Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

spindlemaster

Posts

spindlemaster

#1

spindlemaster

bhenr99

>I got what I thought would be the answer to all my problems, getting a spindle master by Sorby.I just can't get it to cut. I try to get it started and it just won't continue to conplete a cut. I'm sure it's me but can't firgure out what. Any hints that may help me? I watched the Sorby demo and this guy does all kinds of stuff with it. Thanks for any help.

Bob

Re: spindlemaster

#2

Re: spindlemaster

Ruth Niles

>Bob, I watched the short video on this tool and was quite impressed. I have a few old skews and was going to grind one of them to match this tool. I figured it would be used the same way as a skew rather than a spindle gouge. It is a single-sided skew with a round tip.

Re: spindlemaster

#3

Re: spindlemaster

john lucas

>They need to be almost polished to cut. I use fine and ultra fine diamond hones. These are equivelent to 600 and 1200 grit. Because this tool doesn't have a flute the edge angle is more obtuse than a spindle gouge or skew. I find that it doesn't do anything a skew or spindle gouge won't do so I gave it away. I do make my miniature tools this way. I've found that spindle gouge shape without the flute cuts just as cleanly on the small sizes so I just make those tools that way.

Re: spindlemaster

#4

Re: spindlemaster

James Duxbury

>Bob,

I had one of these and the same as John, I gave it away. It has to be razor sharp which in any of the hard woods only lasts a few minutes plus there is just not enough meat in the tool or something. It is a flimsey excuse for a good skew. I like the oval skews the best now but they should also be kept pretty sharp to cut properly.

Re: spindlemaster

#5

Re: spindlemaster

Ron in Drums PA

>I have one of these and I'm not too impressed with it. I finally reground it similar to my bowl gouge. Works better, but still not the best IMO.

I do use the spindlemaster to clean up the bottom of boxes. I like rolling it to it's side to get into the corners.

Re: spindlemaster

#6

Re: Eliminate the "almost".

Al Crandall (N.E. of Indy)

>Rockler's brought a Sorby rep to our club to demonstrate the entire Sorby line 2 weeks ago. He said that if you chip the edge, it was alright to regrind it, but that you then must, and he emphasised must, polish out all the grind marks and return the bright shine to the tool. He verified your thought that the shine was the secret to the tool. When he passed the tool around to the group for inspection, I thought that the edge wasn't what I would call sharp, but it sure was shiney.

Re: spindlemaster

#7

Re: spindlemaster

Russ Fairfield

>The Spindlemaster and the Skewchi Gouge are old tools that predated the spindle gouge and have now been re-introduced. The problem is that they are too often claimed to be the answer to all spindle turning problems. They are not. The reality is that they are just another cutting edge that obeys all of the same rules as other cutting tools.

In my opinion these tools will not do anything that can't done with a spindle gouge that has been ground to the same angle and whose bevel has been buffed to the same polish. They also obey the same rules as the fluted spindle gouge.

The first of those rules is that the higher the polish on the bevel, the finer the cutting edge, the sharper the cutting edge, and the better it will cut.

The 2nd of those rules is that the less the bevel angle the more agressive the tool, the better the cut, and the smoother the surface; BUT the more aggressive tool is more difficult to control and that makes it more difficult to use without getting a "catch".

I am referring to the "bevel angle" as being that angle of solid steel between the bevel and the top of the tool or the bottom of the flute.

The opposite is also true and the greater the bevel angle angle, the less agressive the tool and the easier the tool will be to control and the less likely to catch, BUT the cut will be rougher and the surface left on the wood will be rougher. The 45-degree bevel angle is a good compromise between control and surface smoothness.

The problem with either of these tools is that they come with a very shallow bevel angle of 25 to no more than 30-degrees, and they are always demonstrated by expert woodturners. The tool with the polished bevel and a low angle will impress the Hell out of the audience, but it is a tool that a very few of them are experienced enough to use. The same would be true for a spindle gouge with the same angle and the same polish. It will take the others a few years of practice before they can get same results as the Sorby demonstrator.

My suggestion is to always practice with the spindle gouge that you have, and then practice some more. Start with a 45 or 50-degree bevel angle, and then grind a shallower angle as you are more proficient with the tool. Start polishing the bevel with a felt wheel and rouge, and see the difference. Get a lesson from someone who knows how to use one of them if you must.

And, most important, don't expect the Spindlemaster or the Skewchi Gouge to be the quick answer and a short cut to better spindle turning.

Re: spindlemaster

#8

Re: The Spindlemaster is a waste of HSS!

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: spindlemaster

#9

Re: spindlemaster

robert davis

>

Re: spindlemaster

#10

Re: The Spindlemaster is a waste of HSS!

Bruce Wiseman

>Well on the other side of the fence, I have one and often use it on my finishing cut making pens. Think of the tip of the tool as 12 oclock and slightly tip it and cut either between 1 oclock to 3 oclock or between 9 and 11. (depends on the direction of cut) Rub the bevel as you cut. I won't deny that you can get just as good a cut with a very sharp schew. I personally find the spindlemaster quicker to sharpen, maybe 5 or 6 strokes with a diamond file and it is good to go. As awalys, your mileage may vary.

Re: spindlemaster

#11

Re: Bevel

Duane C.Leach

>When the Sorby Rep demonstrated this tool the bevel was not only polished but also the bevel was convex,rather than hollow ground.

Duane