Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Can I fix this?

Posts

Can I fix this?

#1

Steve Kubien

Can I fix this?

Steve Kubien

>I was turning a splated maple bowl today and in my excitment, I didn't drill a depth hole. I managed to put a 3/8" hole through the base. What is the best way to fix this and move on? Epoxy and dust? Epoxy putty? Cut away even more and glue in a new base (really do not want to do that)? Except having a trashed piece and hang it up close to the lathe as a reminder? I would appreciate your help because the wood is pretty spectacular and I really love the shape.

Thanks,

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: Can I fix this?

#2

Leo Van Der Loo

Steve fit and glue a loony over the hole, it gets

Leo Van Der Loo

>worth more that way or you could make it a toony ;-))

I've got a natural edge thin Black Walnut sitting in the shop where the bottom center is the glue block, any good ideas for that one ??? ;-)))

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Can I fix this?

#3

Re: Can I fix this?

Jeff Myroup

>Steve,

It is hard to tell what the best fix would be with out seeing the piece. You could try and turn a plug out of the same wood. It might be better than epoxy and dust. A new base with contrasting wood would probably work as well. You could highlight it with turquise or some other contrasting filler. Either way I am interested in seeing what you come up with. I am sure we have all faced this problem/ or some variation in the past. Good luck

Re: Can I fix this?

#4

Re: Can I fix this?

Mac

>Steve,Another design opportunity as "they" say.I have this opportunity often and what I do is:drill a hole(in the bottom of vessel) of appropriate size with a forstner or other good quality bit,drill it about 1/4 or so deep.Cut a piece of burl(in my case I use cherry burl often)turn it to approximately the size of the hole you just drilled,doesn't have to fit well.Glue it into the bottom hole,let it dry,use a parting tool to cut a groove around the burl you just installed,diamond shape one works well,mix up some epoxy and use coloring in it to contrast with the burl( I use ebony dust)fill the groove you just made with the parting tool with the colored epoxy and let it harden.After it dries, continue to turn vessel and smooth the bottom of the vessel out and it will make a perfect inlay with a dark band around the insert.Nobody except the two of us will know it wasnt intended....take care......Mac

Re: Can I fix this?

#5

Re: Can I fix this?

Stuart Johnson

>Find a couple nice antique looking metal buttons, file off the part for the thread and counter sink one on the bottom and one on the inside. If done neatly it will look like a design feature. I do this on purpose with some of my segmented pieces.

Re: Can I fix this?

#6

Re: Can I fix this?

jmohnike

>If you can.........remove the bowel and reverse it on the lathe, turn the bottom flat. Glue a piece 3/4 to 1" thick of the same wood onto the bottom matching the grain, use the tail stock as a glueing clamp. after the glue dries turn the addon piece round and flatten the bottom (do not finish), and mark center. remove it and reverse it on the lathe. Finish the inside bottom of the bowel. Remove and reverse it on the lathe, finish turning the outside bottom by forming a bead at the glue joint and profile as needed. The glue joint may not show on the inside depending on the shape, if it does show more than expected you could try and "enhance" it by buring in a ring with a pointed hardwood stick. Have done all of the above with varing success.

Good luck

Joe

Re: Can I fix this?

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Can I fix this?

keith tompkins

>Steve, I wouldn't attempt to fix it. Toss it, or put it on a shelf. It's part of the learning process; we all go through it. You will find that you progress a lot faster by learning from your mistakes, rather than fixing them. Not everyone can be professional turner, but we all have the opportunity to do professional quality work.I know turners who fix mistake after mistake, year after year. A bad trap to fall into.

While this is only one turner's opinion, a bowl or hollow form that's been repaired never looks right. Accidents and mistakes are not limited to woodturning....it happens in all the other crafts as well. However, when was the last time you saw a "repaired" ceramic or glass piece sitting on a shelf for sale? I just doesn't happen. I think we should strive for that same level.

Re: Can I fix this?

#8

Steve Kubien

Thanks for the comments

Steve Kubien

>While I put it aside and went to the next bowl-to-be, it became obvious that it was meant to sit near my lathe and hold the bars/wrenches for my chuck, a 6" ruler and a pencil! However, I think I will try the loonie trick (hopefully while listening to the Leafs lose) and if that proves unsuccessful, I'll try adding a new bottom plank. Don't worry Keith, this one is not destined for any shelf outside of the shop!

Thanks again,

Steve Kubien

Re: Can I fix this?

#9

Re: Can I fix this?

Clay Foster

>Steve,

I've seen lots and lots of "repairs" of this mistake. I've never seen one that looked good. They all look just like what they are - a patched mistake.

Re: Can I fix this?

#10

Re: Can I fix this?

Bill Youngblood

>You could always go a little into left field and design a bottomless piece. It certainly wouldn't look repaired and would be different than the norm. Otherwise, I agree with Kieth. It's only a piece of wood and sitting on a shelf in the shop serves as a great reminder. Just another thought. Good luck.

Bill

Re: Can I fix this?

#11

Re: Can I fix this?

Mac

>Steve this is a pic of what I was trying to explain in my previous post.Some may not like it,but it works for me when I need it....I use it sometimes even when its not needed...


img

Re: Can I fix this?

#12

Richard Allen

Re: Can I fix this?

Richard Allen

>I was hoping the voice of reason would be heard.

There is however one good reason to "fix" the bowl. The techniques that you will learn fixing a bowl will enable you to do things with your woodturning that might not otherwise be able to do. Exactly what that "thing" is I am not sure. I know I started learning about working with epoxy this way. I now use epoxy for decorative effect. I wouldn't be as comfortable using epoxy now if it were not for those first uses of epoxy in "fixes". Of course there are faster ways to become familiar with the use and properties of epoxy. I learn best when I have a tangible goal. So practice working with epoxy isn't likely give me the solid skills I need to make the leap into using epoxy for artistic goals.

Re: Can I fix this?

#13

Re: Can I fix this?

Brian Simmons, Heflin, AL

>I turned this 14" diameter platter from mulberry. It was the only large piece I could make out of the available wood so I really wanted to save it after turning thin enough to pop out the center while sanding. Original hole was about 1-3/4", I opened it up to 5" to give the piece better balance. The plug was made with black walnut and cherry. This piece now belongs to my wife ;>


img

Re: Can I fix this?

#14

Keith, how would you know?????

Barry Irby

>You said, "when was the last time you saw a "repaired" ceramic or glass piece sitting on a shelf for sale?" IF the repair was good enough, how would you know?

We discuss "design opportunities" all the time.

I actually agree with you and probably would not try to fix the piece, but that does not mean its impossible or should not be attempted. I have tossed a few my self and its a good idea to keep one or two as a painful reminder not to make that mistake again. There are plenty of other mistakes waiting for you.

I looked at the picture posted by Mac and like his repair. Bonnie Klein did a Demo at our club and turned one of her small boxes. It featured a ring she let into the opening between the box and the lid. Makes you go HMMMM? Was that little ring of fabulous wood a decorative feature or a design opportunity? Which came first? The ring or the lid that was too loose?

Lots of segmented bowls (maybe All?) have a bottoms glued in or on. How about those layered bowls featured in the AAW journal a few months back?

So I think you should take that bowl and whack yourself on the head with it once in a while so you don't do that again and wait for an inspired design opportunity.

Re: Can I fix this?

#15

Brad Vietje

No, But here's another idea...

Brad Vietje

>My brother used to make a lot of glass paperweights. When I messed up bowls, especially smaller ones, I would reverse them, and true up the hole and give it just a little decoration around the outside. Then it can be inverted, with a LED light and a battery inside, and makes a wonderful display stand for glass paperweights, or other blown glass items. Once it dries fully, you can even open up the hole to around 2 - 3", and inset a piece of glass, on which translucent jewelry or crafts can be displayed (again, upside-down with a light inside).

If you make it look real nice -- carefully sanded and finished on the outside -- you could donate it to a craft shop selling glass paperweights, and they'll be sure to remember you when your skills advance and you are ready to sell some bowls...

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Can I fix this?

#16

Re: No, But here's another idea...

Bob Way, Canton, MI

>Now that's a really clever idea. Even for displaying other items.

Bob Way