Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

v grove bowl gouge vs u grove bowl gouge

Posts

v grove bowl gouge vs u grove bowl gouge

#1

v grove bowl gouge vs u grove bowl gouge

Bill Noce - NE Ohio

>which is the better of the two groves? I have been using the v grove since I have been turning(1995)never had opportunity to use the u grove would like opions. Part time lurker.....O:)O:)

Re: v grove bowl gouge vs u grove bowl gouge

#2

Re: v grove bowl gouge vs u grove bowl gouge

john lucas

>This is only true of my gouges and may not be true for all. The V shaped gouge will grind with the wings thicker (depending on how you grind it). The Wings on my V groove gouge sharpen so they have an angle about 45 to 55 degrees (I haven't measured them). The U shaped gouges I have grind so the wings are really sharp (25 to 35 degrees).

Obviously this depends on the way you have your jigs set up. I see no difference in the chip removeal on my gouges.

Re: v grove bowl gouge vs u grove bowl gouge

#3

Re: Dif'rnt Strokes

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You touch on a seemingly neverending debate. What I gather from a number of discussions, both friendly and not so, is that "point" cutters, especially those using their gouges like a "strong," will prefer the "v" flute [a la Glaser], whereas "side" cutters, especially those who keep the tool axis close to horizontal, will prefer the "U" shape [a la Ellsworth] because it clears shavings better for that style.

[get ready. here it comes . . . . |;-}}}}]

Re: v grove bowl gouge vs u grove bowl gouge

#4

Re: v grove bowl gouge vs u grove bowl gouge

Bill Neddow

>There are about as many opinions on this as there are turners. But here is mine. I like the vee grove because it is more versatile. If you put a fingernail grind on it, you have a large, medium and small bowl gouge in one tool. If I look at the last 1/8 inch tip of my bowl gouge, it is about 3/16 of an inch wide -- this on a 5/8 inch (bar diameter) gouge. That means I can make my 2 inch diameter by 1 inch high pedestal jewelery bowls, which are paper thin, with my 5/8 inch gouge. Why do I do it? Because of the rigidity of the tool. I get less catches. (Most catches are preceded by vibration, either of the tool or the wood) On something that small, a catch means an explosion.

Yet if I make cuts using part of the side of my 5/8 inch gouge, I can easily remove shavings a half inch wide, or wider, in one pass. That I need when I am doing the big (2 foot diameter) bowls I often turn.

Where I really like to use the U shape gouge is for the rounding out of rough blocks of wood into round shapes. You turn a lot of air when you are knocking off the corners. I use the old fashioned square end, as it comes from the factory, (no fingernail). I do a push cut, starting in the center of the disk of wood, and heading toward the outside (rough edge) . At the center, you can always start a cut without catching one of the corners. Hold the tool so it is at about a 10 degree angle off the normal straight-on tool approach. The angle is aimed at the outside edge of the wood. As you cut across the bottom of the piece of wood, the right side of the tool, (closest to the wood) is actually riding on the bevel. This pushes the tool out, when you hit the air pockets and keeps you from getting a catch. You are actually cutting with the bottom of the U or slightly up the left side of the tool. I can remove more wood faster this way than with a fingernail grind. But once the wood is round, the fingernail grind is far more effective.

Re: v grove bowl gouge vs u grove bowl gouge

#5

Get'em both sharp and ride the bevel

Jake Niedling

>

Re: v grove bowl gouge vs u grove bowl gouge

#6

Re: It's "U" for me!

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: v grove bowl gouge vs u grove bowl gouge

#7

Re: v grove bowl gouge vs u grove bowl gouge

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Here's a bit of a email I sent today talking about the same thing.

I do prefer a V shape flute for two reasons. The first and most important is the smaller nose radius that is easy to control because the very tip acts like a smaller diameter tool. The other reason is the straight wings, on a clearing cut the tool can be buried and now it works just like a plane, a straight shearing cut. IMO (with no facts to back this up) a straight shaving doesn't clog the flute like a oval shape. Try to clog that V shape tool. A U shape flute has a lot of steel that enters the wood at the same time so it tends to be grabby. I have seen a friend roll a U shape tool way over, almost closed and get a beautiful shearing cut on the inside platter.

Don't be shy about this question... LoL

Re: v grove bowl gouge vs u grove bowl gouge

#8

Re: Doug-my experience is just the opposite,....

Jamie Donaldson

>... and it may be partly because I learned with a Sorby "U" profile which I still prefer. As a matter of fact, I was able to get into the shop yesterday for an afternoon of turning using your 2 gouges, and the "V" clogs quickly with semi-dry wood, and even moreso with damp wood. I have full control and really utilize the larger radius cutting tip on a "U" profile bowl gouge, and find the pointy "V" to not be as efficient for material removal. I do like your "V" flute for smaller tuning cuts like base details, and the P&N gouge is nearly identical, but I can do most of the same work with a same size "U" flute because I have been practicing with that profile for 21 years!

Re: v grove bowl gouge vs u grove bowl gouge

#9

Bill Blasic

Re: v grove bowl gouge vs u grove bowl gouge

Bill Blasic

>Well I'm going to give it a try as I just ordered one of Doug Thompsons gouges in the V shape. As he makes both styles I asked what he thought would work best for where I'm at in my turning and he suggested the V. Now I can look at two different aspects, V vs U and cryogenic treated powder steel with a 10% vanadium content vs M2. Hey does it get any better!!!

Re: v grove bowl gouge vs u grove bowl gouge

#10

I'm not buying that....

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>That 1/2V shape tool has been used by others and myself on green wood for the past year. If it had any problems the flute would have been opened more. The included angle and radius are more than what the old Glaser had. Matter of fact Johannes Michelsen has used that same 1/2 V shape tool for the past year and just ordered a boat load to go into his new ergonomic handle.

Re: v grove bowl gouge vs u grove bowl gouge

#11

Re: v grove bowl gouge vs u grove bowl gouge

Russ Fairfield

>I vote for neither. For those who can't decide between the U and the V, there is the parabolic shape that gives you the best of both. Henry Taylor omvented it and called it the "Superflute", but it has been copied by many others.