Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

Posts

Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#1

Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>At what point in closing in the upper portion of a bowl does it become a hollow form? I teach a lot of classes in bowl turning and a few in beginning hollow forms. Most of my hollow form students have been in one or more of my bowl turning classes. Often, a student has been turning bowls that are closed in a bit and the question on when it becomes a hollow vessel arises..

What do you think? Or is it a silly question?

Wally

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#2

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

Ron in Drums PA

>IMHO a hollow form is when the biggest thing you can use to sand the inside is your finger.

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#3

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

John Lucas

>Wally I've been asked that also. I think it has to be a small enough opening that you can't use it as a bowl. Just to thrown wood on the fire where does a vase fit in with this. Probably between the bowl and a hollow vessel. Kind of like discussing smidgen vs a pinch which is bigger.

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#4

Ellis Walentine

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

Ellis Walentine

>Funny, I was just talking to David Ellsworth about this the other day. He gets this question all the time, and his take is that if the opening is smaller than the major diameter, it is a hollow form. By that reasoning, a bowl with a turned-in rim would be a hollow form, but it would still be a bowl. David didn't mention where the crossover point is, and I suspect there isn't one.

Ellis

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#5

Thats easy...

Bob Fawcett

>Will a spoon fit through the opening? :-)

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#6

Re: Soup spoon, stirring spoon, salt spoon,.....??

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#7

Re: Thats easy...

georgetroy

>If you can't reach the inside part with a gouge, then you are undercutting and that would certainly be a consideration for a hollow form. GT

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#8

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

Ed in Sptbg.

>If you can get your hand in it and it's still useful, it's a bowl.

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#9

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

John Lucas

>But if you make a fist to get the food out you can't get your hand back out. Therefore it's a hollow vessel.

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#10

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

Jim King

>To me a hollow form is when you cannot finish the soup without tilting the vessel.

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#11

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

Rick Pixley

>Wally,congratulations on your award...My personal definition.perhaps over simplified.is a gowl gecomes a hollow form when you cannot turn the inside with a gouge...Take care,rick

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#12

now u know, wally

bob davis

>

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#13

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

tm

>When I cant decide I just call it a semi-hollow vessel.

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#14

Re: Soup spoon, stirring spoon, salt spoon,.....??

Bob Fawcett

>Soup spoon = soup bowl,

salt spoon = salt bowl,

stirring spoon = sugar bowl

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#15

Dick Hines

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

Dick Hines

>When you can only get one finger in at a time and you don't have to sand the inside.

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#16

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

Steven Smith

>If it isnt good for anything except to look at, its a hollow form.

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#17

Steve Kubien

Oh c'mon!

Steve Kubien

>A smidgen is 0.2746 of a pinch. What, am I the only one using the newer metric system?

Steve Kubien

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#18

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Okay, what would you call the much copied, beautiful pots made by the ancient SW Indians? Most were partially closed in at the top and all were funtional.

Wally

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#19

Re: When it is no longer useable

Russ Fairfield

>

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#20

It that a trick question?

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Pots are pots. The orignal pots are pottery pots. The turned pots are wooden pots.

Now, what is the difference between a pot and a vase?

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#21

Re: Seed Pots; Water Pots; etc..

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#22

Re: Wally, it's not a silly question... but

Allen Neighbors

>if you don't know for sure, no body does.

That's a fact, Jack... er, uh, Wally, and you can take it to the bank.

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#23

Re: That's too easy Wally- we call them pots!!!!

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#24

What Do You Call Them if They're Tuned Wood Copies

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>

Re: Bowls vs Hollow Forms.....

#25

Turned SW Pots?

Ron in Drums PA

>Beautiful?