was in 18 months ago.

Just like you, I started with the Delta Midi - a good starter lathe to find out if you are really a candidate for committing to the next $$$ level.

I don't think you would go wrong with any of the lathes you are considering.

I have a PM3520b and the single overriding feature (among others) that makes me glad I bought it is the sliding headstock.

My back thanks me daily for not having to bend over the bed.

Since I do mainly bowls, that feature is HUGE.

R

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

#7

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

Barry Turner

>A little over two years ago, I moved from a Jet Mini to a Stubby 750 and have had no regrets. The Stubby suits my style. I turn a lot more bowls and vessels than spindles. I didn't test drive a Stubby before I bought one, but I did drive down to John Jordan's shop and play around with one for an hour or so. My mind was almost made up before I went. The visit just confirmed what I already knew from reading the specs and seeing others turn on the Stubby. My second choice probably would have been a Oneway 2436, but they can take up an awful lot of space....as can a PM 4224. Because of the space issue, after the 750 and the 2436, the PM 3520 probably would have been my next serious choice.

It may not be imperative to "test drive" a prospective lathe before the purchase, but at least go see one in person and play with it. See how well the banjo and tailstock slide along the bed and how easy they are to lock down. Turn the lathe on and run it up through it's speed range. Notice if there are rough edges or what appear to be shortcuts in the manufacturing process. Are castings smooth and well finished or rough and with sand pits? How about the ergonomics? Are the controls easy to reach and operate?

If you are like most new turners (and me), you don't have a clue as to what you will eventually want to turn. Get a lathe with enough capacity and power so that you have a reasonable amount of flexibility. Extreme amounts of capacity probably won't be necessary because a 16" bowl is a rather large bowl. It require a large and heavy blank and if you are like me, not something I turn that often.

I think you should give some consideration to the PM 3520A. It can do an acceptable job as a spindle lathe and as a bowl lathe.

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

#8

Re: Test drive-VERY important

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>Even though most of the better lathes have the same features, for about the same price, the "angle" of the feature my not be the same. You should have a lathe that fits your body. This is true of all tools. DeWalt circular saws allow me to see the cut line, Porter-Cable's blow the sawdust in my eyes. Specs, quality, HP, turning radius, etc. all are trumped by body fit. If the way your hand interfaces with the banjo adjustment is not right...you will not ever be happy with the lathe. This is true, no matter how many features you got for so good of a price.

I suggest that you attend a woodturning school that has multiple brands available. Arrowmont, for example, has some thirty lathes: mayo, mustard, green, dark green, black, white, etc. The cost of a weekend class is much cheaper than trying to sell your $3000+ "baby" that you HATE! Would you buy a $300 suit without trying in on first? No, then why would you buy a $3000 lathe without trying it on first? There is no way that a lathe that fits John Lucas' small frame will be OK for Bill Grumbine's or my 6'6", 400# bodies. Find a school near home, there are many around the country. Many clubs have mentoring programs where you could test drive different lathes. Have fun, but make an "informed" decision.

Bill in WNC mountains

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

#9

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

Bill Crommett

>Randy: You have recieved more good advise than you can asimilate, but it should all go into the mix. One thing that has not been addressed is PARTS replacement. Nothing is perfect, and few pieces of mechanical design are going to last forever under any and all circumstances. So it is judicious to investigate what replacement parts are going to cost, if they will even be available down the line. Example: I blew the VSR unit on my big General, and the factory wants $1170.00 for a replacement because the original Altivar - 16 is obsolete and will have to be replaced with an Altivar - 32 (+/-). So, another dilemma !

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

#10

Re: It's 1640... $3795 with 2 HP motor

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

#11

Re: Test drive-VERY important

john lucas

>Bill Just because I feel like little people when I'm around you and Bill G doesn't mean a lathe wouldn't fit. I stand on an 8" box when I demo on the lathe owned by the guy who furnishes our meeting place. He's at least as tall as you guys. Maybe I just need stilts.

You are correct. One lathe doesn't fit all. That's one thing I like about the stubby and Robust. They come with adjustable stands.

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

#12

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

john lucas

>Bill You've brought up my concern on all the modern lathes. Advances in electronics mean that within 5 years all of our VFD's will probably have to be replaced with something new when and if they blow out. I'll be willing to bet you can't buy a direct replacement from the factory. They may furnish an upgraded version simply because they may not be able to get the same device.

That was my major concern with the Nova DVR. If my VFD goes out on my lathe I can buy an aftermarket VFD and replace it. The same is true with the motor. If the motor goes out on the DVR what do you do if Nova doesn't have one?

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

#13

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

Denis Putland from Saskatchewan

>I am not trying to sway you or any body else but thought this info might be of value to some.

General makes an adapter that turns the out board spindle into the same thread as inboard.

Costs another $50.00 though.

Denis

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

#14

Re: Ask yourself several questions......

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>Since starting to play with the Delta all I've done is small bowls. Distance between centers doesn't allow much in the way of table legs and the like.

No matter what I eventually get, most of the playing will be bowls, and hopefully, as skill increases, hollow forms. What I am wanting to avoid is NOT having the ability to do something at a later date because I didn't think the need would ever arise when I bought the lathe. It's doubtful many big chunks of wood twenty inches in diameter will turned but smaller things like plates and platters will be. Maybe even a few table tops.

A recurring theme on the various turning boards is that once the lathe gets in the shop the other machines sit idle, becoming shelves for blanks and finished projects. I have a pretty nice shop in terms of the toys that are in it. I look at a full size lathe as a chance to do some things with furniture projects that I've never been able to do before. That said, I'm a little behind on what I'm doing now because I kept going over and playing on the lathe I have instead of working on what I was supposed to be working on.

The next step I guess is to find some place where I can see the machines in the flesh. I think a trip to Berea may be in my future.

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

#15

Re: If you're going to Osolnik Machinery ...

Jamie Donaldson

>... be sure to call Joe first- he doesn't usually have machines in his office for you to see. You're welcome to test out my Stubby if you're coming by I-64 since it passes about 3 mi. from my home/shop.

Re: How important is a test drive? ...kinda long

#16

Re: If you're going to Osolnik Machinery ...

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>be sure to call Joe first- he doesn't usually have machines in his office for you to see.

I was going to call first, but with that information I will try to find somewhere else closer. If I do opt for one of the Powermatics, Osolnik will be where I get it. They have by far the best deal I've seen. It bugs me to spend a lot of time with a salesman and then buy the product he has somewhere else but in this case there is little other choice. The town I live in has one decent place to buy tools and they don't have any serious stationary machines. Choice B is going to be something I really hate....

getting more than a mile and a half from the Interstates and bypass loops around Cincinati or Indianapolis. I really hate driving in big cities.