Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Dust Collection

Posts

Dust Collection

#1

Dust Collection

HeatherA in Alaska

>Hello, after recently coming in all stopped-up after sanding, my husband surprised me with a dust collector as an early anniversary present. He got me the Jet dc-650sb. It is a small unit with a 30 micron filter (that as far as I can tell cannot be changed for one that filters smaller particles). I have read many of the posts in the archives and realize that it is probably not sufficient. My question is whether I should get one that filters to smaller particles (looking at the Jet with 2 micron canister) or if one of the airshield/ Triton type helmets would be a better choice. It seems from what I have read that many people use both. If I had just the helmet would it get clogged up quickly without any other DC system? I am trying to stay under $300 or so. Is that possible?

Thanks,

Heather

Re: Dust Collection

#2

Re: Dust Collection *LINK*

Russ Babbitt

>I think this is the same unit I have. Too late to check the garage/shop right now. I also have a Delta unit of the same configuration. The bags on both of those units were upgraded. Check the link below at Rockler. Looks like better bags are still available. If I was limited to one unit I would have a powered respirator. If you just have a dust collector there is still dust in the air to get to your lungs. The powered respirator collects the dust before it gets to you lungs plus provides face protection. I have an older Trend type unit and a Triton type beltpack respirator and prefer the one-piece Trend type unit. They do not clog very fast at all. I almost forget there is a filter to clean/replace.


Rockler

Re: Dust Collection

#3

Re: Dust Collection *LINK*

Mike Cunningham (Cape May NJ)

>Heather,

Regardless which filter you use on your DC you'll still have dust in the air that you're breathing. Simply look at all of it floating through the rays of sunlight entering your shop. So, regardless of the filtration bag that you use (yes you need an upgrade) you need some sort of respirator. Someone with more knowledge of DC bags will speak to that but I can recommend a respirator

If you'd like to spend much less than a unit such as a Triton or Trend, but receive significantly more protection than that offered with paper masks, you could consider using what I have, an AO Safety respirator purchased from Lee Valley. This unit, priced below $50 will afford both dust and chemical protection depending on cartridges used. It fits fine with my face shield, is comfortable and low maintenance and when I blow my nose at the end of the day it doesn't look like, well you know....

Hope this helps,

Mike


AO Safety respirator

Re: Dust Collection

#4

Re: Dust Collection *LINK*

Bill McWhirter

>For more than you would ever want to know about dust collection, check out Bill Pentz's site.

Too many times I have bought low end, improved it, replaced it with better, and then finally gotten what I really needed. Each time, many more dollars spent and much more time were invested than if I had done it correctly the first time. (I am currently installing my third dust collection system and the larger ducts that it requires.)

Universal truth that I try hard to remember-"Quality remains long after price is forgotten."


http://billpentz.com/Woodworking/Cyclone/Index.cfm

Re: Dust Collection

#5

Re: Dust Collection

wilbur

>The best advice I've ever heard on dust collection is that you need to think of it as a SYSTEM -- not just a collection of components. That means taking into account the dust collector, the type of ducting you use, air filtration units, how easy it is to collect dust for the tool you're using, the size of your shop, and whether you can exhaust air outside or not.

From a health standpoint, the dust that's the most dangerous is the stuff around 1 micron in size. You can't see these particles, but it's the fine layer of dust you see lying on flat surfaces after you've left the shop for a while. The dust collector you have certainly can't take care of this stuff, as it only filters down to 30 microns in size.

At the very least, you'll need a new filter, or if you can't find one, a new dust collector. But more info on your shop would be very useful.

Re: Dust Collection

#6

George Balock

Re: Dust Collection *LINK*

George Balock

>Heather,

I recently upgraded my jet DC with the cartridge filter from Wynn Environmental. The efficiency of this cartridge is much better than the bags that came with the DC and it filters down to 0.5 micron. I have not noticed nearly as much fine dust in the shop since the upgrade. But this is not enough, I still use my Airmate Helmet to make sure I'm not sucking up that much dust.

George


Wynn Environmental

Re: Dust Collection

#7

Re: Dust Collection

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>You might want to consider a .5 micron two step system. 1 is a cyclone and 2 is a bag system for final filtration. As I live in the desert I have a reverse problem than you. I want to try to keep the cooled air from the shop back into the shop.

Set up the cyclone outside, if you can, and run the prefiltered air back into the shop. Build a rack of several bags for final cleaning of the air.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Dust Collection

#8

Re: Dust Collection *LINK*

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Heather,

Given your expense restrictions I would suggest the following:

1) Get a Triton ($200) or Trend ($279) positive pressure facemask system - they help keep the dust away from your "Breathing System".

2) Get the cartridge filter from Wynn ($130) - it increased the amount of air your system will pull, and filters better.

3) Get a longer hose ($20) (extension) so that you can place the DC farther from you, so that you are not surrounding you with the "Filtered air) that is packed with the smaller, dangerous particles. If possible, put your DC in another room.

Mark


http://www.wynnenv.com/35A_series_cartridge_kit.htm

Re: Dust Collection

#9

Re: Dust Collection

HeatherA in Alaska

>Thanks for the responses. I have commandeered half of our 2 car garage. How fine of a particle will the airstream filter? Also, what is the difference in the $250 model and the $650 one?

Thanks,

Heather

Re: Dust Collection

#10

Re: Dust Collection

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>I assume that you are talking about the $650 3M Airstream and the $250 Trend Airshield. I am not fully qualified to answer, but I my OPINION. If you were going to turn all day, you might want to get the 3M. The hour or so turning a day person would do just fine with the Trend, or the Triton.

Mark