Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Box hollowing.

Posts

Box hollowing.

#1

Box hollowing.

john lucas

>I was hollowing some boxes today and have always wanted to try the Raffen hollowing method. While I was at it I decided to compare it to hollowing the way I learned with the bowl gouge and also the ring tools and round nose scraper.

I chose a piece of dry ash as my test subject because I had enough to throw away. The Raffen method of hollowing with the gouge moving from center to 12 oclock is interesting and will take me more time to master. You have to start with the flute pointing toward 4 oclock and rotate it almost upside down as you move toward 12. That apparently varies depending on the grind of your gouge and the shape of the bowl. Although I was getting some good shavings I was having trouble controlling the shape of the bowl. The cut however was very clean when I got it right which makes sense since it's a cut rather than scrape.

The ring tool also cuts very clean but on this hard dry wood I couldn't take a very big cut. The Raffen cut was much more aggresive probably because the tool is much thicker.

I learned to use the bowl gouge with an Ellsworth type grind. Rotate the flute to the left and cut with the bottom wing with the top wing very close to the wood. This cut is very controllable but doesn't leave as good a finish as the ring tool or Raffen cut. It is a very safe cut however.

The round nose scraper can be grabby if your not careful but is quite easy to use. It leaves a finish a little rougher than my method. I guess that's because my gouge is sharpened as a sharper angle than the scraper.

All in all a fun project. I'll have to borrow the Raffen video again and look at what he does more closely. I also have an Alan Batty video on threading and he uses a cut similar.

Well time to go and put some more finish on the latest box. It has router cuts that look similar to the rose engine cuts that were in the latest American Woodturner. I'll post a photo when I get it done.

Re: Box hollowing.

#2

Re: Box hollowing.

john lucas

>Here is the box I mentioned above. I used my router with the index plate to cut the grooves. The box is Ash and the top is Wenge.


img

Re: Box hollowing.

#3

Re: Box hollowing.

Allen Neighbors

>Gorgeous, John; I love the form, the finial, and the routed top. As always, you do fine work! :o) Wish I had your patience....

Re: Box hollowing.

#4

Re: Box hollowing.

Ron in Drums PA

>Really Nice John

Re: Box hollowing.

#5

Re: Box hollowing.

Gil Jones, Lake Seminole, GA

>Neat box, John.

I like the finial design!

Gil

Re: Box hollowing.

#6

Re: Box hollowing.

John Leonard

>John, the old Del Stubbs video on bowl turning has the best description of the "Raffin" method that I have found. John L.

Re: Box hollowing.

#7

Re: Box hollowing.

Bob Fawcett

>Guess I'll have to watch that video again. I don't quite understand the method John is describing.

Lots to learn.

Re: Box hollowing.

#8

Re: Box hollowing.

Leppikallio

>Just a minute... you said flute towards 4 o'clock?

With "dullish" fingernail grind (and shallow gouge) when beginning this cut flute should be pointing to 1 and when cut moves towards rim you should turn tool so that at rim flute is pointing to 2 - 2:30. If flute points to 3 or more Mr. Catch will slap you to fingers...

Backside of the flute should lean to rim at about 8-9 o'clock. Cut seems to be "safe" only about perhaps 2" deep and obviously not very large diameters. I think another good name for this cut would be "the egg cup cut"... ;-))

Re: Box hollowing.

#9

Re: Box hollowing.

john lucas

>Thanks, I plan to try this some more. I was using a bowl gouge with a sharper angle, about 50 degrees I think. As I moved toward the rim it would try to catch if I didn't rotate the flute further. This kept the bevel rubbing. I tried my spindle gouge and had lots of catches. I probably wasn't using it correctly. I'll keep slugging away. This bowl was a little less than 2" deep so I might have been pushing the limits.

Re: Box hollowing.

#10

Re: Box hollowing.

Leppikallio

>What I ment but didn't say is that this cut is not that easy or safe much deeper than 2". However less than that is fine. Now when I think of it diameter / depth ratio is important factor too. Not easy or safe cut for very shallow "bowl", from rim to center is better then (works charmingly also, harder wood and better results).

I don't try to say that I'm some sort of expert with this cut. Definately not. Perhaps it has been the fact that I was ingorant enough when I tried it but I have been succesful with this cut from quite beginning. I use most of the time that 1/2" shallow gouge (or 3/8" for very small items). Most of the time I rough turn blank, true the end and take couple, perhaps two small cuts from rim to center. Makes it easy to drill hole to center, just turn the gouge when in center and drill... so when I'm drilling the hole flute is still pointing from previous "rim-to-center" -cut to about 2:30. Now when I pull the gouge out from the hole I have flute facing to right direction. To beginning that "backhollowing cut" leave tip to hole about 1/8-1/4 to be safe and turn handle of the gouge to 7-7:30 while rolling the handle clockwise to keep bevel rubbing. When going back to center just reverse those movements. It shouldn't be that difficult if you remember to keep opening as small as possible as long as possible and keep those three fulcrum points (bevel, back of the tool at the left side of opening and toolrest).

Wet wood is much funnier and forgiving again.

You know it but just to make sure as ignoring this fact is not fun: FOR ENDGRAIN ONLY! ;-)) You don't have to test it, many many before you have done it.

Re: Box hollowing.

#11

Re: Box hollowing.

Fog Tanner

>I learned the Raffin backhollowing from his tapes, and later relearned it from a handson with Hisownself. He has changed it a little over the years. The flute is pointed at around 2-3 o'clock and scooping cuts are made in that direction. I think this is so He can pivot away from the lathe rather than pushing the handle down. As He puts it "an economy of motion and a more comfortable position". I have tried both and preferr the 2-3 o'clock. In the videos He shows opening the whole of the opening and then going for depth. In the hands on He has changed that to leave a rather small opening for the gouge to pivot on. Once the depth is reached, the mouth can be opened with the gouge or a swept side half round scraper. I do both depending on the mood and day I am having (i.e is the gouge with me or against me).

During the hands on He was doing it one handed to show the reduction in leverage required using the smaller opeing. I started doing that after that and it does make it much easier. I use a 1/2" shallow gouge with a 40 degree bevel and a "Raffin" style fingernail grind. I also noticed the last Craft Supplt catalog showed a "new Raffin" version for backhollowing. From the picture, it appears a lot like the Ray Key gouge. I happen to have two of the Ray Key style gouges so I will give one a go at backhollowing and see if that work any better.

Re: Box hollowing.

#12

Re: Box hollowing.

john lucas

>Fog My next box is a side grain box so I'll skip this technique but this weekend I should be able to get into the shop and I'll dig up some old endgrain stuff and just wear it out.

Re: Box hollowing.

#13

Re: Box hollowing.

Fog Tanner

>John,

I did go through a lot of end grain trying to get the hang of this technique. I have done several hundreds of various pieces this way and it does get easier the more you do. It also seems easier when you aren't trying to match Hisownself's speed. I think it will take several thousand more before I would feel comfortable trying that.

This evening was a informal get togther at one of the local woodworking stores. Several of us did a communal box. I started it off with the backhollowing technique but quickly found the limitations of the gouges on hand and we had to switch to the Ray Key method. I do find the profile that I got from Raffin seems to work better for this, guess it was those tens of thousands that He has done to find it (over 45,000 scoops alone). I sometimes wonder if we will ever see someone as prolific as Him at the speed, volume and variety of turned items in our lifetime.