Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

How unusual is this?

Posts

How unusual is this?

#1

Ellis Walentine

How unusual is this?

Ellis Walentine

>Here's a shot of a poplar tree I took down yesterday. How unusual do you think this kind of figure is? And will these colors last once I turn it?

Cheers,

Ellis


img

Re: How unusual is this?

#2

Re: How unusual is this?

Ron in Drums PA

>Really Nice

There is only one way to find out if the colors will last.

That is, send it to me and I'll keep tabs on it for you along with monthly updates.

Does that work for you?

Re: How unusual is this?

#3

Re: How unusual is this?

Cyril Griesbach

>Ellis, it's unusual alright. My guess on the colors is that, over time, they will blend into an homogonous brown much like box elder will with time. However, looking at the bark on this...it just doesn't look like poplar to me. Looking forward to seeing a finished piece from this log.

Cyril

Re: How unusual is this?

#4

Re: How unusual is this?

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Ellis, I see this in quite a few of cut poplars, in fact there are logs on my property waiting to become firewood that have this same coloration /pattern in them - these particular logs are no good for turning as the trunk was badly cracked otherwise they'd be turning blanks by now. I do not know what the cause is, nor how well the color retention will be, but I do know that around here that type of pattern in poplar is not unusual.

Re: How unusual is this?

#5

Re: How unusual is this?

Ray Johnson

>Hurry and turn something from it. I would bet that we all would like to see some pictures.

Re: How unusual is this?

#6

Re: How unusual is this?

Pete Kekel - Kentucky

>I've seen even more vivid purple colors in some Poplar logs and the end result is different shades of brown after an oil finish and some exposure to light. Some of the red staining in Poplar will stay longer, but in my experience the purple becomes brown.

Re: How unusual is this?

#7

Re: How unusual is this?

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I've been a carpenter for 35 years. We use a lot of poplar for painted trim and door jambs. I see a lot of colors like this. Poplar can have green,brown, purple, or black steaks in it. I don't think that they fade much, but the cream colored wood will darken with prolonged exposure, and mute the contrast in time. Keep it out of the direct sunlight and the color contrast should last a long time.

Re: How unusual is this?

#8

Ellis Walentine

Re: How unusual is this?

Ellis Walentine

>Thanks, folks. I've turned some purple poplar myself in the past and as Pete says, it goes brown over time. But this log has a riot of color going on. Maybe a water white finish and keeping it out of direct sunlight will preserve that. Only one way to find out... :-)

Ellis

Re: How unusual is this?

#9

Re: How unusual is this?

Robin Corell in Atacsadero CA

>I used to see those colors fairly often in pattern wood. the purples and to a lesser extent the greens are fairly light fast. We used to hate working the stuff with the extreme color as it often had a rather foul scent.

Robin Corell

Re: How unusual is this?

#10

I have absolutely.... *LINK*

Thad in Wartown

>...no idea, but I'd post on WoodWeb.com's sawing & drying forum and ask Dr. Wengert's opinion. He'd know what causes it, which could lend itself to knowing how to best work with it.

Hope this helps

~ Thad


WoodWeb's Sawing & Drying Forum

Re: How unusual is this?

#11

Re: How unusual is this?

Denis Putland from Saskatchewan

>Hi

When I see a poplar with that type of coloring in my part of the world I can almost guarantee you that you will find worm damage or much less likely some other sort of physical damage in the past life of that tree.

Most of the logs with the colored wood is only suitable for fire wood due to cracks and rot.

But keep looking for those older dying poplars as there is some nice colored poplar if you catch it at just the right time.

You are very unlikely to find much color in a young healthy poplar tree.

Denis

Re: How unusual is this?

#12

Re: How unusual is this?

Jim King

>This may or maynot be of interest.

Jim,wood id mihaly.htm

The development of color in heartwood is just the tip of the

iceberg, as it were, of the chemical changes that take place during

transition from sapwood to heartwood, but it is something that we can

easily notice and appreciate. The role of these chemical changes is to

make the wood tissue chemically protected and physically sealed for

durability and resistance to insects and fungi.

There are 200-300 secondary metabolites, chemicals other than DNA,

sugar, proteins and players of essential metabolism, in any plant

tissue, including wood. Heartwood is special in that there is no DNA,

sugar, proteins or nitrogen left in it since it is dead tissue. These

chemicals were produced as the last act of plant metabolism in these

tissues. They are the products of dozens of biochemical programs,

encoded in DNA, and they run simultaneously, sometimes competing, their

relative speed depending on environmental (including minerals, stress,

and pathogens) and internal factors (genetic program in DNA). The end

result is, depending on the species, is a more or less uniform or very

variegated heartwood color. But there are always at least some of all

the chemicals present. It is their relative proportion and distribution

that changes, giving rise to visible patterns of color, patterns of

fragrance and invisible patterns of chemical deposition.

Stress from drought, mineral deficiency, abundance, and most

importantly the constant attack by borers and fungus causes multitudes

of chemical responses in the wood and mostly this is what causes the

patterns. The color pattern is a visual snapshot of combat situations

and moving fighting fronts frozen for eternity at the time of heartwood

formation. Plants have a lot of chemical defenses that act like

immunity. Colored substances often tend to react with DNA, hence the

color in wood.

Minerals may contribute but not as much as the layman's notion.

Plants regulate what they take up by their roots and only few chemicals

can be taken up in excess.

When the defenses of wood are broken, spalting happens. Spalting also

produces colors which are a combined result of the sapwood and the

microbe, therefore more colors may be produced then what the tree alone

could produce, and this may be specific to a given location or unique.

Many fungus are colored themselves, most have melanin that appears

bluish or black, brown.

I use chemical fingerprinting to distinguish and classify samples but I

still use a microtome to make thin sections for microscopy when I

already have a guess. As I said, the information on wood anatomy and

plant diversity of the region is insufficient and spread between

hundreds of articles and books, so keying out a species is not

instantaneous to say the least. But I am better prepared for legumes

and

especially Dalbergia and Machaerium because I already have done the

literature research.

We should be mindful of the sensitivities of the local botanists and

should observe the local regulations. On the long term this study would

ideally benefit the local or national university in the form of

herbarium material and shared data, and should not appear as

exploitation. Just how to go about it should be sensibly worked out.

Pink woods: Truly clear pink woods are rare and therefore valuable.

Pink ivory is a deep pink wood, often without figure.

But even in Peru there should be some tulipwood (Dalbergia

decipularis),

which is streaked with pink. Then you have bloodwood (Brosimum) which

could be deep red or purplish pink, like your rainbow wood. I also

expect Simira, which is brick red in the heartwood, but neon pink in

the

sapwood or wherever you break the epidermis. Then Aspidosperma, which

in

Colombia produces neon pink with some yellow splashes.

I cannot immediately recall more. Most other woods are not pure pink.

Pure purple colors are also not common. Peltogyne is outstanding of

course. But queenwood is remarkable with its magenta colors even though

it mutes into brown.

More later.

Re: How unusual is this?

#13

Re: Looks like Ambrosia poplar to me.

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: How unusual is this?

#14

Re: How unusual is this?

Matt Prusik

>Ellis:

That log is exhibiting mineral stain. It's a known defect in poplar that takes logs and lumber out of NHLA FAS grade and moves them into a No. 1 Common grade.

By the way, that type of poplar is okay to use when the customer specifies "paint grade" for his final work. Modern primers and colored top coats will cover up the stain just fine.

No doubt it's pretty and would make a spectacular turned object providing you can keep the color. I think you're right on "tinkering" with the finish. And if you used some sort of clear varnish, lacquer or other type with UV protection and perhaps a drop of purple dye to tone the finish, you might get it to stay looking that way for a long time. Otherwise it will just go muddy brown.

Best of luck and thnaks for sharing.

Matt Prusik