Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Grinding Wheels

Posts

Grinding Wheels

#1

Grinding Wheels

Tommy Holmes

>I need to buy a new grinding wheel for sharpening. Looking for opinions on which to buy. Choices are Norton 3X SG ceramic alumina (blue) 100 grit or Norton White Aluminum Oxide Wheels 150 grit. I am wondering about how good each type wheel is and if the finer grit would leave fewer serrations and a better edge on the tool.

Re: Grinding Wheels

#2

Re: Grinding Wheels

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>I have tried most of them, and the Norton SG wheels are by far the best value for the money. The produce a great finish, and last.

Mark

Re: Grinding Wheels

#3

Mark, where do you buy them?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>

Re: Grinding Wheels

#4

How About These *LINK*

Russ Babbitt Jr.

>Check this link.


Hartville Tools

Re: Grinding Wheels

#5

Not all Norton SG are created equal

Gordon Seto

>The forty some dollars wheels are not the same as those selling for hundred dollars.

The expensive wheels from CSUSA are far better quality. They are the best. The only disadvantange is the hole is only 5/8"; you can't use the Oneway wheel balancer. The explanation that CSUSA gave was the SG wheels are so balanced that we don't need to use the balancer.

I recently purchased a pair of cheaper Norton 3X SG wheels (Med. Grit 60 and Fine Grit) from Hartville. They don't have any hardness alphabet rating (I, J, K etc.). May be they are not intended for grinding HSS tools; they hardly perform as well as the real SG. On my 60 grit wheel, it grooves real bad. With very light touch, not even the weight of the tool, I couldn't even rounding the heel of the bevel of one tool without dressing the wheel. It is not even as good as the OEM AO wheels that came with the cheap Woodcraft slow speed grinder.

I don't know whether I got a defective wheel or what. They are very disappointing. BTW, I can use the wheel balancer on them; they run very smooth. On the fine wheel, It doesn't wear as well as the expensive one.

IMO, either cough up the big $$$ or stay with AO. You got what you paid for.

Gordon

Re: Grinding Wheels

#6

Re: Grinding Wheels *LINK*

George Van

>Tommy, if I could not afford the SG wheels from Craft Supply as suggested by Mark, I would check out the wheels from Oneway. I have both and think the Oneway is a big improvement over the Norton wheels I have. Stuart Batty said that the Oneway have a larger distance between the particles and therefore grind cooler and plug slower.


Oneway Wheels

Re: Grinding Wheels

#7

Re: Grinding Wheels

Greg Haugen

>I don't know many that use a 150 grit for sharpening. In my opinion its too fine and tends to heat up fast. The finest I would suggest would 100 or 120. My grinder is actually a 60 and a 60. I've found its a nice shaping wheel and for my bowl turning it does a really nice job for sharpening. I use the "pink" wheels from Woodcraft. They're a good "in the middle" option. They're AO but tend to resist grooving more than the white. They're slightly harder. They carry them in 60 and 120. For 30 bucks they're a pretty nice wheel.

http://www.woodcraft.com/family.aspx?familyid=216

Greg

Re: Grinding Wheels

#8

Re: Not all Norton SG are created equal

Steve Russell

>Hello,

Packard Woodworks sells an 8" Norton Seeded Gel Blue wheel with a 3/4" arbor hole (it also has an adapter insert for 5/8" arbors). I have two Baldor 8" grinders and both have 3/4" arbor shafts. The wheels are $100.00 each. Packard is the only place I've found that offers the SG wheels with 3/4" arbor holes. In fact, someone at Craft Supply recommended getting the wheels at Packard, since they did not have a SG wheel that would take a 3/4" shaft. Good luck and best wishes!

Better Woodturning and Finishing Through Chemistry...

Steve Russell

Eurowood Werks Woodturning Studio

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: Grinding Wheels

#9

Re: Not all Norton SG are created equal

Tom Minehan

>I had the same experience with the 3X wheels as Gordon. The 60 grit 3X wheel I purchased grooved in the same manner. I was sharpening my bowl gouge and it started to bounce all over. I stopped my grinding and noticed the groove in the wheel. From the looks of the groove I was sure I had turned my gouge into a square end scraper. I'm not new to sharpening and couldn't figure what I did wrong as the tool looked fine. I contacted the vendor and they sent me a new wheel. I found the new wheel did the same thing even when barely touching the tool to the wheel. Thought my grinder must be the problem. I put the wheel on the other end with the same results. Measured the runout on the grinder shafts and they were ok. Came to the conclusion the wheels were the problem and not me or the grinder.

Perhaps these are the wrong wheels for the application. There is a number 3X60-I on the wheel label. Maybe that means I hardness. The wheel was advertised as a wheel for turners. There were no warnings about what tool material restrictions.

My problem is going away - the rate I'm dressing the wheel will reduce it to it's hub shortly.

Re: Grinding Wheels

#10

Re: Grinding Wheels

robo hippy

>If you want to be excentric, try CBN wheels. They are cubic boric nitride. An 8 by 1 inch wheel costs about $300. I was looking into the ultimate grinding wheels. Was considering diamond (you can have them made) but was told that diamond is fine for carbide, but not good for steel because steel will clog the wheel up. CBN is made for grinding steel. The wheel is 3/16 of CBN on an aluminum core. They are custom made, in any grit that you want. I have an 80 grit for scrapers, and a 320 grit for gouges. My scraper wheel is almost 3 years old and shows almost no wear. I have worn out 1 320 wheel and am on my second one. You can't dress them as the material is so hard it will eat diamond dressers. You have to take it back to the maker for dressing. You clean it with a stick of aluminum oxide. A lot of money to put out for one wheel, but it lasts long enough to make it worth every penny. The finer grit does give a keener edge, and the tools last much longer. Any place that carries grinding supplies can get them or make them.

robo hippy

Re: Grinding Wheels

#11

Re: Mark, where do you buy them?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Craft Supplies USA

Re: Grinding Wheels

#12

Re: Not all Norton SG are created equal

Russ Babbitt Jr.

>I'm glad to hear they are not the same as the SG's from Craft. I bought the Craft ones long ago. I do like them. A friend bought the SG's from Hartville and he does like them, but he is also a beginner with little experience.

Re: Grinding Wheels

#13

Re: Grinding Wheels

Tommy Holmes

>I appreciate all the information and opinions from everyone. I think my best money are the SG's from either CSUSA or Packard. I'll try them and see.

Re: Grinding Wheels

#14

Re:Norton 3X grinding wheels New "K" hardness *LINK*

Jerry Hall

>I had the same problem of the Norton 8 x 1, (3SG60-I: 07660704659) "I" hardness being too soft. BTW it is also not 1" but a bit over 15/16" but that is no big deal. Norton has come out with a "K" hardness in 80 grit 8 x 1, (3SG46-K: 07660705422) My wonderfully responsive supplier sent me the following:

--------------------------------------

"Yes, there is no doubt, the K is the one for turners. The are just too soft for that type of work. I have a feeling Norton heard a lot of complaints and made a harder wheel for turners. Since you purchased your wheel the K came out which is 2 grades harder and much better suited for using a gouge.

After talking to Norton again they stated that 15/16" is within spec. Any time you want one I'd be happy to send it to you. However, I'm at the mercy of the manufacturer and my stock is right at 15/16".

After hearing the feedback from our turner customers last month we updated website to steer customers to the proper wheel."

http://www.sharpeningsupplies.com/Grinding-Wheels-C20.aspx


Norton 3X wheels

Re: Grinding Wheels

#15

"K" is it, I'll buy one next week and try it.

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>