Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

cordless drill

Posts

cordless drill

#1

cordless drill

Darryl Hansen

>Getting tired of tangling my drill cord that I use to put faceplates on with. Cordless drills seem to have two different types of batteries. Ni Cad and Nimh . which is better best why? thanks in advance for what I am certain will be many responses...Darryl

Re: cordless drill

#2

Re: cordless drill

Bill Howatt

>They each have their own characteristics but the most obvious thing is that NiCads are the old technology and NimH are the new technology. NimH batteries typically have more power storage but will self-discharge faster than NiCads (just sitting around they go flat faster). Batteries, like regular alkaline batteries have a very, very long self-discharge time - measured in years.

The NiCads aren't as bad for self-discharging and they have trait called memory. If you draw only a little current from them for a period they remember that and will only provide that current even though they are capable of more. That is why you see recommendations to run the device at full load and discharge the batteries and then fully charging them rather than shallow discharges and recharges.

If given a choice I would take the NimH powered tool.

Bill

Re: cordless drill

#3

Re: cordless drill

Bob Fawcett

>Darryl,

I own 2 Makita drills and one of the impact drivers. Makita makes a kit that contains both a drill and a driver that use the same NiMH packs. Sometimes you can find it on sale at a good price.

I love my Makitas. I have owned Dewalt as well and for my money the Makita is the best.

Re: cordless drill

#4

Take A Look At Panasonic Drills

Barry Turner

>I have a 10+ year old Panasonic cordless drill that I use for power sanding bowls. It's top speed is 1500 RPM which is just about ideal with a 2" foam pad and sanding disc.

My drill is only 9.6 volts and has old-technology NiCad batteries, but is quite adequate for the task. I think either of the cordless drills you mentioned would be quite adequate. If my drill croaks, I may go for a 12-volt or maybe even a 14.4. Actually, the 9.6 works very well and is not so heavy.

I know it's not a s popular as some of the other brands, but don't sell the Panasonic short. They are leaders in cordless drill and battery technology. They may look like hair dryers, but they are one tough drill. The new ones are even smaller and more compact than mine.

Re: cordless drill

#5

Re: cordless drill

Allen Neighbors

>I have two Porter Cable 12V cordless drills (NiMH). My son (uses cordless drills all the time) instructed me to put the batteries in the charger when it begins to show weakness. I obeyed. I've had them for about 5 years, and love them.

I used one of them today to drive 3.5" long 1/4" lag screws into the rafters on my trailerport. 24 lag screws. Had to change the battery once.

Re: cordless drill

#6

Re: cordless drill

Bill Howatt

>Good advice. When you see references to cycle the batteries and to charge them when discharged they do not mean the batteries are dead flat. Exhausting batteries to this state is hard on them.

Bill

Re: cordless drill

#7

Re: cordless drill

Allen Neighbors

>You're right, Bill, I ruined 2 little cylinder batteries on a lightweight screwdriver, by making sure they were completely drained.

I'm a slow learner. :o) But I did learn. :o)