Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

new bandsaw

Posts

new bandsaw

#1

new bandsaw

Don Evans

>I'm in the market for new bandsaw and cannot decide if the extra cost of the minimax may be worth it.

One problem is not being able to actually see one of them in person.

Boiled down to the 16" (there are 2 of them) one $1900.00 the other $2500.00.

Only thing I can see locally is the Jet 18" and it is a nice machine but price is really great $1200.00 (normally $1350.00.

The Jet is all the machine I'll ever need in capacity but I've learned the hard way that weight of a bandsaw is very important.

I've suffered with a 16" Grizzly for 15 years and I don't want the same problems again, out of balance wheels that don't run true, new ones do same thing etc other than that it cuts good once you get past the shaking.

Anyone out there with these saws that have comments on their performance. I'm sure the $2500.00 mini is a safe bet but is it that much better than the other mini for $600.00 less?

Don

Re: new bandsaw

#2

Re: new bandsaw

Rick Pixley

>Check out that one Woodcraft has,I can't think of the name right now as I'm having a senior moment..A friend has one and is very happy with it..I have a LagunaEastern European made) and in retrospect I could have gotten the Woodcraft model for far less and it has at least as good of features as my Laguna and probably has better customer service, in the sales areas at least...Rick

Re: new bandsaw

#3

Andy DiPietro

Re: new bandsaw *LINK*

Andy DiPietro

>Check out the Rikon 18" at Woodcraft and read the two reviews in the attached link.


http://www.toolcenter.com/rikon/10-345-18_BANDSAW.

Re: new bandsaw

#4

Re: new bandsaw

Glenn Hodges, Nashville, GA

>Don, I just bought the Steel City 20" Bandsaw on ebay. I am very happy with it.

Re: new bandsaw

#5

Re: new bandsaw

robo hippy

>For me, it was a question of how high and how deep do I want to cut.I think that bandsaws models should be labeled like lathes; a 3520 lathe is 20 inch diameter, and 35 inch between centers. My bandsaw should be 1615, cuts 16 high, and 15 deep. I got the bandsaw for preping bowl blanks from logs. It has cut the prep time in half, and the turning time has gone down because the blanks are much more even and balanced than the chainsawn ones. Bandsaws that are cutting up to 12 inches high should have a 2 hp motor or better for heavy use. I got the heavy duty Laguna with a 4.5 hp motor, and it will cut 16 high with no problem as long as my blade is sharp. I seldom turn bowls more than 16 high, but some times I would like to go to 20 inches, so I may sell the one I have, and get another bigger one. If you buy a bit more than you figure you need, you won't be disappointed.

Oh yes, I did concrete work for 30 years, and tend to like things over built. Better safe than sorry.

robo hippy

Re: new bandsaw

#6

Re: new bandsaw

Roger T

>Hi Don,

I just finished fine tuning a MiniMax 20 bandsaw. You definately cannot go wrong with one of the Italian made saws. Be it Laguna or MiniMax. Almost 5 HP. Ample table space, though, for turning blanks, I wish it had more table on the operator side of the blade. I put a 16" piece of semi-wet maple on mine this weekend, and feed it as quickly as I thought was prudent. I still believe I could have fed it faster. NO hesitations, hickups or anything. Just raw cutting power.

I had my mind pretty much made up after doing research for a week or so. MiniMax has stellar customer service. Laguna on the other hand, from what I have read has less than desireable CS. I cant speak for the other brands, but there are some awfully nice machines available now.

When I ordered mine, they gave it to me for what is now their show price, plus threw in the mobility kit, and 3 carbon steel blades any size you want.

If you would like to talk more about the MM, please feel free to contact me, just remove (no spam) in the email addy.

Roger

Re: new bandsaw

#7

LeNeave Machinery ...

Ed Moore

>in Charlotte, North Carolina carries the North State line, which is in-house. I purchased a 21" 3 HP machine from the several years ago and have been EXTREMELY pleased with it. The price was very fair and the bandsaw that I received compares favorably with some of the imports.

A friend who has a Laguna bandsaw saw this saw and said that he wished that he had gotten the Northstate instead of the Laguna. Everyone I know who took my advice and got this saw is very pleased with what they got.

I recommend that you call them 800-442-2302 and ask for the Ed Moore discount. I am only a happy customer and am not involved with LeNeave in any way.

Ed

Re: new bandsaw

#8

Jet 20"

Peter Teubel

>I bought a Jet 20" (2hp) 2 years ago. Very satisfied with it. VERY smooth, built very stout. No vibration to speak of. A full 12" cutting height.

The only downside I have found is the bearings in the upper and lower guides are shielded, not SEALED bearings (total of 10). I had to replace 5 of them within two months due to seizure. I didn't bother to get Jet replacements; instead got SEALED bearings from a local bearing supply house ($5 each). No problems since.

The trunions are still cast zinc or something (not iron), but they seem to hold up fine. I've sawn ALOT of blanks on this saw (gone thru at least 50 blades) and it's still working as good as the day I bought it.

How is it for really fine precise work? I dunno. I use it 99% of the time for cutting bowl blanks. More than adequate for the job.

Re: new bandsaw

#9

Re: I replaced my old Delta .....

Jamie Donaldson

>... with a MM S45 2 yrs. ago and wish I had done it sooner. The saw was a show demo and saved on the shipping- I believe the salesman who took such good care of me was named Sam. Love that power!

Re: new bandsaw

#10

Re: new bandsaw

dwr

>Don,

Don't spend you money on the Jet 18. I have one and wish I had bought the MM. However, I was buying several tools and chose to "save" on the Jet.

Why:

Way underpowered (1.5 hp) and blows a dedicated 20AMP circuit on a moderately heavy cut. No way it will take large bowl blanks with ease. I have looked at replacing the 1.5 hp motor with a 3+hp but found that my motor shaft is a weird non-standard diameter... which means my lower band wheel is also the same weird diameter... so, no motor switching for me.

Changing blades is a PIA. You have to go in from the front and then twist the blade to the side to get it on the wheels and into the guides... major design flaw. Should slide straight in from the side... just plain dumb.

Bad manual tensioning location reduces depth of cut... but worse yet, no quick way to "untension" the blade...(no aftermarket kits either) have to crank like the devil to lower the wheel to reduce tension.

Table will not stay put as secure as you would expect or like.

Insert recess is poorly machined and, on mine at least, I have to live with a lip that catches material (very dangerous), shim the insert, (PIA), or make a custom one each time I need one (another PIA).

Guide bearings are basically disposable. You will need to replace them frequently or, as said before with a sealed set.

Adjustment cap screws under the table for moving the bearing assembly are nearly impossible to access, which makes going between blade widths a nightmare.

Only one dust collection chute, so get ready to clean the lower housing frequently, as it does a better job of collecting dust than the chute.

I could go on.... but for anything that will place a demand (frequency or load) the Jet 18" is just an expensive hobby saw.

I have seen Trent Bosch use a little Delta with a riser block and a replaced motor (3hp I believe) and he rips through a blank like crazy... with more height capacity for a tad more the 1/2 the price... go figure.

Just my experiences...

Re: new bandsaw

#11

Re: new bandsaw

John Scheideman

>Don,

I bought the MiniMax 16" two years ago. I haven't regretted the decision for a second. I did a lot of research on bandsaws before buying. The saw is very well built, sturdy, and cuts through anything. I now cut turning blanks with ease. They have upgraded the 16" a little since I bought. It now has a little more height and I think slightly more power. The MiniMax people are the best I have ever dealt with. They stand behind their machines better than any company I have ever seen. They even correspond more than a year later to see if I'm still a happy customer. Who else in the business does that? They are super friendly when you do call with questions. And they are willing to deal a little....throw in a few extras, etc.

My only complaints about the bandsaw are 1.) it is too low to the floor for me (I set it up on a platform and it is MUCH easier on my back) and 2.) you have to adjust the lower guide assembly when you tilt the table. However, it was made that way so that the lower guides would be closer to the cutting action than other bandsaws...so it is a trade-off. Better guidance for a little more fussing when you want to tilt the table.

I dealt with Carl Hultquist. His phone number is 1-866-551-6868 and his email is chultquist@minimax-usa.com. Super nice guy to work with. Tell him I sent you!!

I don't have any affiliation with MiniMax other than being a very satisfied customer. Feel free to email me if you have other questions. Hope this helps in your decision.

John

Re: new bandsaw

#12

Re: new bandsaw

Don Evans

>Thanks much to all that responded. Especially you guys with the MM, that was what I wanted to hear from.

The Jet is really tempting but I can look at it and the Rikon and others and tell that that they all are pretty much the same machine and many from same factory. For example the Rikon and Jet use the same knobs on the doors and other things also.

Now if I could just fine out more between the two MM's and I the writeup on there web page says the $2500 MM has 3 supports in the column and the $1900.00 one has 2, but wonder what that really means in stability and performance. The table tilt isn't big deal and adjusting the bearings.

Next call is to MM and start talking specifics with them. I'll have to go back and look again at the S45 as cannot remember what the difference was. Plenty of time and I know this is my last BS for life so I want to make the right decision.

Thanks much to all.

Don

Re: new bandsaw

#13

Re: new bandsaw

Don Evans

>Just FYI the Jet 18" I'm looking at has the 3hp motor on it, it's at the Woodworking Shop in Raleigh (Klingspor) location.

Don

Re: new bandsaw

#14

Re: new bandsaw

Russ Fairfield

>You will have to make your own decisions based on what you want to be cutting and how thick. I have been looking at a new bandsaw, and I have a few comments about my search, for what they are worth.

My problem is that I cut big wood, and my problem with all of these less expensive 18" and 20" bandsaws is that they will only cut 12" deep under the guides. The only thing the 18" and 20" saws by Jet, Ricon, Grizzly, and a few others have to offer is a larger table and more power. The 18" MM has a 12" vertical capacity. Grizzly used to make a 20" saw with 15" vertical capacity, but they chose to discontinue that model. To me, it isn't worth spending the money just for a larger table and a bigger motor when they have no larger vertical sawing capacity than the 12" I have with my old Delta with a riser block. Actually the Delta is only 11" but I want more than an extra inch.

The old 18" Jet had 1.5HP which was too small. The new one has 2HP, but 3 is available and that is good, but it is still limited to 12" under the top guide.

I have replaced the motor on the Delta with 3hp and it cuts through 11" fine and without stalling. I constantly complain about the small table, but haven't gotten mad enough to by a new saw just for the larger table and 1 more inch of capacity.

Unless they have added something within the past couple months, the Jet doesn't have a tension release lever and I think this is an absolute necessity for a saw with a 3/4" or 1" blade.

I will have to go with the 20" MM or one of the Laguna specials to get larger than 12" under the guides, but those saws will cost me about $3,400 plus shipping. So far I haven't wanted to cut larger wood on the bandsaw badly enough to spend that kind of money, so I keep on using the old Delta and cussing at the small table.