Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Couple Questions for spindle turners

Posts

Couple Questions for spindle turners

#1

Couple Questions for spindle turners

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Hello.

What is the correct way to use a skew chisel to obtain a really smooth surface?

I'm making a couple tool (bowl gouge) handles out of walnut and cherry scraps. I have the basic shape I want. I kinda recall seeing Norm using his lathe making spindles and using the skew chisel as the last step to get a really smooth surface. I also remember seeing (can't remember where!) a video of Ernie Connover doing it and he had his one hand behind the piece he was turning and that hand was also supporting the chisel(?). Maybe I am way too cautious but I didn't want the chisel to did in. So I was barely touching the wood.

I guess this question could dovetail into "How do you get that perfect cylinder or taper?" for a table leg for example. I ask that too because I'm supposed to be making a table for my MIL. I might try turned legs. I usually make tapered legs.

I tried it last night and was ending up with high spots that looked something like spirals. Very faint, not very noticeable, but there. I'm able to get a smooth surface with a regular gouge but I'm trying for that super smooth feel. Like a board I just hand planed vs. sanded. Remember, I'm a flatwork guy. I like using hand planes, not sand paper. Well, when I can get away with it... :)

Sorry for so many questions and wordy posts... I can't help it! Geez, I think my wife talks too much?... :)

Thanks,

Joe

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#2

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

Ruth Niles

>Joe,

With turning tool handles, you really don't need to have your hand supporting the piece since it's rather large in diam. This is usually done with thin and long spindles that might wobble while turning or that any pressure from the tool would break the turning.

You might be using too light of a touch if you're getting those ripples or not rubbing the bevel so your skew is more or less bouncing over the wood to cause a ripple.

Practice is not an over-used word with respect to the skew chisel!

You'll be getting baby-butt smooth finish in no time.

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#3

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

John Lucas

>If you can get Alan Lacer's video on the skew it will help a lot. It depends on the thickness of the spindle whether or not you have to use your finges or a steady rest to get a smooth cut. Mostly it's proper technique with the skew.

To get an accurate taper measure about every inch or so and use your parting tool to cut down to the size you have designed. Then you just take the skew and take off wood until you just barely go below your cuts.

It's hard to describe how to use the skew in words.

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#4

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

John Lucas

>Ruth is dead on. To get a good smooth finish without chatter takes a very sharp tool and light pressure on the bevel of the tool.

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#5

Translate your skills

Georg Waldhof

>Have you ever tried using a hand plane on a spindle? It acts similar to a skew, but you don't have to deal with catches, etc. and it can/does produce a consistent cylinder. Think of it as a smoothing action like on a table top but round.

Of course, this is pretty useless on beads, coves, etc. but it works pretty nicely on cylinders and tapered cylinders (cones).

Never rule out a possibility - just make sure to think about the possible consequences first ;-))

Good luck!

Oh - another thing: I've seen turners use a skew upside down (point on bottom) to reduce catching.

George

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#6

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

Jorge Castaneda

>Joe,

Spirals are usually made by catches, just like making a thred for a screw, if that is not what you are taliking about,

I think I know what, we call it "ropping" kind of looks like the lay of a rope, it is caused by vibration, I get it all the time in my Nova 3000 lathe, sometimes if you just slow down your rate of feed it goes away, sometimes changing the lathe speed to a higher (or lower) helps too, inspect your lathe and try to identify sources of vibration, in mine there are 2, one are the pulleys, that were cast and machined only in the outside, so they are not balanced, the other is in the motor.

Try raising the tool rest a little and when you are cutting, small bites with the heel of the skew leading.

A very sharp skew and lots of practice...

Jorge

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#7

Angle?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>At what angle should you approach the spindle? Not sure I'm asking that right. Below is a crude representation of what I was trying.

Thanks,

Joe


img

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#8

Darn. That's not right...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>The bottom right of the pictured skew should be pointing down more. The picture looks more like a regular chisel! Sorry. You probably know what I mean...

Thanks.

Joe

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#9

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Joe,I am going to utter what some consider blasphemy here, but sandpaper is your friend. I can get a very smooth surface, burnished in a lot of cases, with my skew. Then I go back and sand it. Why? Because any finish I am going to put on that wood, especially if it is a stain, is going to be received differently on differently finished surfaces. This doesn't really matter for tool handles, but it does matter for table legs. If you have sections that have been turned with gouges, and sections that have been burnished to baby butt smooth with your skew, people will notice the difference across the room. It will look like two different pieces of wood stuck together in some cases.

If you have big ropy chatter from vibration, regardless of the cause, you need to work on technique, sharpening, etc. If you have little ropy stuff that you can feel, but not really see, get out the abrasive gouge and fix it up right. The overall piece will look much better for it.

Bill

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#10

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

Russ Fairfield

>Has anyone, or do you know of anyone who has actually used a hand-plane to smooth the surface of a spinning cylinder on a lathe??

I have seen this in the woodworking magazines for 50 years. I first saw it in one of the 40's vintage Popular Mechanics magazines in our high school library, so it has been around for a long time. I had to try it then, and I have tried it several times over the years, usually prompted by its being published as a new tip in a magazine. I have never been able to do anything but throw the plane across the room.

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#11

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

Russ Fairfield

>Hear hear Bill. That's what they make 60-grit for.

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#12

Re: Darn. That's not right...

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Joe, regarding your picture, it is the presentation of the edge that counts, whether you are using a skew chisel or a straight chisel. Starting at 45 deg is a good place, and then you adjust the angle to accomodate whatever the sweet spot of the skew plus species is going to be.

Bill

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#13

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

Don in Northern Arizona

>I am in kindergarten when it comes to woodturning, but I did take a class in spindle turning from Ernie Conover. Another reason Ernie wraps his hand around a square that he is turning into a spindle is so that he can feel it become round and not take off more wood than is necessary. From everything I have been taught the key to success with the skew is to practice a lot and hopefully you will eventually get that sheen that hardly needs sanding. As a beginner, I find an oval skew is a little easier to use. In the meantime if you need to get something done with a minimum of wasted wood, you can get a near perfect cylinder and taper with nothing more that a roughing gouge and possibly a spindle gouge using the parting tool as suggested by John Lucas to mark out your taper. Then use a non-loading sandpaper like Norton 3X to get your spindle smooth. It seems to me that Norm always has to hit his turnings with a little sandpaper even after he uses the skew.

Don

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#14

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

Matt Berry

>The Skew Chisel video by Alan Lacer is a great learning tool. It is worth the money and will help answer your questions about the skew chisel.

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#15

Re: Translate your skills

John Lucas

>I've tried using a handplane. It chatters and really doesn't give you as good a cut. Sometimes I can get it to cut nice. It only works on long straight areas however.

My dad is not a good turner and really doesn't want to learn. He gets it close with the rought out gouge and uses a 3" belt sander to flatten his tapers.

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#16

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

John Lucas

>Russ As I mentioned above I have tried it with block planes, smoothing planes and jointer planes. Haven't launched on yet but it just doesn't do a good job of smoothing wood while the lathe is spinning.

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#17

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

John Lucas

>Bill I ran into exactly what you are talking about when trying to stain some pieces for a customer. I had to sand back the skew areas. Then I saw George Hatfield turn and his coves looked just like his flat areas. I practiced until I could do that. I still use sandpaper mostly unless I'm trying to show off because frankly, it's just faster.

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#18

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>I tried it one time too Russ, and managed to fling a plane across the room. I am much better with a handplane now (on flat wood anyway) and my planes are better, but there is no way I am taking a good Lie Nielsen or Lee Valley plane and sticking it on a piece of wood. That is what my chisels are for.

Bill

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#19

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Not only that John, but the legs will need to match the rest of the table, and it is unusual to see flat wood sanded past 150 grit! I used to sand to 220, but then I took a class with Jeff Jewitt, and he said anything past 150 was not really needed. I suppose this will bring out some sanding advocates now, but I am only the reporter here.

Bill

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#20

Re: Translate your skills

Georg Waldhof

>LOL - I've done that too, with the belt sander. ;-))

It took me a bit of tinkering, adjusting and practice with a hand plane before I got the chatter out, but your right, its pretty pointless on a short piece.

And you can't do duck calls with it either.

George

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#21

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

john lucas

>Bill did you see my sanding test on flat wood. None of our club memebers was able to see a difference in the wood after 400 grit using 4 different woods and oil and lacquer finishes. I still haven't had the time to run this test on figured roung wood which some say will show up the difference.

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#22

Plane launching

john lucas

>Don't they have a power tool racing organization. We could have a plane launching contest. Kind of like the pumpkin launching but usint a lathe.

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#23

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

Peter Hyde

>Joe,

others may disagree but I too had all the same problems and solved them in 2 ways.

1 Buy the tickest skew you can find

2 try adjusting your speeds to remove rope effect

3 After roughing support thin cylinders with you left hand first 2 fingers behind the revolving piece and your thumb over the top of the skew holding it down on the toolrest.

4 Look at this


img

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#24

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

Jimiles

>I can"t remember where I heard it, but my favorite advice on "proper use " of a skew is this: hold the handle high, use the pointy end in the slot, push down on the handle and the paint can lid will pop right off. LOL

Re: Couple Questions for spindle turners

#25

Lol - :)

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>