Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Turn with wet or dry wood. Why? (longish)

Posts

Turn with wet or dry wood. Why? (longish)

#1

Turn with wet or dry wood. Why? (longish)

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Hi.

This question really is geared towards people that have mini's I guess (not a BMW Mini but a Jet Mini...). When I look at all the nice little bowls and so on posted here I always wonder if it started out as a wet chunk of log or a (KD) dried chunk.

Saturday I took some scrap Cherry, glued it up into a chunk and Sunday morning played around with it and my new Nova G3 chuck after rounding the corners off with my bs. How did it turn? Well... as you know cherry is pretty hard... it has a ways to go yet before it's even round.

I went to visit Doug Thompson again yesterday afternoon to see the beginnings of another hat (amazing). I took my chunk of cherry to show him the progress. When he was laughing hysterically at it, I threw it at him, grabbed one of his hats and ran! No, just kidding. He pointed out cracks in it. When I got home I noticed it appears more cracks developed. These were scraps that have been laying around in my shop for a couple years. So they were stable. Not sure why they would be cracking/moving so much now. The grain is all oriented the same direction too. Maybe the gluing? Doesn't matter. Just something to practice/play with.

I'm going to set that cherry chunk aside for a few days. I have to try my hand at making a couple tool handles now. Those will be turned from glued up stock too though so I'll see how that goes.

After watching Doug turn massive tree parts into thin delicate hats, I can see it's obvious why you would use yet wood for big stuff. What about little stuff though. It seems a drag to start a bowl, throw it a bag for a couple months to dry then finish turn it. I know. I know. During that couple months I could finish making that cherry table I started for my MIL. But I want to make a bowl... :)

I suppose some will say wet because it's wet when you find it laying someplace and it was free, or you'll say wet because it's much easier to turn wet. But what are some other reasons?

Thanks.

Joe

cold near Cleveland

Re: Turn with wet or dry wood. Why? (longish)

#2

Re: Turn with wet or dry wood. Why? (longish)

Jeff Myroup

>Joe,

My reasons for turning green have alot to do with what you have stated, free and easy to work. I think the main reason has to do with the suprises that lay under the bark. It is like opening a great gift Christmas morning. You never know what you will get.

jeff

Re: Turn with wet or dry wood. Why? (longish)

#3

JL

Re: Turn with wet or dry wood. Why? (longish)

JL

>OK - I am not a bowl turner, I turn spindles. I turn green hard maple on occasion for legs and stretchers. I also do the same with kiln dried hard maple.

I like turning it wet - nice satisfying curls. Cuts like a dream. I have to make things oversized a bit in the tenon as the leg or stretcher has a tendency to go oval on me as it dries. Not enough to really change the proportions on the leg or stretcher coves, bulbs, etc. - but enough to mess up a tenon fit. Some caveats - always cut a relief groove with your parting tool a bit in from both ends. If you don't, you may get checking into the top or bottom of your spindle (DAMHIKT). I usually stick the finished leg in the hot box for a couple of days with foil wrapped around the middle and lower parts leaving the tenon and the base exposed. I then true up the tenon.

I like turning it dry - the curls aren't satifying - cause there aren't any curls. The wood will keep it's proportions if it was adequately kiln-dried or air dried. It will also take better detail IMHO. You don't have to worry about checking that much.

I can turn a leg or stretcher faster with less tool sharpenings with green wood. I can get better detail and use a leg right away with kiln dried. I like both. If I can get decent air dried, I'd rather use that, but I don't have a source for it.

Re: Turn with wet or dry wood. Why? (longish)

#4

Re: Turn with wet or dry wood. Why? (longish)

Peter Teubel

>KD wood over 2" thick is both expensive and difficult to dry without defects. 6" thick DRY lumber generally does not exist (without defects). That's why we bowl turners rough turn to approx 1" thickness and dry it by various methods. Personally, I rough turn one bowl out of 3 to put aside for proper drying. I date it, slather Anchorseal over the entire bowl, and come back to it in a year or so. By using this method, the 1st year is the "longest" (i.e. waiting). After that, you'll have a stock of dry/drying bowl in the pipeline for finish turning.

There are various other methods for accelerating the drying process (DNA, soap, microwave, boiling, freezing, pagan rituals, divine intervention, etc.), but I just "put'em aside fer awhile". That's how I have close to 100 dry bowl blanks in my shed.

Re: Turn with wet or dry wood. Why? (longish)

#5

Free and nearly endless supply

Pat Taylor

>

Re: Turn with wet or dry wood. Why? (longish)

#6

Re: Turn with wet or dry wood. Why? (longish)

Bob Fawcett

>Joe,

Some here also turn wet and turn it to completion. You could do this and have a bowl. It will probably warp some. So what. You still have a bowl, and sometimes the warping adds to the finished piece.

Get yourself several blanks, rough turn a couple and put them up, then turn the next one to completion. Now you have the best of both worlds.

Re: Turn with wet or dry wood. Why? (longish)

#7

Brad Vietje

Two Responses

Brad Vietje

>Good question Joe, especially since almost all of us have some perfectly good scraps and small stock laying around.

First, I have never glued pieces together to make a bowl, so I may be way too biased. I turn 'em green and set 'em aside, as Peter mentioned, but usually small bowls are ready to turn in 3 - 6 months - depends on your local climate. BTW: you are almost always better to store green wood somewhere where there is no heat, especially if you have forced hot air heat-- this will ruin otherwise excellent blanks. Rough-turned bowls can be seasoned indoors, but they will need to be protected from drying and cracking. This can be Anchorseal, paste wax, paper bags, cardboard boxes, etc... Place the protected rough-outs in the coolest, most protected place you have, away from sunlight and wind -- corners of shop floors or stacked in a corner of a shady garage might be good -- lower in a room is usually cooler and more moist. Roughly 50% humidity is good.

Second, you can also make bowls quite thin from green wood, and allow them to be oval. For this to look "good" (highly subjective) you will probably want to fuss a bit to tilt the bowl so the figure and features are balanced -- that is, so the bowl doesn't have a big target of growth rings all on one side, and a really odd, warped shape when finished.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Turn with wet or dry wood. Why? (longish)

#8

Steven Antonucci

Want to lose a contest? Compete with Free...

Steve Antonucci

>Green wood is free. It grows on trees. Trees die, and need to be removed. People often pay for the removal. I haven't ever double dipped (charged for dropping a tree and taken all of the free turning wood...), but that would be the best of both worlds!

The reasons for green wood are obvious: supply is plentiful and usually free (I don't know of anyone paying to get green wood, except the occasional bowl). There is almost no alternative, and if there was, it would be prohibitively expensive (probably the reason there is no competition...)

BTW-

There is no greater joy at the lathe than a sharp gouge, reasonably high speed, and a balanced piece of wet maple.

Steve

Re: Turn with wet or dry wood. Why? (longish)

#9

Steve Kubien

Re: Turn with wet or dry wood. Why? (longish)

Steve Kubien

>I turned my first non-pen in late December. Since then, I've got about 6 bowls (varying degrees of happiness) and 3 plates. What would that have cost me if it was all dried stock? I don't know but it would be too much for just messing around with. The 2 pieces I am most happy were dried stock (elm plate and cherry bowl) but I would have wasted a lot of stock if I hadn't had green wood which was free.

Steve Kubien

P.S. I am a unemployed mini owner who likes watching things warp after I turn them.