Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Difficult to dry crotch figure?

Posts

Difficult to dry crotch figure?

#1

Difficult to dry crotch figure?

Dave Belser

>The photo shows some white birch crotch where I attempted to cut out the figure into a 3x3" square blanks (one is turned round). I'm a little surprised at how badly the drying went. Both blanks were coated with anchorseal all around. I have a fair amount of experience (mostly successfully) drying wood. With this birch, I was attempting to have small blanks that would be entirely crotch/feather figure when turned.

It's a little hard to see from the photo (color balance is off), but the wood just blew apart along the feather lines in the figure. Is this a notoriously hard thing to do or did I just mess up this time? Is there some special technique for drying just figured wood? Is it reasonable to try to cut a blank just from the figured area from a crotch?

The one thing that I know was not a good idea is that this tree came down in a storm during September and as I remember, we had had a lot of recent rain. It's possible that the wood was just way too wet to begin with.

- Dave


img

Re: Difficult to dry crotch figure?

#2

Re: Difficult to dry crotch figure?

Barry Irby

>I have a birch crotch drying (dry?) in my shop. Its a block about 12" X 7" by 3". It has some cracks in it along the feather. I am thinking of cutting it into veneer and was hoping the cracks were on the surface and there would be a "sweet" part in the middle.

If I wanted box blanks, I would prep them by turning them green, rough hollowing them and taping them together butt to butt and drying them in a paper bag. When they were dry, I would finish turn them. Hard to dry a big solid piece without cracks.

Re: Difficult to dry crotch figure?

#3

maybe next time....

Dave Belser

>Thanks Barry, I'll give that a try next time.

I'm just surprised at how badly these broke up. Like the piece that you describe, I tried to just turn past the cracks - find some good wood - but they just go clear through, to the point where the wood just flakes off along the figure lines.

The blocks are only 3" sq and about 6" long. I've dried plenty of green stuff that size without problems. I didn't have a specific project in mind which is why I left them sq.

- Dave

Re: Difficult to dry crotch figure?

#4

Re: Dave, many times when a tree

Allen Neighbors

>comes down in a storm there are stress cracks throughout. These cracks will easily and normally follow grain... thus, feather cracking. I don't think there is anything you could have done.

I have some Bois d'Arc that is the same way... came down in a storm... full of cracks throughout the tree.

These storms just put too much stress on the tree. Just my thoughts on it.

Re: Difficult to dry crotch figure?

#5

Steven Antonucci

Sealer might have helped....

steve antonucci

>I've had that happen and worse...

I have a bucket of Anchorseal that I dunk the whole thing and it helps bit, but you really need to be patient. Barry's idea about turning closer to finished will also help, but I'd still seal the roughout too.

Steve

Re: Difficult to dry crotch figure?

#6

Re: Sealer might have helped....

Dave Belser

>I coated all of both blanks with Anchorseal, didn't dunk but I didn't spare any. Thats why I'm suprised about the complete failure drying.

- Dave

Re: Difficult to dry crotch figure?

#7

Re: Dave, many times when a tree

Dave Belser

>Allen thats best answer yet - It's not my fault!

I've never heard of what you are describing before but it sure matches my experience with this tree. Most of the figure I cut from it did this. The tree branched into two large trunks just a little way up, one side was dead. The wood I kept came from the live side. I guess if the tree droped in a storm it might not have been in great shape to begin with.

- Dave

Re: Difficult to dry crotch figure?

#8

Re: It's better when we're not

Allen Neighbors

>at fault, huh. :o) We had a tornado hit here in April last year. I got a lot of wood from it. All but just a few pieces have stress cracking.

Sometimes when turning some of it, and slight cracks show up, I'll put CA on the crack, allow about 5 secs for it to penetrate, wipe it off, immediately sand with lathe turning. And then repeat again and again, until sanding doesn't leave dust in the crack (it's filled).

Re: Difficult to dry crotch figure?

#9

Re: Dave, many times when a tree

Jorge Castaneda

>Dave,

Even without a tree falling in a storm, a crotch is an are fulll of stress, I made a platter of green elm and boy, did it ever change shape!

it did not crack on me but could not possibly turn it again. Some areas srank considerably more than others.

Jorge