Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

1st Maple Goblet

Posts

1st Maple Goblet

#1

1st Maple Goblet

John Bussom

>This was inspired by Curt Fuller's posting of his segmented goblet, LOML says "I like that" so I try! Not as beautiful as Curt's but just getting it off the lathe in one piece was an miracle for me!

Well John Lucas here is a pic, I took it outside in the noow sun to do it, appreciate your comments and I don't take them as hostile, I realize any comments from this fine group are meant to be constructive to my PPPhotos. I am planning to make the "frugal photo studio" if that don't help then call on some advice from some contacts I have with the local newspaper photographers and bribe them a little!

John


img

Re: 1st Maple Goblet

#2

Re: 1st Maple Goblet

John Bussom

>I forgot to put the size of this, 2" dia 7" high, the cup wall is about 1/8 thick and 2" deep, only finished with mineral oil, kind of a hurried finish but it will do. LOML is very happy with it even though it don't have the Celtic Knot.

John

Re: 1st Maple Goblet

#3

Re: 1st Maple Goblet

David Breth

>Hope you don't mind a comment from a hack. My thought is that the ball especially, and the stem overall are too thick to blend well with the cup and base. If the ball were smaller (north-south and east-west), I think that would improve it, and it would drive the stem overall to be of less diameter.

I personally would like to see the cup of a slightly larger diameter than the base, these appear to be pretty close in diameter. I say that having absolutely no idea what the rule of thumb is.

In my mind, goblets are pretty tricky guys to do. I've only turned a handful, and only one that I liked long term. I'm hoping that some folks will respond with methods of working the stem, because when they get thin, they get whippy and difficult to control.

David B.

Re: 1st Maple Goblet

#4

Re: 1st Maple Goblet

C.W.Stivison

>Nothing more fun to be around than a happy woman.

Re: 1st Maple Goblet

#5

Re: 1st Maple Goblet

Curt Fuller

>That's about a gazillion times better than my first goblets were. You've done a nice job.

Re: 1st Maple Goblet

#6

Re: The photo- the goblet is too..............

Jamie Donaldson

>...close to the background, and you rotated the camera "anti-clockwise"(as the Brits say) rather than clockwise- the result being that the flash is below rather than above the axis of the lens.This places the shadows above the elements of the goblet and gives a distorted view of the goblet profile. Rotate the camera clockwise next time and the shadows will be less obtrusive, and place the background at least 2 ft behind and leaning away from the turning.

Re: 1st Maple Goblet

#7

Re: 1st Maple Goblet

John Bussom

>Thanks David,

No I don't mind constructive critism, I agree with the ball size but you should have seen how big it was before I slipped with my skew, I liked it a bit more after cleaning it up again!

I hope someday to be able to have the confidence to be able to do thinner stems but this being my first of a somewhat delicate piece I was really pleased just getting it off the lathe in one piece!

I too am looking forward to any response concerning the "rule of thumb" for these goblets, something I read alot about before turning my 1st segmented bowl, but then maybe I should just measure some of the antique collection of stemware sitting in the MadeInChina????? closet! Brother just dwells on that word!

A link I received from Mr. Curt Fuller that may help explaining how to turn the thin stems http://www.turnedtreasures.com/project.html/goblet.html

John

Re: 1st Maple Goblet

#8

Re: The photo- the goblet is too..............

John Bussom

>Jamie,

Thanks for the photo tips, it took me awhile to understand what your were telling me, it's 7am after working 12 and being up a little while longer..... and the liquid relaxer doesn't help the old mind either this early in the am.

I am working on the photo part of this, setting up the Phrugal Studio and that being the size it is will put the backdrop where it should be I hope. I started on it yesterday and as soon as I get some better pics I will post them and I hope you will be able to point out my mistakes!

Thanks

John

Re: 1st Maple Goblet

#9

Re: 1st Maple Goblet

John Bussom

>Thanks Curt,

for your kind words and the post of your beautiful "celtic knot" goblet that inspired me to "gitterdone" that I modeled after

John