Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Difference between spindle and roughing gouge?

Posts

Difference between spindle and roughing gouge?

#1

Difference between spindle and roughing gouge?

Terry Stellman

>Can anybody please describe the differences between say a 1" spindle gouge vs a 1" roughing gouge? Looking at the catalogs I can't see enough detail to see the differences, if any. Thanks.

Re: Difference between spindle and roughing gouge?

#2

Re: Difference between spindle and roughing gouge?

Greg Haugen

>There are a few exceptions to this and they are P&N and Cryosteel. A roughing gouge, now alot of turners are calling them Spindle Roughing Gouges "SRG's", in a traditional sense is stamped or pressed from flat stock into a "U" shaped to some degree depending on manufacturer. The "blade" is held in the handle by a "tang"-a narrower section of the blade. It the knife making trade its called a "rat tail". This is where the name change comes into play. This should never be used for bowls or where the grain is in facegrain orientation. The "tang" creates a weak spot in the event of a catch can break or bend and cause serious harm. Another version of this is the shallow gouge or continential gouges. They are also forged or stamped from flat stock and have a tang. Used very similar to conventional SRG's they don't have the high sides and are great for a long flowing curve in spindle turning. Both of this style of gouges the steel is equal thickness anywhere on the cutting edge being its bade from flat steel so it has a uniform thickness.

A traditional spindle gouge is milled from round bar stock. The size of the gouge is the size of the steel used whereas bowl gouges are sized by the size of the flute. A 1/2" spindle gouge is 1/2", 1/2" bowl gouge in a catalog is more towards 5/8". The profile can vary from a "detail" gouge where the flute is considerably smaller than the steel. Leaving more steel under the bevel to help avoid vibration. A "spindle" gouge flute is more proportionate to the size of the steel. The milling or end view profile is more of a upside down crescent moon. The "tips" or corners or thinner then the "belly" of the flute.

Most turners have up to a 1/2" spindle gouge or even a 3/8". You can get larger through Glaser Tools but unless you're turning a telephone pole its a bit large and alot more money.

For truing a square piece or a long flowing curve with the wood in spindle orientation a continental gouge or SRG works the best. SRG a 1 1/4" is a good size. The only real difference between these two options are the sides of the gouge. SRG are "U" shaped and forged or continental gouges don't have the high sides, more a shallow dip.

Hope that helps?

Greg

Re: Difference between spindle and roughing gouge?

#3

Re: Difference between spindle and roughing gouge? *LINK*

Russ Babbitt Jr.

>This link might help.....can't hurt.


Too Types

Re: Difference between spindle and roughing gouge?

#4

Thanks.

Terry Stellman

>

Re: Difference between spindle and roughing gouge?

#5

Re: Difference between spindle and roughing gouge?

Dick Anderson

>The roughing gouge, which should properly be called a spindle roughing gouge, is strictly and only to be used in wood in the spindle mode, that is with the grain parallel to the lathe axis. The tang is far too weak to safely cut end grain, which is what you will cut when the grain is perpendicular to the lathe axis. A spindle gouge (round bar stock) is stronger and can be used safely with grain oriented in any direction. Obviously wood cuts better with the tool (skew, gouge, etc.) oriented in a grain direction where there are wood tibers supporting those tibers being cut. Cutting in the opposite direction results in more wear-out (usually).

Re: Difference between spindle and roughing gouge?

#6

Re: Difference between spindle and roughing gouge?

wilbur

>Is it just me, or does it seem counterintuitive that a roughing gouge operation is considered to generate stronger forces than a bowl gouge? I would think that the impact of a rough blank hitting the roughing gouge before it becomes completely round would generate a lot of force.

Re: Difference between spindle and roughing gouge?

#7

Re: Difference between spindle and roughing gouge?

Russ Fairfield

>The difference is that a catch with a spindle gouge will tear up some wood and cut a spiral. A catch with a roughing gouge will bend the tool, and then tear the tool out of your hand and throw it across the room. Sometimes it will throw the wood after it just in case you didn't get the message.

Re: Difference between spindle and roughing gouge?

#8

Re: Difference between spindle and roughing gouge?

jeff myroup

>If you look at it from a purely Physics stand point, Force= Mass x Acceleration (F=MA). It is true that a rough piece will have a larger mass, and the speed of the lathe is generally slower. While roughing the surface spped of the edge will slow down during the process. Because of the uneven surface of a rough piece, a catch can be more dramatic. This will cause a rapid deceleration. Acceleration (can be positive or negative) is a change in speed over time. So using our formula F=MA, you can see that a large mass that is quickly stopped (a catch) will generate a large force. A roughing gouge compared to a bowl gouge generally has a larger surface area for this force to act upon. Combine this with a small tang and bad things can and will happen. The force travels down the handle, with the tool rest acting as a pivot point for a lever. To conteract this force, as the tool handle travels up, people will push down on the handle. The lever action bends the tang, or breaks it.

Jeff

Re: Difference between spindle and roughing gouge?

#9

Re: Difference between spindle and roughing gouge?

wilbur

>That makes sense to me. But it kind of begs the question: Why would anyone want to have a roughing gouge?