Re: New Thompson tools
Fog Tanner
>I have been using one of The Thompson gouges for the past several weeks, a 5/8" "V" flute. I took it straight out of the package, yes they come in a plastic container and not wrapped in newspaper, put it in the Kelton handle that came with my McNaughton tool. It was the only tool that I have ever got that was sharp out of the box. I roughed out a 19" Pecan bowl and was into the next before I even thought of sharpening it. I have a Henry Taylor that I been using and was going to compare the two, but very quickly there became no comparison and I left the Henry Taylor for the light work. I will say that from past experience, I am not going to the grinder as often. I did sharpen The Thompson on my Tormek and got it too sharp , it would really take the wood off - a little too much, so I went back to a 100grit dry grinder. I think I just needed a larger/longer handle. But, I also wanted to see if I could sharpen it on my Tormek, got a razor sharp edge with a polished bevel - no scratch marks.
It comes with basicly an Ellsworth grind and is usable without doing anything to it. Our club has bought six for our Spring Retreat raffel and I had a chance to compare some of the various sized Thompsons agaisnt my Henry Taylor. The Thompson 1/2" gouge is about 1 1/2"-1 3/4" longer than the Henry Taylor when measuring the flutes. And the whole tool is hardened so you get that much more flute, but you also have some material for a short half round scraper when you grind the flute away. The 3/8" is also longer but I don't remember the length. The last 2" is gound to size (i.e. 1/2", 3/8", etc), as the rest is slightly oversize (around .015). And I love the gun metal blue finish, they really stand out amonst the other tools.
There is more metal under the flute than the Henry Taylor or a Jerry Glaser. This is true of both the "V" and the "U" shaped flutes. I also compared the Detail gouges and they are similar in shape to the P&N, but unlike the P&N (which are excellent tools) The Thompson comes sharpened.
After a small show and tell at the last club meeting, we place another order for some more Thompsons. Everyone that ordered a bowl gouge had to have a detail gouge also (one member ordered two). I now have a box of steel and after looking at the 5/8" "U" shaped gouge one of the members ordered, I am going to have to have one of those too. I had gotten the 1/2" "U" (along with a 3/8" detail), and after looking at these "U" shapes, these are not wimpy gouges like some of the others I have seen. There is some steel under the flute. The Thompson basicly takes the next step where Galser stopped. The radius at the bottom of the flute is larger, more steel under the flute, the finish is smooth and not peened so it slides easier, and LOTS more usable steel.
Right now, I am waiting for the spindle gouges that Doug is coming out with. I do a lot of spindle work and would like to have some 3/8" and 1/2" gouges that I didn't need to sharpen so much. But that also means several of each for the various bevel angels. I also have a prototype tool (non gouge) that I will pass on as soon as I can get a handle on it and try it out. But, I already know it will work great.
And you can't find a better or more trusting guy to do business with than Doug. He has brought us a great tool at a very fair price. As long as these tools last and the prices he is charging, I don't see him buying up an island in the South Pacific anytime soon. He took the Jerry Glaser gouge and made it better, and was kind enough to share it with the rest of us. I know I will be buying Thompson tools as long as he will keep making them. Now if the price of flat stock will just come down so he can make a skew.....................
Fog