Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Norton 3X grinding wheel - K grade

Posts

Norton 3X grinding wheel - K grade

#1

Norton 3X grinding wheel - K grade

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>A week and a half ago we talked about grinding wheels and problems with different grade wheels.

Jerry Hall posted a web site sharpeningsupplies.com I called and ordered a 46 and 80 grit wheel, the 80 grit wheel is backordered but the 46 grit wheel arrived in two days. This is the page it was ordered from.

http://www.sharpeningsupplies.com/Norton-3X-Blue-Grinding-Wheel-K-Grade-P101C20.aspx

The wheel is a Norton 3X SG "K" grade. Most SG wheels sold in catalogs are the softer "I" grade, I do own a set from Packard and they do sharpen tools very well with no heat buildup. The only problem with a "I" grade is it's easy to wear a groove in the face of the wheel.

Using the "K" grade wheel;

The first thing you will notice is how hard the wheel is compared to a white, pink or "I" grade grinding wheel you had on the grinder before. It doesn't remove steel quite as fast as the other wheels so it's easy to control how much steel you remove, (this is a strong point) The wheel can be dressed using a diamond for a smooth finish or get this... a star wheel dresser for a rough wheel finish. It's hard to put a groove in the wheel.

The wheel run today is 46 grit, this grit should NOT be use for every day grinding because it's just to course. This is however a good example how the "K" grade wears, after grinding 20 tools you can see a concave wear pattern. This is on a slow speed grinder, tomorrow I'll order another Wolverine jig then move this wheel to a high speed grinder. When the 80 grit wheel arrives I'll let you know.


img

Re: Norton 3X grinding wheel - K grade

#2

Re: Norton 3X grinding wheel - K grade

Gordon Seto

>Doug,

It seems you have another batch of tools ready to go. Are those spindle gouges?

Do you meant you can shape 20 tools without dressing the K wheel? How about heat build up?

I returned my 3X wheels, mine didn't have a grade rating on it. I use the 60 grit coarse wheel to round off the heels of the bevel. The wheel grooved so easy that I have to true the wheel before I can finish one tool. I was partially lifting the tool and use the whole width of the wheel; not even the full weight of the gouge was on the wheel.

I have the 80 grit SG wheel from CSUSA on the other side. It is far superior than the 3X SG wheel. I thought I can get a less expensive coarse wheel to reserve the life of the expensive wheel. IMO, the no hardness grading Norton 3x SG is no match to the OEM white wheel that came with the Woodcraft slow speed grinder.

I may have a defective batch, or they are not intended for A-11 steel. The 100 grit 3x SG is not as good as the 80 grit SG wheel. It needs dressing more often, but not grooves as bad as the 60 grit coarse wheel.

Gordon

Re: Norton 3X grinding wheel - K grade

#3

Re: Norton 3X grinding wheel - K grade

Ed in Sptbg.

>I use a Norton 5SG46-KVS wheel (Travers.com, Order #52-000-102, it has a 1 1/4" center hole so the Oneway balancer works with it) on a Woodcraft slow speed grinder. I don't know how it compares with the 3X, but I find next to no dishing or grooving problems with the 5SG. Someone recently commented on M2 scrapers being easier to sharpen (or better) than 2030 and 2060 scrapers but the 5SG raises a good burr on these harder steels, again with minimal dishing problems. The burr can be a little coarse with the 46 grit, but this can be controlled, as Doug noted, by smoothly dressing the wheel with a diamond. On the other side of my grinder is a Packard Norton 100 grit white wheel used for finishing and touch up sharpening.

Re: Norton 3X grinding wheel - K grade

#4

Re: Norton 3X grinding wheel - K grade

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Because the spindle, detail gouges have such a large bevel the grinding process does take some time. To grind one from scratch I'll rough the shape with a 24 grit wheel (Norton extra course) on a Dayton 8" high speed grinder. The 40 degree angle is created, friction does heat the steel to a point it is unconforable to hold so I'll do twenty at a time. Grind for a few seconds then go to the next this way the steel never gets to hot to hold onto.

This wheel was used to shape all 20 tools without dressing the wheel. Each needed about 1/16 of steel to be removed, heat is not an issue because the steel is held in a jig.

GRINDING and BURNING

No grinding wheel will burn steel unless you use to much pressure. A light touch is needed and let the wheel do the work. The higher grits (80 -120) need a very light touch and keep the tool moving across the wheel, never grind in one spot on the wheel. Grip the jig just tight enough to have control and lighly touch the wheel this is all that's needed. Lose the idea that pressure is needed to grind, it doesn't.

For my own personal use a 6" high speed grinder with a green 120 grit wheel is perfect to sharpen my turning tools.