Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Roughing out Bowl?

Posts

Roughing out Bowl?

#1

Roughing out Bowl?

Jake (SoMN)

>All,

Had some people over to the shop this weekend for a get together. We decided to turn a green bowl as a group.

I then proceeded to circle cut the blank on the bandsaw and mount it between centers on the lathe.

Here is my question. I proceeded to rough the outside the bowl with a 1/2" bowl gouge. As always, this takes quite a bit of time. A couple of the guys said I should have a rouging gouge to perform this operation. It will work faster and better. It was my understanding that one should never use a roughing gouge on a bowl due to the smaller tang.

What do all of you use to rough out a bowl?

Thanks for your assistance.

Jake D

(remove the 2 for email)

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#2

Steven Antonucci

Bowl Gouge

steve antonucci

>Roughing with a bowl gouge should not take very long at all on green wood. I use a side ground bowl gouge starting at the foot with the lathe as fast as prudent.

I can do this in under 2 minutes if motivated.

Steven

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#3

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

Greg Haugen

>Never ever use a roughing gouge (SRG) on a bowl, period. Whoever said that, slap them in the back of the head next time you see them. Kidding, somewhat.

A few pointers-Use a 1/2" bowl gouge to turn a bowl. If the grind is a swept back or irish grind you can remove alot more material faster if your lathe has the horses to make it happen. If you're turn on a jet mini you won't take a 1/2" to 3/4" shavings no matter what gouge you use. Between centers? If you're using a drive center and a live center there are better, more efficient ways to do this. Screwing a face plate to the bowl blank or I like to use the woodworm screws that comes with the chucks. Drill a hole in the center of the bowl and thread the bowl on the screw when its in your chuck. Make sure the blank seats against the top of the jaws. Either one of these options you can bring up the tailstock for trueing the blank. After its trued I take away the tailstock so I have more room and better "gouge" angles. Makes life alot easier. If you have it between centers you can't get rid of the tailstock until you're ready for the chuck with a tenon.

Where in Southern MN are you?

Hope it helps,

Greg

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#4

Re: Bowl Gouge

John Lucas

>Jake Steve said it right. I used to wear myself out roughing bowls. Now I start at the foot and work my way toward the rim. This gives you a solid section for the gouge to ride on at the beginning of the cut. This not only reduces the bouncing but lets you take a bigger cut.

I use what Is called a pull cut for doing the bottom. It lets you take a big bite and is very safe. If you can get the video of Stewart Batty and Mike Mahoney it shows this cut very well and they are really funny. I think Bill Grumbines video shows it also but I don't remember for sure. He and I have the same style of cutting so I'm pretty sure that it does show that in the video.

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#5

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

Bill Neddow

>If you are turning small bowls (12 inches or under) use a bowl gouge. The bigger the bowl, the bigger the gouge. I would never use a 1/2 inch bowl gouge on a 12 inch bowl -- it is too small and takes too much time. Use a 5/8 inch.

Mount it on a face plate, and use a pull cut, starting from the center where the base will be.

Now, into the dispute over using spindle roughing gouges on the outsides of bowls. The "accepted wisdom" out there is only partially correct. Yes, you must not use a standard roughing gouge. The little rat tail tine on most of them should be banned as being unsafe. If it was a drug, or an electrical device, it would have been pulled from the market by now. I have a picture in my files of a friend's gouge, bent in half turning spindles -- and he is not an aggressive turner. But, instead of banning them and forcing the companies to produce a better device, we protect the companies and endanger turners by adding "caveats" to the use of the tool. Is it possible to make a safe and reasonably priced tool. P&N has had one on the market for years, and a design similar to that should be made mandatory for anyone selling roughing gouges.

Can the flaw be fixed on existing roughing gouges. Yes. Cut the tine off. Put a piece of 5/8 inch drill rod in the flute, and have SOMEONE WHO REALLY KNOWS HOW TO WELD actually weld them together with a mig arc welder using mind steel wire. That is the advice I have had from two different metallurgists from different parts of the country.

Use it with a push cut, starting from the center, where the spigot will be. Ride the bevel on the right side of the tool, and cut with the bottom of the flute, or sometimes with the bottom and a bit of the left side. Riding the bevel keeps the tool from falling or getting sucked into the big gaps you have when the tool is not touching the wood. If you have the wood properly screwed on a faceplate, you can remove a lot of wood in a hurry. I normally turn 18" to 30" bowls and can reduce my turning time by about 70 per cent on the outside of a bowl using this method.

Now, one "caveat" for this technique. Do not try to use a roughing gouge on the inside of a bowl. It is not shaped for that and you will get a big catch;.

On the outside of the bowl, the rouging gouge works best while you are making the block of wood round. Once the tool is touching all the way around, switch over to a bowl gouge. It will be faster this way.

Now I sit back and await the reaction. This does work, and used as descrribed, is not dangerous. I rough abut 800 large bowls a year and have been doing it for close to 10 years. I have never bent a modified roughing gouge.

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#6

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

Glenn Hodges, Nashville, GA

>I also use a P&N tool to rough out bowls it is their 7/8 inch Supa Bowl Gouge. It will move a lot of wood fast, and you do not have to worry about it breaking.

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#7

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

Russ Fairfield

>A useful tool for making an unbalanced piece of wood into something round is the straight tool in the McNaughton tool set. One plunge cut into the solid wood and it is round.

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#8

Re: Roughing out Bowl? *LINK*

Darrell Feltmate

>I use an Oland tool but would use a bowl gouge over a roughing gouge for bowls any day of the week. Take a look at web site for more on roughing with the Oland.


Around the Woods: Roughing a Bowl

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#9

You're insane. And should know better. Period!

Angelo I.

>

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#10

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

Russ Fairfield

>There are some turning practices and techniques that should be confined to the inside of our shop when we are alone and nobody is watching because they are inherently dangerous in the hands of the beginner or intermediate woodturner. Turning a bowl with a roughing gouge is one of those things that we should keep to ourselves.

I agree with Bill in that we can use a roughing gouge on the outside of a bowl, but only IF we can obey the first 5 of the "Six Laws of Woodturning" as decribed in Keith Rowley's book. IF we can obey those same 5 laws while keeping the tips of the wings away from the wood, we could also turn the inside of the bowl. Those are two very big IF's, and there are only a very few woodturners who can qualify.

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#11

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

bowlman

>What is an Oland tool? What are its advantages/disadvantages as compared to ther tools?

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#12

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I agree with those that have said that a roughing gouge can safely be used on the outside of a bowl. BUT only in the hands of an expert. The problem with giving this sort of advice is that in the hands of an inexperienced turner that practice is dangerous. I have seen several roughing gouges that were bent almost double. I saw one roughing gouge that had been bent and the tang torn right through the side of the handle. The turner was injured and required surgery on his hand.

The bowl gouge is a tool that was designed for the job and does it very well.

Wally

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#13

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

robo hippy

>I used to use a bowl gouge for all of my roughing, but have switched to a scraper. I had wondered how some people could turn a bowl strictly with scrapers, and thought I would try. In the process, I discovered that the scraper is an excellent tool for all of the rough work and shaping. I still get better finish cuts with the gouge, but can remove wood much faster with a scraper. It also has the advantage of being able to cut on push and pull cuts, so you don't have to stop and move back to the top of the cut. A 1 1/4 inch scraper can really remove a lot of wood in a hurry.

robo hippy

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#14

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

John Lucas

>If you watch Mike Mahoney or John Jordan turn a bowl, they take off 1/2" in a single pass with virtually no tear out. I'm not there yet but can take a pretty big bite most of the time. I think this is faster and much more controllable than a scraper. I grew up with scrapers because I didn't own a bowl gouge and thought that you used big scrapers on the inside and rough out gouge or spindle gouge on the outside. I had some horrendous catches but thought that was part of the game.

I now use a bowl gouge, sometimes with different grinds. I don't agree that you have to have a bigger gouge to do a bigger bowl. I can take 1/2 deep pass across the bowl with my 1/2" bowl gouge. Usually I limit myself to a little aggresive cut. I've never been a fan of bowls flying across the shop.

I have a 5/8" and 1". I never use the 1" and only use the 5/8" because I put a reallly long handle on it and the length helps cut down on vibration in really out of round work.

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#15

Thanks..update

Jake (SoMN)

>Thanks for all the input.

I thought the two guys advocating a roughing gouge were more than a little off the mark, thanks for the confirmation.

And a point of clarification. When I said between centers, I should have said with the tailstock engaged. I either do faceplate turning or use the Oneway chuck to rough the bowl. I have just started turn bowls using the screw center to form the bottom/outside first, then flip in the chuck and turn the inside. Typically I start from the chuck side and move out to the rim when roughing

I think the major problem I am having is that I am suffering from gouge envy and just don�t have a big enough tool�.

It was great getting all the responses. Now if I can just get rid of my tear out problems I will be set.

Jake D

(Remove the 2 fro email)

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#16

i also use oland type tool,beeer yhan bowl gouge

robert davis

>i go to the bowl gouge when the blank is round

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#17

Re: You're insane. And should know better. Period!

Bill Neddow

>Angelo, turning wood involves sticking a steel bar into a spinning, irregular-shaped piece of wood -- which means that we are all a little insane :-)))

The problem with using a roughing gouge on the outside of a bowl is not at the cutting edge. It is at the tine. Even in the gruesome example Wally has cited here, the failure was at the tine and the accident occurred because the tine bent. Now, when U shaped tools had to be manufactured by blacksmiths pounding them to shape, there was no easy way to avoid making a rat-tailed tine to put the handle on. But technology has advanced. P&N is making a beautifully designed roughing gouge with a good strong tine and is selling it at a very reasonable price. We are maligning a tool, not because of its cutting abilities, but because of a fixable flaw in the manufacturing process.

I don't think the solution is to put a "Surgeon General's" warning on the tool, and in the advertising. This just allows the manufacturers to get away with making an inherently unsafe product. If you have the tool rest too far away from the wood, that tine will bend whether it is being used on a spindle or a bowl. The solution is for the tool manufacturers to stop dragging their heels, and to address a flaw in their product. I know this is not making me popular, but I feel someone has to address the problem. Using the tool and keeping quiet, as Russ suggests, is also not a solution. It is being used all over the world by beginners -- and we had better address the problem on two fronts -- fixing the inherent flaw, and education.

A prime example of how this works is the skew -- at least on the education front. Now, the skew is a great tool -- but this is the one that should have warning labels attached, if if it is going to happen to any tool. I talk to a lot of wood turners and this is the tool that has scared the living daylights out of most of them. And most of them will not use it because they have got a tremendous catch, the wood has flown off, and the chisel has ended up in the ceiling, or some other unwanted place. Would I recommend "Surgeon General" type warnings? No, I recommend some good videos, such as Alan Lacer has done, on how to use this wonderful tool safely.

I will not use a roughing gouge in my shop unless it has the tine replaced -- even for spindle work. I do not let it hang out four or five inches beyond the tool rest, whether I am working on a spindle or a bowl. I do not start by sticking the tool at the outer spinning edge or a rough piece of wood. I start at the center of the spinning disk, where the foot will be. That way, i can feel if the cut is too heavy -- as I start cutting a combination of wood and air, and back off a bit. Common sense has to prevail.

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#18

So were the Wright Brothers

Bill Howatt

>I find it disturbing when a person who has been turning for 10 years and roughs 800 large bowls a year presents a technique that obviously works is dismissed as insane. This is hardly the way to advance woodturning. I imagine when the first powered lathe was introduced to replace the spring-pole lathe there were many who thought that was insanely dangerous too.

If you don't understand why some technique works then ask for clarification and discuss it on a rational basis.

Bill

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#19

Re: You're insane. And should know better. Period!

Russ Fairfield

>The AAW efforts to change the name of the roughing gouge is a wasted effort because it will do nothing to make it a safer tool or how we use it. Advocating a change in the design and manufacture of the tool would be a substantial contribution to safer woodturning. I would like to see them take a stronger stand on this issue.

Nothing will change as long as the old-style roughing gouge is still available to us. It seems to me that the place to start would be the woodturning catalogs. If they removed all of the old style roughing gouges from their pages, and carried nothing but the P&N or similar style gouges, we would see a positive move towards a better tool. Until that happens, all we will see is a superficial name change.

I find it odd that the forged Continental-style spindle gouge, which is a smaller version of the roughing gouge, has been all but totally replaced with the spindle gouges made from a round bar, while the old style roughing gouge seems to last forever without any change. I like the Continental spindle gouges for a lot of reasons, but mine are getting short, and I will have to order any new ones from the UK because they have been discontinued from all of the US woodturning catalogs.

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#20

Re: You're insane. And should know better. Period!

George Van

>I agree Russ, I use the Henry Taylor forged HSS gouges on my spalted woods as they seem to do the best job for a skewed cut that does not pull out the fiber. They also give me a lot of sharp cutting edge to use before grinding.

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#21

Angelo I

Ron in Drums PA

>This is Angelo I's first post here. I checked.

We don't even know if he is a turner, a lurker or a troll.

My guess is he is looking to start trouble (aka troll).

Ignore him

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#22

Re: You're insane. And should know better. Period!

Bill Neddow

>You are right Russ. I spent 30 years in public relations and saw a lot of people try to solve their problems by changing the names of things, and not tackling the underlying problems that they were in trouble for in the first place. Same principle applies here. Change the product -- not the name.

Re: Roughing out Bowl?

#23

Re: Angelo I

Charles B. Watson

>Angelo may just be the President of the AAW, too!