Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Exchang Piece

Posts

Exchang Piece

#1

Exchang Piece

Scott in Falcon

>Hi all,

I'll be the first to admit that I signed up for the exchange looking forward to it and feeling quite confident that I met all of the requirements set forth in the rules. You see, I've been turning for a couple of years, but don't get near as much time at the lathe as I would like to so I still make more scrap than acceptable pieces. But, I would make a piece that was the best I could do and be happy to pass it along.

I then read all of the lurker threads (I say this warily so as not to bring the subject up again) and I started having doubts about my qualifications. I'm no where near the quality of turner that many on this board are. I actually got to the point that I thought about withdrawing my name from the Exchange. But I didn't want to cause headaches for the guys running it, so I held off. I took a couple of deep breaths and went back and re-read the rules for the Exchange. I still qualified! :)

With all that being said, here's my Exchange piece. It's a 6 inch diameter Cherry plate with a Padauk stand. I sure hope that the person back East that it is on its way to enjoys it as much as I do!

Scott


img

Re: Exchang Piece

#2

Back view   

Scott in Falcon

>


img

Re: Exchang Piece

#3

Re: Exchang Piece

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Scott that is a beautiful piece that anyone here would be proud to receive.

I think if you go back and re-read the original post and then the responses you will be able to see the progress into chaos. Never in the beginning of that thread was there any mention of ability, years turning, etc. What was said pointed to instances of poor quality (actual hole in the bottom of a bowl) work. There is a tremendous difference!!! It was the over reactions and the perceived need of some to defend themselves for whatever reason that dragged that thread down.

Re: Exchang Piece

#4

Re: Exchang Piece

Carole Valentine

>Scott, that piece is beautiful! Anyone who receives that and doesn't appreciate it probably needs their head examined.

Hope you post some more of your work.

Re: Exchang Piece

#5

Wow

Ken DeMarco

>Scott, That is beautiful, wonderful piece of wood and well executed

Ken DeMarco

Re: Exchang Piece

#6

Re: Exchang Piece

Raymond Overman in SC

>Nice work Scott. That curly sure is pretty and I like the display stand too.

Re: Exchang Piece

#7

Brad Vietje

Ya done good !

Brad Vietje

>Excellent piece, Scott. While there is no threshold of perfection required of exchange participants -- just the best work someone can do at their individual level -- this piece would certainly qualify even if there was a very high standard to be met ! Anyone on this messageboard would love to receive such a pretty piece -- well done.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Exchang Piece

#8

Awesome Piece Scott!!!

Greg Haugen (La Crosse, WI.)

>Give yourself more credit. That is an outstanding piece!! Excellently executed and you really gave a great piece of wood the justification it needed! Well Done. Post more please, that was a pleasure to view!

Greg

Re: Exchang Piece

#9

Beauuuuutiful!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>This is lovely!

Re: Exchang Piece

#10

Leo Van Der Loo

A well done piece with incredible wood, love it

Leo Van Der Loo

>

Re: Exchang Piece

#11

Barb Siddiqui

O my goodness

Barb Siddiqui

>what a beautiful piece. Don't ever back out of anything...wow.

Re: Exchang Piece

#12

Re: Beauuuuutiful!

Mac

>Beautiful piece.....I'm back east!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: Exchang Piece

#13

Are you sure that it...

dwr

>was not supposed to head to the West Coast Scott??;)

Looking good! Someone is getting a beauty!

Re: Exchang Piece

#14

Re: Exchang Piece

chris rolke

>that is gorgeous

i see so many unbelieveable pieces on here

Re: Exchang Piece

#15

Steven Antonucci

I'm back East!

Steve Antonucci

>

Re: Exchang Piece

#16

Dick Hines

Re: Exchang Piece

Dick Hines

>Scot, I think your requirements are just great! You should post more of your work. I know I am looking foward to seeing more.

Re: Exchang Piece

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Exchang Piece

keith tompkins

>Scott, you are no longer a lurker....there's no going back now! Beautiful piece.

I'll bet if more lurkers began to post their work, we'd all be in for a big shock!!

Re: Exchang Piece

#18

Re: Beauuuuutiful!

bowlman

>Ditto what they said ... your skills are better than you think. This is a piece anyone should be proud to make or own. I'm already looking forward to your next post!

Dick Gerard

aka bowlman

Re: Exchang Piece

#19

Re: Exchang Piece

Bob Fawcett

>Wow this is beautiful!

I sure hope it is headed my way.

I am no pro either. I started turning 1/06. I hope what I made lives up to others expectations as well, but I did just what the rules say, I made something that is the best of my current ability.

Re: Exchang Piece

#20

Thank you!

Scott in Falcon

>I just wanted to say thank you to you all for the kind words and encouragement!

I'll post a pic of my first hollow forrm as well as some lessons learned in the next couple of days.

Scott