We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Jennifer's great bowl made me decide to ask a question that has been on my mind for awhile. Everytime I see a Catalpa bowl I am struck by how much it looks like Paulownia. I have never turned Catalpa or seen any but I do know about Paulownia. Has anyone turned both? If so could you please compare them?
>Barbara, I turned that piece of Paulownia that you had given me last, it was harder to turn than the Catalpa. Also a species from one area of the country might be slightly different than the same species from another area. I'm trying to justify why I like Catalpa better than Paulownia, not that your wood wasn't great!?!? : )
>The Paulonia that I have run across here is AR was a lot softer than most of the Catalpa that I find. It was the fastest growing wood that I have ever seen. There were 1.5" rings on it, or put another way a 3" diameter increase for one year.
l only got the stump just above ground, and it had a nice big curly figure to it.
I have seen some dead standing trees, and was surprised that it was fairly decay resistant for a white wood.
I have a nice big Catalpa that I got back in August that I am just now getting around to working with. It is over 4' diameter, and has a hollow of about 1' diameter, which leaves about 18" of good wall thickness. Everything from the dust-bowl years of the 30's on back is missing. Arkansas wasn't as bad as Texas and Ok, and other southern plains states, but there were some records set back then that still stand.
I was out of paint for the ends when I got it home, and just kept thinking that I would set up a sprinkler at the first signs of checking. I have a new reason to respect this wood, because it still is uncoated, and no checks yet.
I visited the largest catalpa this summer. It is one of those that rather than climb, you can more or less walk up it, and out its giant limbs. I took a seat on one, and had a friend take my photo. When I started to get up, it was easy to see that the pith center was right there slightly above the surface. Lots of old trees only have living tissue on one side, usually the underside, and the ones that have really great rot resistance will just keep holding up to the elements without rotting, but weather away more like stone really.
The only thing that I don't like about catalpa is the creosote smell tickles my nose, and makes me want to sneeze.
I was telling one of my friends that I have done a fair amount of boat work with, that I think it would make a great Teak substitute. It is about the same weight, density, color, and grain pattern. Neither has great strength, but at least it doesn't dull the blades as fast as teak. The problem is that it doesn't grow a long straight trunk.
This one winds 360� in about 8'.
Well, I guess you found how to get me wound up. Sorry for going on so long.
>Barbara, I've not turned Catalpa. But I've made bandsaw boxes out of it. The sap gummed up the blade on my bandsaw and then it burned the rest of the way through. :o) I've turned only that chunk of Paulownia that I got from you.
Believe me, Catalpa will turn better than Paulownia. The Paulownia is much softer wood, closer to pine, I think.
>Barb, I have turned both, but the paulownia I had was plantation grown and much softer with much wider growth rings than our native wild stuff. The catalpa I had was very light in weight and soft. Mine was also very, very dry. I thought they were somewhat similar with the exception of the growth rings and the smell. Some of the catalpa did have spectacular chatoyance which surprised me.
>I was thinking about white pine... don't know what tree it comes from... probably not a true pine...
Yellow Pine is one of the most "warpable" woods I've ever worked with. I used it on the outside window frames when I put new windows in my house. Some of them need to be replaced already... warped completely out of place. :o)