Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Holdfast Vacuum Chucking System

Posts

Holdfast Vacuum Chucking System

#1

Holdfast Vacuum Chucking System

Rick Davenport

>I did a search for holdfast here, but nothing came up.

Does anyone use one?

Do you like it?

Hate it?

Why?

Thanks,

R

Re: Holdfast Vacuum Chucking System

#2

Re: Holdfast Vacuum Chucking System

Rick Allen

>I think there are some messages you might search for to get a feel for what those who have thoughts about this system have expressed.

My memory says that this is a noisy system which wears out you air compressor.

I have seen other venturi vacuum systems is use. The venturi is noisy even if you can't hear the compressor run (because the compressor is in a different room with sound suppression).

Good Luck

Re: Holdfast Vacuum Chucking System

#3

Re: Holdfast Vacuum Chucking System

Russ Fairfield

>The only thing different is the source of the vacuum. The spindle attachment is a commercial adaptation of something that many woodturners have made been making for themselves for a long time.

The venturi has been use for many years with vacuum bags for laminating veneers to all manner of objects. It does require an air compressor that will peobably run continuously while the vacuum chuck is being used, the vacuum will be less than that with a dedicated vacuum pump, and the noise of the escaping air will make you want to wear ear protection.

My opinion, for what it's worth, is that it would be a reasonable way to get a vacuum chuck if you already have an air compressor that is up to the job. The problem is that the requirement of air tools is always understated and the capacity of air compressors is always overstated. To me, "up to the job" is an advertised compressor capacity that is twice what is recommended by the manufacturer of the tool. When they say 2.5 CFM at 50 PSI for the tool, what you really need is 5 CFM at 100 PSI.

If you have to buy an air compressor, them a dedicated vacuum pump is a less expensive way to get a vacuum. These are often available for less than $100 without a motor, and less than $150 with the motor.

Re: Holdfast Vacuum Chucking System

#4

Re: Holdfast Vacuum Chucking System

Pete LaBelle

>Be advised that if you go forward with a venturi style vacuum generator that yes, you will use a lot of air.

Be advised also that dry-sump (oil-less) air compressors are not designed for continuous running. Too much heat builds up and seals will melt out. Wet sump (oiled crankcase) compressors do not have this problem.

Re: Holdfast Vacuum Chucking System

#5

Re: Holdfast Vacuum Chucking System

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Rick,

Ask me again in about a week. I ordered one a couple of days ago and should have it in a day or so.

I only did so, because I use one infrequently, but I now have a large 80gal Oil-sump compressor. I can sell my current vacuum system and pretty much break even, and end up with a vacuum system that I can put in a drawer.

I saw one last April and the WC gathering in N. Georgia, and it was pretty quiet. Especially when compared to the old vacuum pump I am using.

Mark

Re: Holdfast Vacuum Chucking System

#6

Re: Holdfast Vacuum Chucking System *LINK*

Juergen

>I made one of these a few years back using the guts of the part below.

http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/ctaf/displayitem.taf?Itemnumber=92475

It works fine. I've got it hanging on the pegboard wall waiting for that 80 Gal, 15 CFM, 2 stage, 10 HP, Oil lubricated compressor. Even though it works well it's VEEry noisy. So until the good fairy shows up with a compressor I'm using a shop vacuum and some PVC fittings. I haven't dropped a piece of the lathe in 10 years. The cool thing about the shop vac setup is that it's High Volume Low Pressure. Bark inclusion and other leaks are not a problem.


Air Vacuum Pump

Re: Holdfast Vacuum Chucking System

#7

Gast pump option *LINK*

Russ Babbitt

>It does require 220v but is one of the cheaper vacuum pump options available. I would suggest searching Ebay for good used pumps.


Surplus Center

Re: Holdfast Vacuum Chucking System

#8

Re: Holdfast Vacuum Chucking System

Rick Davenport

>Thanks for the comments everyone.

I do have a compressor that would be up to the task.

I'm just curiuos about whether the Holdfast system is viable, or just cheaper than the alternative.

R