We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Has anyone used the RS2000 hollower..specifically the hooker tool with the swivel tip holder and cutter? Comments on how it cuts and performs esp. by comparison with the Sorby Hollowmaster/bent multi-tip tool or in comparison withteh Kelton tools?
Also would the cutter holder and cutter from the Sorby Hollowmaster fit the hooker tool? It looks similar and they're both made by Sorby.
>... the Stewart tools, and I often use the swan neck with small scraper in the armbrace handle for smoothing interiors. There are lots more hollowing tools available now than when I learned from David Ellsworth in 1990, and I use his style tools which I made. Recently John Jordan introduced his own tools, and I find them ideal for my purposes, but use the Stewart tool handle and Jamieson "D" handle for a captured hollowing set-up with the JJ tools. Most of the hollowing tools available are over engineered, over priced, and difficult to sharpen, something few take into consideration when buying without having used them first.
Thank you...I couldn't see much of a difference between the RS2000 and the Stewart tool, either...except price.
After my experince with the kelton system, I know exactly whatyou mean by not trying a tool first. Which is why I asked about the RS2000. I don't live in an area where there are turning clubs, a WoodCraft, or even courses offered through the community college...nada, zip. So my opportunity to try a tool like the Kelton or the RS2000 is almost zero. I have to rely on more experienced turners to maybe offer some insight.
I figured...hope...that the RS2000 might perform more like the Sorby Hollowmaster that I own and like.
The one design factor I don't like about the Keltons is that there is limited versatilty with the fixed edge. I am/was hollowing a vessel through a one inch hole and there seemed to be a gap from right under the shoulder...which I could kind of reach with the severely bent Kelton...and the side wall--right at the transition--that I couldn't reach at all, not even with the less bent cutter. In fact, it was trying to thin that area out where I got the terrible catch that nearly (may have, in fact) destroyed my work. I am not enthusiastic about any other tool that takes the same approach.
I like the design of the RS2000 because if it is anything like the Hollowmaster, I can reach all areas with a simple adjustment of the swivel cutting tip. I just need to know how it performs for folks...especially those who use and like the Sorby Hollowmaster.
>Well, that's interesting...I can see how it would add a great deal of stability.
But I don't see many tools that conform tot hat philosophy. The keltons, for instance (like many others) have a curved or swan neck shape. That immediately puts the cutting tip out of line with the shaft and in fact makes the tool more likely to twist in your hands if there is a catch...DAMHIKT.
With my Sorby Hollowmaster...and I assume the RS2000...if the cutting tip is at a fair angle from the curve of the shaft--for instance when cutting deep under the shoulder of a HF--the torsion seems to actually be applied almost parallel to the straight section of the shaft. A catch does twist the tool, it levers it end to end, if yousee what I mean.
Then too, kelton claims that there are three cutting edges on their tools. On the curves shafts, none of which is directly in line with the shaft, and all of which tend to roll the tool if a catch occurs.
That's the way I see it, but I'm a confirmed lubber and it could reasonably be asked "what does he know?" :)
I am afraid you may have some misunderstanding about the cutting edges "inline" with the shaft. Only the straight part of the shaft is supposed to be on the tool rest. Unless you have bent the tool, the 3 cutting edges of Kelton hollower are very close to the same axis of the shaft.
No matter what hollowing tool you use, if you have the curve part of the shaft on the toolrest, you will have to counter the torque from the tip rolling.
From your other post, "I give up on Keltons", you said you have better success with the Sorby Hollowmaster. I think the reason may be Sorby has a wider shaft, therefore you have a wider margin of the cutting tip still inline with the shaft. But that flat wide shaft won't allow you to hollow with a relative small opening.
I think most of the tool design have their pros and cons; you win some lose some. You have to work around their characteristic.
>I see your point (and nice illustrations, btw...although the one on the left isn't quite true to the shaft, or your point) but regardless, unless I'm missing something else, the torque is not going to run down the length of the shaft. The way I see it, the pressure is on the tip directly in line with the first half inch or so of the tip. That will make the tool want to twist...and Yes, when using the keltons I have always had the straight part of the shaft on the rest....as I do with the Hollowmaster.
I think you are correct about the Hollowmaster, for certain. The flat surface tends to counter the torsion being applied to the tip...at least to some degree. That,s one of the reasons I asked about the RS2000. It is essentially set up like the Hollowmaster but has a round shaft.
I guess it really comes down to whether the flat underside is the reason I have little or no problem with the Hollowmaster or is it some other factor that makes the keltons such a bear to use...for me.
I'm not following your argument here, and I think Gordon's photos make his point very well...
If you are keeping the rest under the straight part of the shaft, there will be almost no torque at the handle -- that's why they're designed that way. While the one tip extends a bit beyond the axis of the shaft, it does so only very slightly, and there will still be very little twisting force at all. The curve can be much more extreme than the example pictured, and still no torque (though it won't be as stable to turn with).
As an exercise, take a coathanger and bend it different ways and experiment with various tool rest positions... you can have not only a swan neck, but even a triple-S curve, and as long as the tip is in line with the handle (or very nearly so), the handle sees no torque if the rest is positioned properly. That is, ALL of the curve has to be on the other side of the rest from your hands.
One other thing I notice is that these tools are very thick (tall?) and blunt at the tips. That means that in tight quarters (inside small vessels), you may have to cut well above center to keep the heel from holding the cutting surface away from the wood. You could possibly get a catch if the tool is too low, and you are actually contacting the wood with the lower, unsharpened heel surface -- when the tool rotates enough that the cutter suddenly engages, you'd be in for a bang. This may not contribute to your problem, but its a possibility. If you hold the cutters with the curve parallel to the floor, cut a little further above center with a sharp tool, and it ought to work fine -- a little CCW rotation is the usual orientation.
You should also be learning to use these tools in a shallow, end grain bowl, BTW, and not inside a hollow form where you can't see what's going on. Once you've got the tool mastered in an open form, you can learn to work inside HF's by feel.
>DW, before you invest in a Sorby check out the Don Pencil Scorpion and it's little brother the stinger for small pieces. I've used my Stewart (the Scorpion and the Sorby are copies) since 1987. I don't like the feel and fit of the Sorby nearly as well. The Scorpion feels better than the Sorby to me and is a quality tool. For me, the round bar of the Stewart, Sorby, Scorpion has an advantage over a flat bar. I like to tip the cutter a little when using it. This is especially true when using the teardrop scraper.
When using hollowing tools you should be cutting on or a little above center for best and safest results. I feel that the swiveling tip has a big advantage over tools like Kelton. You can swivel the cutter to present it to the wood for the best cutting, depending on where you are in the vessel.
DW, I suggest that you make yourself a boring bar to remove most of the wood inside the vessel. For small and medium sized pieces, use a 1/2 x 1/2-inch mild steel bar about 12 inches long. bore a hole in-line with the length of the bar to insert a 3/16 inch cutter as is used with Stewart and other tools. You can grind off the corners of the cutter a little and intall it in the hole, using med. or thick CA glue. To replace the cutter just heat the bar and the glue will melt. Install the bar into a handle at least 17 or 18 inches long. To use the tool bore a hole down the center of the vessel (do this with any hollowing tool). Just insert the bar and work it back and forth from the center hole to the vessel wall. You can hollow most of the piece in a very short time. Use the tool pressed against your side and move your body back and forth. Makes for very stable and safe cutting.