Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented form

Posts

Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented form

#1

Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented form

Ron in Drums PA

>After looking at eagle's pen it gave me an idea for a segmented hollow form using wood and brass.

Any ideas what might be a good glue to use?

Re: Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented form

#2

Re: Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented

IAN

>ron, I haven't tried it but I would think that CA is the only one rated for use on metals. my only concern would be that wood movement over time causing the joints to fail.

IAN

Re: Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented form

#3

Re: Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented

Bill Stehman

>Hi Ron,

Do not use gorilla glue even tho they say it is for that. It expands and forced brass veneer out from between segments when I tried it. I have used melamine glue with good success but never trusted it between rings, however my father made hundreds of segmented bowls and ornaments mixing metal, lexan, stone and wood. I still have some that have held together for many years so it works. I'm sure there are better options. CA dries brittle and will collapse with movement.

Re: Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented form

#4

JL

Re: Would a clear epoxy work??

JL

>I've never done a segemented work, although I've glued a lot of things. I would think that something with more "open time" than a CA would be needed. Maybe Mark Kauder will chime in here.

When I've seen segmented demos, it seems that after "adjusting" the pieces together before assembly, there is still some time involved in the glue-up process. I also have a tendency to glue various appendages together when I use a lot of CA :).

Re: Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented form

#5

Re: Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented

Bob Fawcett

>Epoxy works on metal. I used to glue golf clubs together with it. Never tried it for something like this.

It holds gouges in handles pretty good though.

Re: Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented form

#6

Re: Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented

Ron in Drums PA

>I haven't thought of melamine glue. When you say "never trusted it between rings" do you mean wood to wood contact?

I know CA will become brittle and epoxy will creep over time. Gorilla glue and similar glues have their problems also so they're out.

Re: Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented form

#7

Re: Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Ron,

In the places where you need a wood/brass joint, I wouldn't use anything but an epoxy. I would not use a 5-minute epoxy myself. I don't know if there is such a thing as an epoxy that is between a 5 minute epoxy and someting that needs 10 hours, but that is what I would use. A longer set time will also give you more cleanup time.

C-A for me is an emergency tool for segmenting. Fix a crack, fill a void, etc. It is too brittle for many applications.

Mark

Re: Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented form

#8

Re: Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented

eaglesc

>I use CA all the time and have never found an instance where it is "too brittle"

Put a drop of thick CA on a piece of packing tape and let it cure naturally.

You will be able to separate it and bend it in half without breaking.

Claims that it is brittle are just plain wrong.

Try a glue up on a small piece with the brass "Scuffed" and Ca and I think you will be surprised.

Epoxy?

Most glue joint failuers I have had in my intricate glue ups have been with epoxy.

I don't trust the stuff for soemthing I want to stay together.

Re: Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented form

#9

Re: Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented

Bill Stehman

>Yes Ron, I personally don't like any glue that doesn't set hard. Just my quirk. I have glued end grain picture frame miters, let it set over night then breaking the joint with a hammer. It will pull wood fibers out so it works.

Re: Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented form

#10

CA doesn't have shear strength...

jwoodwright

>CA or super glue will fail under shearing forces. Glue two pieces of 1x4 x 2 ft, so that you have a 90 degree angle. This gives a 4x4 lap joint. Wait overnight, heck, wait all week, now take the two ends and standing on one end, pull up with the other. The joint will fail.

Do this with yellow glue or titebond or poly glue and you will pull apart wood fibers, The glue actually becomes one with the wood fibers.

Now, will it work on stuff you don't plan on destroying, YES! In fact, I've turned pens since 1998 and probally have used a gallon or more in small squeeze tubes...

I've used CA since 1975, when I discovered it in the USAF. They used it to hold the little honeycomb sections in jet wings... Quart size bottles...

Re: Which glue for wood and metal for a segmented form

#11

Thanks For all the replies

Ron in Drums PA

>I'm going to do a couple of test pieces with both melamine and regular set epoxy.

Thanks again!