Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Chuck opinions

Posts

Chuck opinions

#1

Chuck opinions

Pete (Stafford, VA)

>When I purchased my Jet Mini several years ago, I also purchased the Supernova chuck and several jaws. I have recently upgraded to a Powermatic 3520 (still have the Jet that I use for my pens) and now I either need to purchase a new threaded adapter (IF the new threaded adapter for the SuperNova2 will fit the original Supernova. I can't seem to find any accessories for the original Supernova anywhere) or maybe even a new chuck. I'm mainly interested in using the chuck for bowls - what do you Ladies and Gents think? Stick with what I've got or maybe upgrade to one of the Oneway chucks????

Thanks!

Re: Chuck opinions

#2

Re: Chuck opinions

Carole Valentine

>Hi Pete. You can never have too many chucks. :)))

Besides, I think it's a hassle to change adapters. I am pretty sure the Supernova2 adapters fit the older Supernova, but I can't swear to it. Fire off an email to Teknatool and ask them.

Re: Chuck opinions

#3

Re: Chuck opinions

Peter Teubel

>Teknatool makes only one adapter style...and they fit all their chucks.

Re: Chuck opinions

#4

Dick Hines

Re: Chuck opinions

Dick Hines

>The adapters will work. Your PM 3520 has 1 1/4" spindle and your mini is 1". The jaws for the Super Nova 2 are interchangable with your Super Nova2. You will find changeing jaws becomes a drag so I would suggest picking up a new chuck when you can.

Re: Chuck opinions

#5

Re: Chuck opinions

robo hippy

>I don't like the thread adapters, in your case, 1 1/4 to 1 inch. It puts the chuck that much farther from the headstock and will cause more wobble, especially since you have a new bigger lathe and will be turning bigger bowls. Don't overlook the Vicmark chucks. I have three and have used and abused them all severly, and they hold up.

robo hippy

Re: Chuck opinions

#6

Re: Chuck opinions *LINK*

Gordon Seto

>Pete,

Don't get the Oneway chuck; it is not because Oneway chuck is not a good chuck. Because you already own several Nova jaws. If you stick with Nova, all your existing jaws will work with any Nova brand chuck (new or discontinued). You don't have to repurchase the jaws that you already paid for.

You have 2 options:

Get a 1�" X 8 insert for your chuck or

get a spindle adaptor from 1�" X 8 TPI to 1" X 8 TPI for your Powermatic lathe so you can use any accessory that is 1" X 8 TPI.

If you continue to use both lathes, I would suggest you get the adaptor. Changing out the chuck insert is not too convenient each time you switch lathe.

If I get another chuck, I would also stick with Nova. The SN2 has a lot of improvement over the original SN.

Gordon


Nova chuck inserts

Re: Chuck opinions

#7

Re: Chuck opinions

Jim Swank

>The 3 I'd look closely at are the Oneway Stronghold, the Vicmarc 120, and the Nova Titan. It's hard to find fault with the Oneway products other than price. Vicmarc has a good reputation, though I've never used one. If you have several jaws for your Nova, I'd be inclined to go with the Titan for that reason alone.

Re: Chuck opinions

#8

Re: Chuck opinions

Bill Youngblood

>I also have a PM3520 and a Jet mini. I've had old style supernovas and had few complaints. I recently got a Vicmarc and REALLY like it. I think it holds as tight as the Novas and it works righty tighty lefty loosey. Much better than the backwards Novas. I boutht an adapter so I can use both Novas on the mini and the vicmarc on the PM. I rarely use a chuck but if I need another one I will probably get another vicmarc. Hope I don't confuse the issue any more than it is but that is just my opinion.

Bill

Re: Chuck opinions

#9

Re: Chuck opinions

Bob Fawcett

>If you stick with the Nova chucks, get a new 1 1/4" x 8 insert for the chuck. If you're like me, once you start using the Powermatic, you hardly ever use the mini.

If money is no object get a Titan or a Stronghold. I have the Stronghold and am very happy with the Oneway chucks. I also have a Talon. This was my Jet Mini chuck. I bought another insert for it to fit the PM and I don't think it has been on the mini since. You need the larger chuck when you mount large blanks in my opinion.

Re: Chuck opinions

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Chuck opinions

keith tompkins

>Jim, the jaws from the previous nova chucks won't fit the Titan...it uses jaws with three set screws each, while the others only use two. A friend of mine ordered the Titan with several jaws for the super-nova, assuming they would fit. He invited me over to check it out...none of the holes line up. the good news is the Titan is a nice chuck, far superior than the super-nova.

Re: Chuck opinions

#11

Re: Pete, Lefty tighty, Righty Loosey,

Allen Neighbors

>is what you're used to with your Nova Chucks. I'd stick with Nova.

The best way to go, IMNSHO, is to get the Large Nova Titan Chuck with the large PowerGrip Jaws, and get it with the 1 1/4 adapter, so it will be dedicated to your PM. You can still use any of the other Nova jaws on the Titan, if you should want to... you just can't use the PowerGrip jaws on the other Novas... you wouldn't want to, anyway.

I have two SN2s and am getting the Nova Titan with PG jaws, next. Carole's right; you can never have too many chucks. :o)

Re: Chuck opinions

#12

Re: Keith, Nova's Website says they will.

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Chuck opinions

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Pete, Lefty tighty, Righty Loosey,

keith tompkins

>Thanks, Allen. I'll have to check that out! I may pick one up for the outboard end of my General.

Re: Chuck opinions

#14

Re: Keith, Nova's Website says they will.

Allen Neighbors

>Quote from Teknatool' Nova Titan Chuck page: "All your existing Nova and SuperNova accessories will fit onto the Nova Titan - including inserts and accessory jaws!"

Re: Chuck opinions

#15

Re: Chuck opinions

Gordon Seto

>Tom,

I have original SuperNova, Midi, SN2 and Titan chucks. All the jaws for the smaller chuck fit the Titan. You just don't use the 3rd screw of the Titan slide. Only the large PowerGrip jaw for the Titan uses 3 screws per slide.

I think it is smart for the engineers from Nova to design all their jaws (except one) to be cross platform compatible with all their chucks.

As long as I stay with all Nova chucks; lefty, righty is not a problem. LOL

Gordon

Re: Chuck opinions

#16

Brad Vietje

Yes -- but not the other way around.

Brad Vietje

>

Re: Chuck opinions

#17

Brad Vietje

Re: Chuck opinions

Brad Vietje

>I'd get the Titan for the big lathe with the 1.25" insert, so you can still use all the jaws you own. You can get a second 1.25" insert for the Supernova if you want to use that one on the 3520, too. BTW: all the classic Supernova jaws and accessoried will fit the S-N-2 (and the Titan), except the geared T-handle for tightening the scroll, since the S-N-2 uses a hex ball. Jaws made for the Titan will only fit that chuck, as the jaw slides have 3 screw holes.

I'm sort of in the same boat, with a 3520-B and two lathes with 1"-8, though I inherited my dad's Stronghold when he died 2 years ago. I got the 1.25" insert for the Stronghold, so its dedicated to the 3520. I also got a 1.25" to 1" adaptor, as well as a 1.25" Supernova insert so I can keep the smaller chuck for the smaller lathe, and either convert it with the insert for work on the PM, or just screw on the adaptor for a few small jobs (and I agree that this is less than ideal, but a well-made adaptor should still run true). I'd rather have all one line, with interchangeable parts, so getting the Titan will make your situation less confusing and more coordinated than mine.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Chuck opinions

#18

Shaft Thread Question/thought

Barry Irby

>I know you can get adapters that screw on a shaft to convert it to different threads/diameters. Most of them I've seen are screwed onto a large shaft to extend it and make it smaller. Are there ones that are like sleeves that would be 1" by 8tpi internally and 1 1/4" by 8 tpi externally? You could screw that onto the shaft of the mini lathe and leave it. Then you could use all the accessories for your bigger lathe without have to change the insert in the chucks.