Re: Stay with it ...
Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL
>Dick,
It looks like you have a great handle on the mechanics of making a segmented bowl. Joint tightness is good, and joint alignment is good. The mechanics are tough at first, with practice they get easier, but always require out attention. Consider the Woodturner Pro software, It is cheap, and allows you to forget about the calculations, and concentrate on the bowl design.
Next: A couple things to consider when/if you do the next one:
1) Never let the ring construction dictate the shape of the bowl. It is quite the opposite. We segmented turners have the luxury of deciding what we want to turn, and then building the wood to suit that design. IF you mess up a ring, you can turn it off and start again with another.
2) Don't try to scrimp on the wood. Some people think that segmenting is a good way to use as little wood as possible. Make the walls of your rings thick enough to allow for error, and for design changes. I almost never make the walls on my rough segment rings thinner that 1.25".
3) Never let your chucking method dictate the shape of the foot (true in any woodturning). Use enough of a waste block to let you turn the bottom that the piece needs.
4) When you look at the shape - ask yourself: "If this were a solid wood bowl, would the shape still be pleasing". I tell people that (at least in the past) segmented turners on the whole turn some of the worst shapes in the world, mostly because they spent all their time worrying about the rings designs. Additionally, they saw other segmented work and decided that it was the way segmented work was suppose to look - a good deal of it has horrid shape. Non-segmented turners are often intimidated by the work involved in segmenting, and as such are loath to tell a segmented turner that the shape of his work is not up to par (then again so are many solid wood bowls), so they tell the segmented turner how great the wood is, and how hard it much be to make, etc, and never tell them that the shape could use some refinement. The ends up being positive re-enforcement for ugly shapes. We have all done it - it is part of the learning process - grow beyond it. Shape, Shape, Shape. In 20 years all the wood will be dark brown or gray, but the shape will shine through.
Your piece is not ugly. It could use some refinement. I applaud you for trying segmenting. Most don't.
Good luck in your future work.
Mark