Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

Posts

Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#1

Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

Allen Neighbors

>Tree man brought me this; Owner said it was Walnut; don't think so.

But I don't know what it is. I blanked it out, and decided to turn one thin bowl to start. Cored a blank, and began to hollow. Got a catch, and ruined the thing. I'll post several different shots.

Can anyone identify it for me?


img

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#2

Re: Mystery Bark 

Allen Neighbors

>


img

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#3

Re: Mystery Side Grain 

Allen Neighbors

>


img

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#4

Re: Mystery End Grain 

Allen Neighbors

>


img

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#5

Re: Mystery Trunk 

Allen Neighbors

>


img

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#6

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

Carole Valentine

>This first pic looks somewhat like Box Elder aka Manitoba Maple. Are there red streaks or is that my monitor?

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#7

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

Mike Cunningham (Cape May NJ)

>That piece on the lathe looks like box elder.

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#8

Almond?

Troy German

>Plumb and peach also look similar.

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#9

Re: Mystery Trunk

Troy German

>The three main branches is how a farmer might cultivate a tree to increase sunlight exposure to the fruit.

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#10

Yep, box elder, lighter weight than maple

Jim Swank

>

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#11

Re: Your monitor's fine. It's red.

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#12

Re: The red wasn't there when I first

Allen Neighbors

>cut the blank. Then I noticed it when I began turning.

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#13

Re: Almond?

Allen Neighbors

>Never seen plum or almond, but I'm sure it isn't peach... I don't get the smell that I get when I turn green peach.

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#14

Just sayin'.....

David Breth

>My wood identification expertise extends about as far as my medical training, which pretty much stops at putting a bandaid on whatever the problem is, but I can't help but see a great deal of similarity between that piece and the piece of cherry below. The piece below has sapwood, and was actually a healed over branch disguised cleverly as a burl before I got my chainsaw on it.

I've intended to make this piece the subject of another post, so I guess I'll stop additional description.

Just sayin'. Looks kind of cherry-like to me.

David B.

David B.


img

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#15

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Allen,

Judging by the bark, you've either got pin cherry or one of the plums. I've had plum with lots of pink. Regardless, that is some beautiful wood.

Definitely not box elder, though.

Gary

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#16

Could be English walnut although usually the

Don Henthorn

>heart wood is darker. But not absolutely always however so it could be. That might be the reason he called it walnut.

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#17

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Mystery Trunk

Leo Van Der Loo

>I think it might be some kind of flowering Cherry/Plum (in the Prunus family) or the like, it's the bark that makes me think it might be in that direction, but like you say Allen, all those woods do have a smell to go with them and usually also have some of the gum also, it certainly does not look like any Walnut I know, I don't know if it could be a hazelnut/filbert tree, there are tree sized ones, never turned any of that kind of wood.

The best of a penny and a half I have for you, with what's given.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#18

Addendum: I farmed a lot of

Don Henthorn

>English walnut in California and pruned and cut many, many trees, especially after the ice storms came through and crushed the trees like giants had walked through and crushed them. I cut and burned six cords of wood a year and some years at least half of it was English walnut. I wasn't turning much then but what I wouldn't give now for some of that stuff I burned.

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#19

JL

Re:Hijack - general question...

JL

>Are most stone fruit (cherry, plum, etc.) woods generally alike except for variations in color? I've only turned dark cherry in the fruit woods (and that was kiln dried). I know they are all of the genus Prunus.

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#20

Almond limb

Troy German

>It's Apricot that also looks like Almond not peach, sorry. The pic is of an almond limb that was laying around. It's one of the main crops were I live (Chico, CA, northern Calif.).

Troy


img

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#21

Ice Storms??...

Troy German

>Wait just a minute there...Ice storms???...In California?? Are you pulling my leg?

Troy

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#22

Leo Van Der Loo

Re:Hijack - general question...

Leo Van Der Loo

>JL I would say they are not the same, but they do have a lot of familiarities, also one of the reasons they are so easily crossed and mixed, take peach-plum-apricot-nectarines-almonds,

their barks have a similar look as do the cherries, not the same as Birch but a bit like that, horizontally strips and lenticels, also when wounded they secrete a gummy sealant. the underbark has also similarities.

Cherry woods are very much alike, plum/prune is not the same as cherry, but does look very much like apricot.

There must be people that have more experience with the almonds and nectarine.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#23

Re: Mystery Trunk

Jimiles

>This view of the bark looks like Cherry to me

Does it have a smell when cut, Cherry has a distintive smell

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#24

JL

Re:Thanks

JL

>

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

#25

Re: Mystery Wood... where's Ed Karch? :o)

robo hippy

>I agree with plum as the wood. Bark, and wood color, and the way the pinks, and reds are in the wood. Finishes nicely and the colore help it sell very well.

robo hippy