We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>This is my latest play with the router box. This is Ash and Rosewood. I mounted the router below center to do the lid. This makes the cuts appear to spiral. I had to make a curved pattern for the router to follow to cut the lit.
>I've always wanted to try one of these and I had a small piece of spalted holly so I gave it a try. I wish I had drawn it out first. I don't like the shape of this one. The finial looks clutsy. I think the flying saucer shape should go and the ogee form should be smaller.
>I get what you're saying about the finial, but I have mixed feelings about that. If you remove/reduce those features much more, you lose some really attractive spalting elements that are drawing my interest. I guess it is a little sacrifice of one to get the other.
I like both of these. The ash/rosewood contrast is nice, but it is that spiral element that grabs me. I have this "thing" about spirals. And they are such an important form in the universe. I love how it is repeated in the top of the rosewood finial. I get the point about the fat finial on the holly, but I love the spalting and I like how the lid just flows into the base or box. Thanks for sharing these.
>John, the faceted box is terrific! Looks like you're just gonna have to build that rose engine lathe! It's nagging at you isn't it. Got yer head spinning. I'm having the same problem.
As for the finial - it needs to be a little slimmer but what is really missing is transitions between the major elements. The flying saucer shape would work better with a transition shape. Probably beads in this case. I'd also like to see the top onion come to a sharp point. To me, rounded off shapes look sloppy. Basically you got the making of a great design with the onion box. I'd keep at it until you are happy with it.
>Also, John, the way the spalting flares up it looks like a flame and the finial works with that. The shape follows the spalting (or visa versa) but I find it attractive just the way it is.
Keep in mind very thin finials are, at times, just a woodturners' challenge and not necessarily better. You done good! : )
The onion box does just what you intended. It looks like an onion, and the flying saucer mimics the dry leaf at the top of the onion. If you change the "stem" of the onion, it'll change it's looks too much. My thoughts, for what they're worth.
>I found your comments interesting. I realize thin finials are mostly for turners but sometimes they just need to be thin to flow right. In this case you might be correct on making it finial thick to show off the spalting.
I've been drooling over Rose Engine and Holzapfel lathes forever. I'll never have the time to play with one but I'll keep drooling.
I've got to stop making boxes and turn some of that Cherry I just got.
>Charlie I don't do many flatwork tool reviews. You probably have me confused with the other John Lucas who writes about flat woodworking. We talked online many years ago when the internet first got going. I think he was concerned that I was trying to step in on his name. I told him no that I was a woodturner and we just happen to have the same name. Get's confusing.
I've had death threats because there is an undercover officer named John Lucas who didn't live very far from me. Of course there is a famous basketball coach but then He's black and rich and I'm white and poor so we don't get confuse often.