Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Silly Electrical Question

Posts

Silly Electrical Question

#1

Silly Electrical Question

tm

>I'm putting my shop area back together after insulating, drywall, paint and weather stripping & caulking.

I just bought 2 Craftsman retractable power cord reels so that a I can bring three outlet receptacles down from the rafters in the garage. They have a circuit breaker built into them, which seems like a good feature in the event of an overload. I have to use a surge protector to protect the Nova DVR XP. I'm guessing I'll still need to run the surge protection but thinking it would be nice to eliminate that component if I could safely get away with it.

Does a circuit breaker do the same thing as a surge protector?

Thanks,

tm

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#2

Re: Silly Electrical Question

Fog Tanner

>The circuit breaker is there to keep you from putting more amperage through the wire that what it can handle. 12ga wire is typically rated for 20 amps, although you can put more. If you run 40amps the wire will overheat, possibly met and start a fire. This is all a long duration process.

Surges on the other hand are measured in microseconds or millionths of a second. Here you can see several hundred to several thousnd volts and amps. During the short duriation, there is not enough time to generate the heat to melt the wire. But, enough to damage sensitive electrical componants in things like moter controllers, PC,s TV, and some ovens. So you have two different devices each with a different target of protection.

I don't turn during storms and keep the lathe unplugged during those times I am not using it. A number of the members in my club are going through the process of trying to figure out which one of the whole house type surge protection units to get to cover our toys. Mainly to cover the times when the power company is working on the grid or some of those thunderstorms we get at the horizon (20 miles away). If you can see the lightening storm that far away, it can affect you. I live in coastal Texas and we can get severe weather before you know it. Safest thing is just unplug those tools when you are not going to be using them.

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#3

Re: Silly Electrical Question

tm

>Thanks for the detailed explanation.

When it comes to electricity, I'm like one of the apes at the start of Kubricks 2001 A Space Odyssey. I'm the one off to the side, scratching my head, hoping I don't get zapped.

tm

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#4

JL

Re: Silly Electrical Question

JL

>Rather than surge protection for my Jet EVS, I just unplug it. Come to think of it, the only thing I don't typically unplug is the dust collector. It does take a second or two to "find its brain" (the Jet that is - takes longer than that for me, usually the 2nd dose of caffeine). I don't think it harms a lathe to be unplugged.

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#5

Re: Silly Electrical Question

eaglesc

>On another note.

It is not good to run electric motors on a n extension cord that is coiled.

YOu didn't say how many feet are on the coils but it would be best if they are fully extended if running high amp tools for a long period of time.

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#6

Re: Silly Electrical Question

jeff myroup

>The problem with using extension cords, Is not only heat but voltage drop. The smaller the gauge wire, and the longer it is, the more drop.

Jeff

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#7

Coiled Cords slow electrons....little known fact

Jerry Hall

>Yup, All those coils in the cord really do slow down the electrons as they try to race around those tight curves. They like straight runs better, and you get more rpm out of your lathe instead of wasting those turns in the cord. Learned this in my high school physics class (taught by an art teacher.) :)

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#8

Re: Silly solution- just plug the....

Jamie Donaldson

>... extension cord into a surge suppressor, and then use the shortest and heaviest line possible. I have played with electronics for many years, and voltage spikes out here in the country are common, and very destructive of solid state equipment.

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#9

Re: Coiled Cords slow electrons....little known fa

eaglesc

>Did he mention things like heat and fire, not to mention premature motor failure?(if you are lucky)

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#10

Re: Coiled Cords slow electrons....little known fa

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>Whole home surge supression is the way to go. These fit in the main power panel and protect everything from line power.

Oh and don't forget a Satelite dish, exterior TV antena and your tele line. I believe Monster Cable and others make boxes for these.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#11

Re: Coiled Cords slow electrons....little known fa

Fog Tanner

>When did your art physics teacher come to the revalation that electrons flowed through copper wire like water through a hose. I think he should share this with the rest of the scientific community or at least talk to this old electrican I once met. Which makes you wonder since they flowing through the wire, where do they go - do they just dribble out the other end and wind up falling all over the floor under the lathe.

Coiled or straight, the speed of electricty is the same. the "flow" of electricty is not the same as the flow of water through a garden hose, it is more like a hydralic line where you put pressure on one end and it transmitted through the line to the other end (i.e. brakes on a car).Generally, the only thing the electrons "care" about is the conductor and its resistance. This translates into heat and/or voltage drop.

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#12

Re: Thanks Fog, I needed a .....

Jamie Donaldson

>.... good laugh, and that mental picture of the electrons running out of the hose and around the floor did me in!!!!Every fool knows that after they play for a while they jump back into the return hose and go back home to ground!!!! ;--))))

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#13

Re: Silly Electrical Question

Allen Neighbors

>TM, my old FIL, a master electrician, said that it isn't good to have a coiled cord, just because of the electronic field that it produces.

Also, if you are running your Nova on an extension cord, you really do need to get a heavy duty cord... I suggest a #10 guage, though a #12 guage would probably do fine... it just depends on how long the extension is. If you go to a larger guage than is called for it is better for the equipment that is plugged into it. Usually, the wire that comes on those retracting reels is 16 or 18 guage. Even 14 guage is too small to run your Nova.

Electricity doesn't "flow through" a wire, like water through a hose; it travels "around and along" the 'surface' of the wire. The larger the wire, the less resistance to the travel of the electricity.

Something to think about......

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#14

Spilled electrons

John Pickett

>Just make sure that if you have a bare wire that you place a plastic bucket underneath to catch the spilled juice. LOL

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#15

Re: Coiled Cords slow electrons....little known fa

Ron in Drums PA

>I wonder what happens when there is a kink in the coil?

Do the electrons slow down!

LOL

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#16

Re: Spilled electrons

John Lucas

>Yea it's like dropping a bag of BB's. Say where is Jen when we need someone to pick them up.

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#17

Re: Silly Electrical Question

eaglesc

>Thanks Allen.

You made the nay sayers look ridiculous.

I imagine they also think the world is flat.

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#18

Re: Coiled Cords slow electrons....little known fa

jeff myroup

>If that where the case your lathe would never turn, since the motor is nothing more than tightly wound small gauge wire. I think your physics teacher should stick to art.

Jeff

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#19

Re: Coiled Cords do present several.....

Jamie Donaldson

>....potential problems in use. If overloaded they heat up, sometimes enough to melt the insulation, and then the arcing can short into another loop of the coil. And if the insulation has nicks or abrasions, the coil affords an opportunity to short into another loop. Continuous use can eventually break the strands of the conductor or insulation as well.

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#20

Re: Coiled Cords slow electrons....little known fa

Bob Fawcett

>My power company offers this as well. Don't know what equipment they use or the price. I bet others do too.

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#21

Re: Coiled Cords do present several.....

jeff myroup

>All of the things you mentioned are true, But coiled wires do not slow electron flow.

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#22

Re: Silly Electrical Question

Bill Howatt

>Yes, a coil of wire is an inductor but I'm not going to get into how much inductance it has and if it has an effect on the motor or not. Resistance of too small a conductor is more of a threat but there is more in play than just resistance.

Bill

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#23

Re: Silly Electrical Question

Barry Irby

>Years ago, the National Electric Code was changed to cause manufacturers to make electrical panels larger, specifically above the main panel lugs to allow bending space. They wanted electricians to curve or arch the wires into the lugs, rather than bend them at right angles or sharp corners. The explanation was that sharp bends caused the wires to heat up when under load. I don't know if the explanation is true, but I do know the panels are larger than they used to be.

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#24

Re: Silly Electrical Question

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>It is like the reason light switches have to be at the same level as called fo in the code.

So blind people can find them !

Fact

Bill in Casa Grande AZ.

Re: Silly Electrical Question

#25

Re: Coiled Cords do present several.....

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Jeff,

My understanding had been that a coiled extension cord with sufficient load would produce an electro-magnetic effect which could increase resistance in the coil. Also, I think that I remember that adding a metal core to the coil increses the electro-magnetic effect.

Increased resistance at the same voltage increases heat in the wire. The tighter the coil, the more resistance. Coiled electrical components produce significant heat.

To put it more cogently, a non-coiled extension cord might be a bit safer than a cord coiled tightly on a metal drum, if you are pulling near the rated capacity of the cord. It's also possible that the rated capacity has a large enough CYA factor built in so that you wouldn't have to worry either way.

I could be wrong, I haven't studied my electrical theory in awhile. Gary