Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Black Limba Vessel

Posts

Black Limba Vessel

#1

Black Limba Vessel

Neal_Addy

>Black Limba with Blackwood. 5"H x 4-1/2"W. Finished with Seal-A-Cell, buffed with Tripoli and Wax.

All comments/critiques welcome.


img

Re: Black Limba Vessel

#2

Re: Black Limba Vessel

David Walser

>Neal,

I really like the form and the wood is beautiful. It may just be the photo, but it appears the finish might have been improved had you filled the open pores. In the photo, it looks like there are lots of small black holes that detract from what might otherwise be a smooth gloss.

Re: Black Limba Vessel

#3

Re: Black Limba Vessel

Neal_Addy

>It's not the photo. This wood was very light and porous. There are literally hundreds of pores throughout the piece. I actually sharpened the pic to bring them out.

It's interesting, but in the right light each pore is filled with a gold glint. At first I thought they were sap but they survived sanding and Seal-A-Cell so I guess not.

Re: Black Limba Vessel

#4

Re: Black Limba Vessel

Troy German

>This is a great piece. It�s one of my favorite shapes and VERY well done. It brings up a topic I�ve been thinking about lately. Your piece is visually perfect, but I�m very tactile. The main thing that attracts me to a particular turning is if it appeals to the sense of touch. The open pores on this one seem as if they would detract from the tactile experience of this piece. I think it would make an interesting thread (one that I�ll follow up on tomorrow in more detail) to find out what other people�s primary attraction factor is (e.g. visual, tactile, functional, etc�).

Besides the pores there is a lot I like about this piece. First is the overall shape and that the curve is well executed. Second is the finial, it�s sleek and well proportioned with enough happening to be interesting but not so much that it looks too busy. The bead is especially well done. The long taper is also appealing. Third, I can�t tell from the picture, but it looks as if the collar might be textured between the outer bead and the base of the finial. If so, that�s a very nice detail. And finally, the color of the wood is interesting as well.

Excellent job, and thanks for showing your work.

Troy

Re: Black Limba Vessel

#5

Re: Black Limba Vessel

Dick Parr

>That really looks great Neal, it is a very stunning piece..

Wonderful job.

Re: Black Limba Vessel

#6

Steven Antonucci

Is it my Exchange gift? :-)

steve antonucci

>Can't be, since I've already received one... darn!

It's a beauty.

Steve

Re: Black Limba Vessel

#7

Re: Black Limba Vessel

Fred Bearman

>To each his own, and if we all liked the same things it would be a pretty boring world, but for me I really like the effect of the open pores, both visually and from a potential touch experience. It makes it kind like pointilism (SP?). One way or another - beautiful piece, and absolutely gorgeous wood.

Fred Bearman

Port Huron, Michigan

Re: Black Limba Vessel

#8

Re: Black Limba Vessel

Mike Nelson

>Hey Neal, I think the pores make this great piece unique, it's almost like you did an exceptional job of texturing. Mike

Re: Black Limba Vessel

#9

Brad Vietje

Simply Fantastic !

Brad Vietje

>Neal -- that's one beautiful vessel. I appreciate the open pores as they are. In my view, most fillers end up looking pretty dull, and my senses prefer to get a sense of the wood itself, not just the shape and the colors. If it were mine, and if I wanted to fill the pores, I might use a few applications of medium CA with wet sanding in between, as it does seem to cure quite clear. With the beautiful texture, this one wants to be held (and if you send it my way, I'll be glad to hold it for you!), so I think the pores add to it rather than detract.

I can only think of one very minor change that might look even better (and I'm aware that it looks great right now !), and that would be a subtle change in the curve of the finial just below the captured ball. I think it would even better if that were a more concave curve leading to the small step above the wider base, but I could be wrong about that.

Excellent piece.

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Black Limba Vessel

#10

ebd

Re: Black Limba Vessel

ebd

>Absolutely lovely!!!

Re: Black Limba Vessel

#11

Beautiful

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Most likely it is silica causing the glint.