Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Lathe features

Posts

Lathe features

#1

Lathe features

Robert D. Macgregor

>I hope to be able to afford a lathe upgrade before I get too old to lift a tool anymore. One issue that I would like some feedback on is the relative merits of swivel-head lathes vs. sliding head vs. outboard turning (fixed head).

It seems like most of the time when I see a comment about a swivel-head lathe it is a complaint about realignment problems. Is this just with the low-cost-range lathes, or is it still and issue with a $2000 or $3000 lathe? Would it be handier to get a lathe with a sliding headstock so I can run it down to the end and turn bowls without a lot of back twisting (I think both the Jet and Delta 1642 are like this, and some lathe heads both swivel and slide)? Finally, assuming I don't have a reversible-motor lathe, how much of a learning curve is there to working on the right side of a bowl, instead of the left, in outboard turning?

Thanks,

BOB

Re: Lathe features

#2

Re: Lathe features

Rik

>Greetings Bob,

I use a PM 3520 primarily for bowl work and love being able to slide the head stock to the end - much easier on the back. I also have the 18" extension for larger work.

-Rik

Re: Lathe features

#3

Re: Lathe features

John Lucas

>Robert Each feature has it's problems. Rotating head has alignment problems but there are ways around this. Also the tool rest may not reach all the areas of the turning or will have vibration.

Sliding headstocks require more space at the end of the lathe so you need more room in your shop. If your doing pieces larger than the lathe swing you need a freestanding tool rest or in the case of the Oneway and Powermatic you need a "bowl turning extension that mounts lower than the standard ways.

outboard turning also requires more space and you either need left hand threads and reversing or a faceplates that lock on. Either way you need reverse on the lathe. The same problem with the tool rest exists on thsi.

Re: Lathe features

#4

Steven Antonucci

Depends on your budget and needs...

steve antonucci

>I almost bought a VB36 about 2 years ago (some of you might remember that fiasco with EBAY), but in retrospect, it would be largely wasted on me. Not a talent thing, but a capacity thing, since I don't turn that big all that often. Sure it's a great lathe and will spin a big log, but is that what you really need?

Within each of the price brckets, you'll see a "clear winner". For about $1,000, I don't think you can beat a Nova. For about $1800, a lot of people like the Jet 1642. For $2500, either the Powermatic 3520 or Vega are great lathes. Is the Powermatc worth 2.5x a Nova? I'm not sure.

I have a Nova 3000, and for all of it's shortcomings, it's never held me back. The swivel head is nice, and no major problem to realign. It's nice to be able to stand in front of the work when hollowing or making a bowl.

If I was in the market for a new lathe, here's my short list of features that I consider essential:

1.) Overall mass. More (in the right places) and no such thing as too heavy.

2.) Big bearings to match a big swing. Big wood on little lathe means dead bearings pretty soon...

3.) "Variable speed"- having it controlled electronically is nice, but I've live with changing belts and don't really mind it...Need a low speed to round big wood.

4.) Overall fit and finish. Does everything line up? Burrs on the ways?

Hope this is helpful.

Steve

Re: Lathe features

#5

Look at it another way

Greg Haugen

>What do you turn? Bowls or vessels all of the above are good choices. Don't count out short bed lathe either, like the Vicmarc. IF you turn smaller items or spindles, any features with the swing don't matter. Look for a solid lathe or between centers length, Oneways 1224-heavy duty construction for a small lathe with a bed ext. you've got a nice spindle lathe.

Swiveling heads can be realigned in seconds with a Double Ended MT2, check packard woodworks. One end in the tailstock and the other in the headstock, they're aligned. 5 Seconds max. Most heads that swivel also slide. Sliding is nice also. If you want to core bowls ever, I would recommend at least a horse and a half.

I also like to use "tommy bar" chucks over "keyed" chucks. I won't look at a lathe if there's no spindle lock.

It all depends on what you want to turn.

As Steve said its alot easier to put a price range on it and then some options really come to the top.

Generals are also nice lathes.

Greg Haugen

Re: Lathe features

#6

Re: Lathe features

Jim in Manassas

>I have the PM 3520, and I am sold on it. I have not turned a big enough bowl to have to slide the head to the end. But I know when I am ready I can. The power is great, it is heavy enough, like I said I am sold on it. Go for the PM 3520 if you can spend the $2,800.00.

Re: Lathe features

#7

Okay, stupid question time

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>outboard turning also requires more space and you either need left hand threads and reversing or a faceplates that lock on.

Would you have to have a special faceplate for outboard turning?

I ask this because one of the lathes I'm looking at is the General 26020VDR-M2. The guy at Woodcraft in Fairfield, OH mentioned being able to put the faceplate on the left side of the headstock for outboard turning. The problem I see with this is A: Righthand vs Lefthand threads, and B: According to General's website the outboard threads are a different diameter.

I found out that although it may require waiting a little I might have more funds available for lathe acquisition than I originally thought. The Jet 16-42, while apparently at the top of its class, has moved down the list a tad.

Re: Lathe features

#8

Re: Okay, stupid question time

John Lucas

>Randy It depends on the lathe. Some have left hand threads. Many have threads that are either left hand or smaller size than the inboard spindle. Some lathes like the Nova 3000/1624, and a few others that have a swiveling head will let you turn the lathe all the way around and turn outboard. The Nova even has an auxilliary tool rest that mounts outboard. You'll have to do the research on the specific models you are looking at to find out for sure what they have outboard.

Re: Lathe features

#9

Re: Lathe features

John Lucas

>Jim It's not the size of the wood that I use the sliding/swinging headstock. It's being able to stand upright while turning the inside of bowls or hollow vessels. What I like about the sliding headstock is being able to use a steady rest while hollowing vessels and still stand at the end with my back straight. You can't do that with a swiveling headstock.

Re: Lathe features

#10

Re: Okay, stupid question time

John Kyler

>Some lathes have the same size thread but right or left thread (in/out).

Now with that in mind, there are also faceplates that are threaded with both right and left. Had one.

Re: Lathe features

#11

Re: Lathe features

Jeff Myroup

>I agree with John. The sliding headstock is great. When hollowing I can move to positions that I could not due with out it. It gives me greater control over the tool.

Re: Lathe features

#12

I vote for the sliding head stock as well

Bob Fawcett

>I have a 3520, so I am prejudiced. I like being able to move to the end of the lathe. I also have the 18" extension which can be mounted lower. The cost is less than $300. So far, I have not turned anything that requires me to mount it lower than the 20" swing of the lathe, but I have a large slab just waiting on me to do so.

The reversable motor is also nice for sanding, and thats about all I have used it for so far. Haven't found a need to stand on the other side and turn in reverse. I can slide the headstock to the end and reach anyting turning in forward. If your budget is $3000, I don't think you can beat the PM.

Re: Lathe features

#13

Depends what you want to do

Jim Swank

>Outboard is fine for bowls. Whether you need a separate faceplate or chuck insert, turn forward or learn to turn reverse, none of that matters once you get past the initial learning curve.

The real place a sliding headstock is superior is if you want to do both bowls and hollowforms.

One other things you should consider is whether the headstock spindle is hollow so you can use vacuum chucking in the future.

Re: Lathe features

#14

Re: Okay, stupid question time *LINK*

Peter Hyde

>Randy,

The Generals all have a different sized LH thread on the outboard. They also have provision to mount an outboard extension to take a higher toolrest. See item #260-B60 here:-


http://www.general.ca/pagemach/acces_g/lathe.html

Re: Lathe features

#15

Re: Okay, stupid question time

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>Thanks, that answered the question. The guy at Woodcraft was partialy right. He mentioned the outboard turning but he said the regular faceplate would work. He was wrong. With a 20" swing inboard I would probably seldom need any more capacity but I would like to have the option.

Re: Lathe features

#16

Re: Lathe features

Robert D. Macgregor

>I appreciate the various viewpoints and advice. I sort of lean toward the sliding headstock since my body really doesn't do well with extended bending and twisting. Of course, a number of lathes offer both sliding and swiveling, so I don't absolutely have to choose irrevocably!

My current lathe came with IN (RH) and OUT (LH) faceplates, but I haven't yet used the outboard because I don't have an outboard rest.

Thanks, again.

BOB

Re: Lathe features

#17

Re: Lathe features

Allen Neighbors

>I chose the Oneway 1640 2HP. I turn 24" outboard, using the bed extension, riser block and tailstock; everything has right hand threads, same spindle size. Spindle has a groove to capture set screws for reverse turning. It blows the 3 grand price limit, though.

Re: Lathe features

#18

Re: Randy-General faceplates used to ...

Jamie Donaldson

>... have both LH and RH threads, but I haven't looked at any of the current production originals in several years. It's very easy to look at a General faceplate and tell if they are double threaded.

Re: Lathe features

#19

Re: Randy-General faceplates used to ...

John Lucas

>Delta used to make some also that were 1x8 both left and right threads. They look like an X pattern on the inside of the faceplate so it's easy to tell if you have one of those.

Re: Lathe features

#20

Re: Randy-General faceplates used to ...

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>The way I read the info on General's website not only is the outboard lefthand thread but it is a larger diameter as well. If so, a different faceplate would required for outboard turning. It isn't that big of a deal, it's just that it isn't QUITE as simple as I was led to believe. It's probably another case of "New and Improved" where it is actually the opposite.

Re: Lathe features

#21

Re: Randy-General faceplates used to ...

Bill Howatt

>I have a General 26020VD a few years old and the inboard thread over the bed is 1-1/4 X8TPI the outboard thread is LH 1-1/8 X8TPI. Dumb but this is the way they always have been AFAIK.

Does make things more complicated because you can't just use the plates/inserts threaded both LH and RH because of the diameter difference. No idea why they thought this was a good thing to do.

Bill

Re: Lathe features

#22

Keith Tompkins

Re: Randy-General faceplates used to ...

keith tompkins

>The General uses a 1 1/4" rh thread inboard, 1 1/8" Lh thread on the outboard. I'm not sure why, possibly to avoid grabbing the wrong faceplate...I like turning with a long bed lathe...I lean against the bed, giving me lots of support.