Re: Difference between spindle and roughing gouge?
Greg Haugen
>There are a few exceptions to this and they are P&N and Cryosteel. A roughing gouge, now alot of turners are calling them Spindle Roughing Gouges "SRG's", in a traditional sense is stamped or pressed from flat stock into a "U" shaped to some degree depending on manufacturer. The "blade" is held in the handle by a "tang"-a narrower section of the blade. It the knife making trade its called a "rat tail". This is where the name change comes into play. This should never be used for bowls or where the grain is in facegrain orientation. The "tang" creates a weak spot in the event of a catch can break or bend and cause serious harm. Another version of this is the shallow gouge or continential gouges. They are also forged or stamped from flat stock and have a tang. Used very similar to conventional SRG's they don't have the high sides and are great for a long flowing curve in spindle turning. Both of this style of gouges the steel is equal thickness anywhere on the cutting edge being its bade from flat steel so it has a uniform thickness.
A traditional spindle gouge is milled from round bar stock. The size of the gouge is the size of the steel used whereas bowl gouges are sized by the size of the flute. A 1/2" spindle gouge is 1/2", 1/2" bowl gouge in a catalog is more towards 5/8". The profile can vary from a "detail" gouge where the flute is considerably smaller than the steel. Leaving more steel under the bevel to help avoid vibration. A "spindle" gouge flute is more proportionate to the size of the steel. The milling or end view profile is more of a upside down crescent moon. The "tips" or corners or thinner then the "belly" of the flute.
Most turners have up to a 1/2" spindle gouge or even a 3/8". You can get larger through Glaser Tools but unless you're turning a telephone pole its a bit large and alot more money.
For truing a square piece or a long flowing curve with the wood in spindle orientation a continental gouge or SRG works the best. SRG a 1 1/4" is a good size. The only real difference between these two options are the sides of the gouge. SRG are "U" shaped and forged or continental gouges don't have the high sides, more a shallow dip.
Hope that helps?
Greg