Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

lathe is not a vice

Posts

lathe is not a vice

#1

lathe is not a vice

eliot d

>I attended a demonstration yesterday where the demonstrator said several times that a lathe is not a vice. He was referring to not tightening up the tail stock too much when turning between centers. Fair enough. But when I use a spur center at the headstock, I tighten up the tail stock enough to force the spur edges into the wood. So the blank really is in something like a vice. (I usually back it off a bit after I'm satisfied that the spur is grabbing OK.) Have I been doing it wrong? Should I have been hammering the spur center into the blank off the lathe?

Re: lathe is not a vice

#2

Re: lathe is not a vice

john lucas

>I use 3 techniques. When I'm mass producing spindles I cut an X with the bandsaw in the bottom. I have a jig set up to make it faster. For normal spindles I do just like you said. I simply crank the tailstock up turn a little and tighten the tailstock further.

For bowls and big spindles I tighten up the tailstock, then lock the spindle and rock the wood a little. This lets the drive center bite in a little. I tighten the tailstock and do it again. Two or three times and it's seated really good. I wouldn't rock it too hard you could damage your spingle lock.

Re: lathe is not a vice

#3

Re: lathe is not a vice

Jim Swank

>Yes, with a wooden mallet or a block of wood between the live center and hammer. That protects the end of the live center shaft from being mushroomed and damaging the bore. And only with the live center out of the lathe, to save the bearings from damage by the shock. We used to cross cut the ends of spindle stock with a backsaw back when I was a kid in school.

Re: lathe is not a vice

#4

...or get Steb centers.

Peter Teubel

>These do not require nearly as much "vice" force to bite and hold as a standard 4-prong spur. And since the center points are spring loaded, you don't have to worry about splitting the wood. Another nice feature if you have both drive and tail Stebs of the same size is the fact you can swap the work end-for-end and still maintain center.

Re: lathe is not a vice

#5

Re: lathe is not a vice

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Hi eliot,

I have done the same as you have done for years. So far... so good. My bearings are still pretty good. I now have a pretty top end lathe, but this was not always the case. But I have seen no ill effects on any of the lathes I have owned using this method. Including my Jet mini. In my practical experience it has caused no harm to my lathes or the bearings. I think sometimes people read things on the internet and in magizines and pass them along as gospel. But of course, this is just my experience. But that is really all I have to go on. :) YMMV

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: lathe is not a vice

#6

JL

Re: 2nd vote for Steb Centres...

JL

>I find the center and use my center punch off of the lathe. I then mount it on the lathe and use the tail stock to just engage the steb centre spurs. I'm eventually going to invest in the live steb centre for the tail stock.

Re: lathe is not a vice

#7

Re: lathe is not a vice

Rick Allen

>Hi Eliot

You failed to mention that Patrick was clamping his spindles in a chuck and using the tailstock for support, not as a force to maintain drive center engagement.

As far as seating your spur center in a spindle. It depends. It depends on the wood species, the size of the wood, the speed you will be turning the wood.

For a soft wood, like poplar, I will mount as you have said. Except I will not back off the tailstock. I find that the spur works it's way into the wood as I turn the wood from square to round. I find that I must advance the quill to maintain a secure hold on the workpiece.

For a harder wood like maple I will cut a corner to corner "X" on the drive end of the spindle stock and drill a small hole for the point of the spur.

I tend to favor the "safety" drive that Oneway sells. This is often called a dead cup center. I find that drilling a small hole is all the prep I need for hard woods. For soft woods a center punch will provide the dimple I use to locate the spindle between centers.

Please note that the profile of the Oneway safety center and the Oneway live center are the same. A spindle mounted between these centers can be flipped and the spindle will maintain a true running condition. Also note that dismounting and re-mounting will result in a true running workpiece. With a spur center the workpiece will likely not be running true if it is dismounted and then remounted. If you identify one of your spurs as the prim spur and mark your workpiece to indicate which notch the prime spur was in before dismounting you can re-mount the workpiece and expect it to run true. I notch the side my spur centers with the grinder to indicate which is the prime spur.

Re: lathe is not a vice

#8

Re: I suspect

Charlie Anderson

>that with you nice lathe and many tools, including multiple hollowing systems, your wife considers your lathe to be a 'vice'!

Re: lathe is not a vice

#9

Re: lathe is not a vice

eaglesc

>I understand the comment as to why a lathe is not a vice. That being said if the reason for not using the lathe as a vice is the fact that the bearings could be damaged, how did the demonstrator deal with the subjcet of the opposite force when using the knock out bar to drive something out of the Morse taper?

Would not the same damage occur if the mating piece is in there "solidly"?

Re: lathe is not a vice

#10

Re: lathe is not a vice

Jake (SoMN)

>I will engage softer woods the same way, by using the tailstock.

One should never hammer the wood into the spur when it is mounted on the lathe. The danger is that one can deform the morse taper in the headstock over time and thus its friction fit on the spur drive.

I think the impact of a hammer has much more energy than slowly pushing with the tailstock.

jake

(remove the 2 for email)

Re: lathe is not a vice

#11

3rd vote for Stebcenters

Greg Haugen

>

Re: lathe is not a vice

#12

Re: lathe is not a vice

Russ Fairfield

>Some personal observations and comments, for what they are worth.

It seems to me that spindle turning should require only as much force from the tail center as required to positively rotate the stick in the lathe; and that the less the force required the better when turning small diameters.

The spur center is a positive drive, and once it is bedded into the wood, the tail center only needs to be enough to maintain engagement of the spurs and keep the stick from falling out of the lathe. Everything else we can use to drive the wood is a compromise.

Do people actually use a "safety center" to turn wood? I have always heard and read of their merits, but I have never been able to get one of them to drive the wood for turning without using unreasonable (wood-bending) force on the tail center. Add to that the problem that, once slipped the ring has burnished the wood, and it requires even more pressure to spin the wood so I can turn it. Maybe I am doing something wrong, or I should learn to take lighter cuts.

I see the "Steb Center" is a wonderful idea except for a couple things. The spring is so strong that it requires almost as much force to collapse the spring as it does to make a "safety center" work. This may have been corrected in those of recent manufacture.

I could never understand why the manufacturer of the "Steb Center" has always advertised the ability to put a stick in, or remove it from the lathe with the lathe running. This is s sure way to have a stick of wood get away from me and flying across the shop. This might make for good showmanship, but it is scary when it happens at 2500 RPM and there is an audience present. The 2nd problem with the "Steb-Center" is that the center point is long enough to encourage this unsafe practice.

Shortening the length of the center point protrusion and replacing the spring with a lighter one will make the "Steb-Center" into something that I can use.

Rather than do that, I took a tringular file to the "safety center" and made notches in the cup so it lookes similar to a "Steb-Center" without the spring. This is my preferred drive center because it is a more positive drive. It will still slip if there is a problem, and the daimater of the ring is the same as that of the Oneway tail center and this makes swapping ends easier and more accurate. This is a reasonable compromise and it works. The only problem is that I have to drill a center hole in very hard wood. I have always wondered why nobody makes a drive center like this.

Re: lathe is not a vice

#13

Re: lathe is not a vice

eliot d

>What spindle lock? I have a Powermatic 3520A. Besides no spindle lock, the speed indication is in frequency something-or-other -- not in RPM. AND the readout is on the other side of the lathe ( so you can't see it!) Also, the tail stock is not hollow. I asked the Powermatic rep in Louisville about what genius designed it, but got no real answer. Aside from these few (minor)issues, it's a fabulous lathe -- really!

Re: lathe is not a vice

#14

Re: I suspect

eliot d

>Oh, no! Claudia is happy to have me out of the way most of the day!

Re: lathe is not a vice

#15

Re: lathe is not a vice

eliot d

>Intriguing set of responses. For the proponents of safety centers, will they work for a really large, heavy log? My impression, is that they don't have enough torque to drive a large piece -- unless the clamping force is huge. I use a safety center for smallish spindles only when practicing with a skew because I get so may catches and the safety center's clutch slipping action is just what I need. From these responses, I have the feeling that so long as I don't hammer on the piece while it's on the lathe, I'm OK.

Re: lathe is not a vice

#16

Re: lathe is not a vice

Greg Haugen

>Well, like the other 90% of turning I think its personal preference. I TOTALLY agree I have no idea why the heck the would advertise the placing and removal of a spindle with the lathe running for the stebcenters. Someday that will cost Sorby quite a bit of money and someone's going to get rich off of them in a lawsuit. I don't like spurs for several reasons but mostly because as soon as I hit it with a dead blow mallet and seat it into the wood. I go place it on the lathe and by the time I put the tailstock up to center I've moved it enough to dislodge the spur drive. So what's the point of hammering it??? And yes a lathe isn't a vice. When I started turning with a skew I used a saftey drive, I would rather the piece stop then catch hard. But after about 1.5" to 2" they're not the best drive option. I found that the Stebcenter were a good compromise. I can drive or slip depending on SLIGHT, slight I said, tailstock pressure adjustment. Plus I didn't have to hammer the thing in. I do have two sizes the 1/2" and the 7/8" (I think). I've driven 4x4's with the 7/8" easily and without slip. I switch sizes at the 1.5" range unless I need to work up to a tenon at 5/8" and the 7/8" would be too large. I'm a skew believer but I also do use most of my gouges on spindles depending on shape and size. So my cuts are light but also heavy. I've turned chopsticks with my 1/2" Steb and just parted them off and I didn't have an issue with flexing for tailstock force or anything.

There is no perfect option. If there was no other options would stay in business. For the most part I think Stebcenters are a good compromise and so is a safety drive with "cuts" made in it for a little more "bite". The only down side to Stebs is that they're not cheap.

The whole issue of force on the headstock from the tailstock I think is a little overdone. Some guy probably was seen trying to do some woodbending (its a joke) between centers and it's got blown out of proportion. I have seen turners, namely Alan Lacer, hammer a piece of wood directly in the Morse taper of the lathe to hold it without a chuck to turn tops. Now, yes, you can try to do woodbending on the lathe or something and put more force on the bearings than needed and its wrong. But I just think the issue is a bit overdone.

Greg

Re: lathe is not a vice

#17

Re: lathe is not a vice, but turning wood can be!

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>

Re: lathe is not a vice

#18

the Brits don't know how to spell

adrien

>

Re: lathe is not a vice

#19

Re: lathe is not a vice

john lucas

>Russ I couldn't have said it better. I have not been a fan of the steb center ever since I bought one. I tried a safety drive and like you I guess I take to big a cut. I had to keep tightening the tailstock and then I got chatter due to the pressure.

Re: lathe is not a vice

#20

Dick Hines

Re: lathe is not a vice

Dick Hines

>I have a PM 3520A and it has a spindle lock. No indexer but a 2 possion lock.

If I am not mistaken Rude Osolnik helped PM with the 3520A

Re: lathe is not a vice

#21

Re: lathe is not a vice

Dinyar Chavda

>I turn green wood almost exclusively, and I put it between centers, and then "give it a couple of whacks with the old hammer". The quote is from Dave Ellsworth's tape on bowl turning, which is what I learned turning from. I have been doing this for years, and have not seen any adverse effects on the bearings or the mating of tapers to the spindle. Maybe the reason why I can get away with it is because I own a Woodfast, made in the land of Crocodile Dundee! Just my experience.

Re: lathe is not a vice

#22

Spindle lock

Jorge Castaneda

>Sometime during the past year somebody posted a neat an easy way to give the Powermatic a spindle lock, maybe it was Joaz?

Do a search

Jorge

Re: lathe is not a vice

#23

Re: Spindle lock

John Lucas

>THere have been several good tips on making the spindle lock on the powermatic, stay locked. The simplest was to just remove one of the two screws that hold the lock guard in place. The loosen the other one slightly. Push in the button and rotate the guard left or right and it will hold the button in.

I just hold the button in with my finger and rock the wood.

Re: lathe is not a vice

#24

Re: Spindle lock

eliot d

>I suppose I should clarify: the 3520A does have a spindle lock; but you have to hold the button in with one hand to make it work. Therefore you don't have two hands free to do whatever you're trying to do with the spindle locked. And, yes, there are several ways to rig up something or other to hold the button in. My point is that every other lathe I've seen has a mechanism of some sort that you turn, pull. push, etc. to keep the spindle lock in place, thereby leaving two hands free.

Re: lathe is not a vice

#25

Re: Spindle lock

John Lucas

>I agree. I wish they would change that but they didn't. At least not on this lathe.