Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

Posts

What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#1

What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

John Kyler

>Ok, I do all my sharpening.

I was curious thou what people pay to have woodturning tools or carving tools sharpened. I know some turners in my area that don't want to buy the grinder etc. to save money.. But what would be a fair price for sharpening if they could get it done somewhere?

And is there somewhere it can be done?

John

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#2

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

john lucas

>I sharpen tools so often I can't imagine paying someone to do it. There are a lot of different ways to sharpen tools without a grinder. A disc sander can be rigged up to the handwheel and makes a great sharpener. That's what I used for a good while until I made a jig to hold my 3" belt sander. Then I used that. I finally bought a grinder.

I know we all push big fancy grinders with white wheels but I sharpened my tools for a very long time with a $30 dollar grinder and gray wheels. It's all in the technique.

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#3

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

Lee Dale

>When turning a bowl or most anything else I sharpen several times and always before the final cut. Quote from John Jordan "Your tool can never be too sharp".....Lee

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#4

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

Ron in Drums PA

>John I can't imagine not sharpening my own tools. Even if it was for free I just couldn't to it. There are times I may need to sharpen a tool a couple times each turning session.

If you get lucky you may find a service that knows how to sharpen turning tools. I bet they are few and far between.

When I started turning, I purchased a cheap set of HF tools to learn how to do sharpen properly. It took a while, but I got the hang of it. I even found out that set of HF tools where not so bad.

Best thing to do is find somebody local to you to show you how to sharpen, then buy a grinder and practice.

BTW, I'm still experimenting with some grinds, you can't do that with a sharpening service.

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#5

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

John Kyler

>I better jump in here.

I have a grinder and will likely get a Tormek. I have no problem with my own tools.

But I run into some people that just wont part with the money for a grinder.

Or are afraid to sharpen (tell them to get the video from AAW), or just need to get the right grind back on the tool and keep looking for someone to grind the tools. I just wanted to see if there are places out there to do it and how much. The local sharpener in the Denver area does saw blades but not turning tools.

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#6

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

Bill Youngblood

>Maybe you could get your local AAW chapter to do a demo on sharpening. If your friends knew how to sharpen, maybe they wouldn't be afraid of it. As far as being too cheap, well sharpening is part of turning so they need to face the music. Alan Laser says that tools can be sharp or really sharp, but should be scary sharp.

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#7

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

Ron in Drums PA

>Sorry I misread you John.

Check a local woodcraft store to sharpen turning tools.

They might sharpen tools and may even have a grinder or two.

Tell your friends good luck.

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#8

It Would Take Weeks

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>to get anything turned if I didn't sharpen my own turning tools. Or I would have to have about 30 bowl gouges. I can't imagine not sharpenbing my own tools.

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#9

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

Carole Valentine

>I agree with Ron, I wouldn't do it even if it was free. I sharpen too many times while turning a piece. In addition, a grind on a gouge is a really personal thing, not like a plane or saw blade. Heck, I won't even let anyone sharpen my chainsaw chain anymore after having experienced a "professional sharpening"

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#10

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

Rick Davenport

>I have a mobile knife sharpening business and make half my income from it (the other half, believe it or not, comes from woodturning).

Having said that.......

If I ran into a woodturner who wanted to pay someone else for sharpening their tools, I would take the time to teach them to sharpen. The money saved by doing your own, would soon pay for a grinder and maybe even a Wolverine system.

I couldn't, in good conscience, take money for something a woodturner simply has to learn.

It's an integral part of turning.

Rick, "NotsoDull" Davenport

www.notsodull.com

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#11

I can't imagin anyone seriously trying to turn

Don Henthorn

>with the idea that they will send their tools out to be sharpened. That tact would be frustrating beyond words and it will take months to finish a project. It shows a basic misunderstanding of the difference between regular woodworking and turning. In regular woodworking pushing or pounding a chisel will result in going through several inches, perhaps in a few instances several feet of wood. In turning wood the chisel will be going through not a couple feet but likely thousands of feet of wood and the mount of sharpening required is exponentially greater. No turner is going to remain a turner if he/she has to wait to resume work after a tool dulls until some sharpening service sharpens his tools. It ain't going to happen.

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#12

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

Pat Taylor

>Not to beat the dead horse here, but I was fortunate enough that a Tormek was in my budget from the get-go, and I consider it one of my most essential "tools".

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#13

JL

Re: I can understand saw blades..

JL

>and even carbide router bits - but turning tools? The LOML says I have too many sharpening things already :). Waterstones, 8" grinder, Tormek, slipstones, etc.

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#14

Re: She's right, but then I begin to count....

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#15

Brad Vietje

WHY would you pay to have tools sharpened?

Brad Vietje

>Sorry, John, but I just felt compelled to change the tag line to what everyone must be thinking... I find this question oddly upsetting; am I the only one that feels like some people need a dash of cold water in the face to just wake them UP !?!?

I understand you do not use a sharpening service, and that you're asking for others who apparently don't dare to sharpen their own tools. This seems like a football player that wants to hire a shoe-tying service to me !!! I would refuse to help with that sort of request, and simply reframe the issue: "How can I help you learn to sharpen?", or something like that.

As John reported, the cost of a grinder really isn't the issue. Tools can be sharpened very well, and very easily on a disk sander -- really, they can. Lacking that, they could even create a sharpening disk with a chunk of MDF attached to a faceplate and a stick-on sanding disk -- really -- truly -- this will work! A few minutes to maybe an hour with a few pieces of scrap wood to make jigs or fixtures, and they're off and running, and their turning will advance by quantum leaps and superman bounds when they learn to sharpen their own tools.

As everyone else has reported, I sharpen and hone pretty often -- many times in an afternoon turning session. The key is to take off so little steel that they can do it as often as needed, and not waste good $$$ or tool steel. Even an $89 grinder and a $35 wheel will soon be much less than sending tools to a sharpening service. The results will also be FAR superior, and sending tools out to be sharpened just encourages using tools that are already getting dull which is dangerous! Not only that, but I can not imagine the earth turning slowly enough, or me living long enough to be satisfied with having to wait for someone else to sharpen my tools.

As for the tools, most of us have a few cheap-o tools that are good for sharpening practice -- If I had a similar friend, I'd be happy to help him/her construct a simple sharpening setup, and I'd GIVE them a cheap-o tool or two for practice just to get them past their fears.

Sorry to take such a harsh tone, but these people either need to learn to do it, or need to go do something else. I may be wrong, or entirely out of line here, but people who don't dare to take responsibilty for their tools probably just can't take full responsibility for using a lathe, and they are asking for a dangerous accident by being so timid. I don't mean to sound so punitive; I think the real question boils down to how can we help them get past their fears and get greater enjoyment and better results from their turning ?

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#16

Dick Hines

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

Dick Hines

>I do all my own sharping. When I start a bowl I sharpen my 3 bowl gouges. As one get so it wouldn't cut I switch to #2 and to #3. Then it's back to the grinder. This way I can move more wood between trips to the grinder.

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#17

That Could Only Be Aked By a Non_Turner...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#18

Re: That Could Only Be Aked By a Non_Turner...

John Kyler

>I'm a turner and I asked.

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#19

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

Peter Teubel

>"I know some turners in my area that don't want to buy the grinder etc. "

=======================

Then they are not turners.

I used to work part time at a local Woodcraft store and several times folks would come in to have their lathe tools sharpened. Every time, I've refused and explained why they HAVE to learn to sharpen their own tools...regardless of how little they use them. I show them how right there in the shop. Some end up buying a grinder and jig(s), some just leave.

This may sound harsh, but I feel I am doing them a service by explaining to them (in detail) how and why sharpening must be done often. Turning with dull tools is both unproductive *AND* can be dangerous.

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#20

Brad Vietje

POW! KA-ZAM! But no one meant to be harsh...

Brad Vietje

>Hello again John,

I've read through all the responses a few times, and I hope you don't feel like we're a bunch of jerks here at W/C for taking such a hard line in responding to your question. Well, actually, not everyone did, but I sure did.

I'm sure nobody here meant to be rude, or un-welcoming to your question, and I think we all get it -- you DO sharpen your tools, and wanted good advice for others you know. I take from the collected comments that the best response is to stand firm, and let them know that they really should learn to sharpen their own tools, and that big wampum is not required to put together a perfectly good sharpening system.

I just want you to know that no one wants you to feel bad, even though quite a few of us took a big swing and swatted that ball out of the park -- sharpening is a topic that arouses a lot of passion, and NOT sharpening appears to be even worse! Let your friends know that a few hours of practice and just a few pieces of scrap wood, and they can sharpen their tools as often as they like, and can make great strides to the next level in their turning.

If it helps, I can make a simple MDF sharpening/honing set-up, and post some pic's for you to pass on to the sharpening-challenged in your area. Even better, drag them to an area club meeting where they can get some sharpening tips from a local turning guru, especially someone who likes to tinker and do things using creativity and ingenuity instead of $$$.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#21

Re: What is the real reason for their asking? *LINK*

Russ Fairfield

>I think we are trying to answer the wrong question. We should be asking why anyone would want to have their turning tools sharpened for hire.

Could it be that the reason for anyone asking about the cost of sharpening lathe tools is that we have convinced them that THE ONLY tool to use is a long fingernail grind on a spindle gouge amd a long side-grind on the bowl gouge. These are the most difficult tool profiles for a beginner to duplicate, so we tell them to buy another $200 worth of grinding jigs and accessories in order to dulicate the tool profiles. The result is that they now have more invested in the grinding than they do in the turning and they still can't sharpen a tool consistently. Sharpening is still a difficult task for the new woodturner, and making it more complex doesn't make it any easier for them. .

I have become an advocate of the straight-across 45-degree tool grind for new woodturners. It is easy to duplicate because all they have to do is lay the tool on the rest and twist it across the grinding wheel. That way, they can grind a consistent and sharp tool, and spend their time learning to turn wood. They can worry about the fancy profiles later.

If they don't want to buy a grinder they can use a belt sander or a disc sander. Don't have that?? Then they can attach an MDF disc and a stick-on sanding disc to their lathe. PSI has one of those (made from steel plate) in their catalog. The objective is to get them turning wood, and not having to spend more on grinding than they did on the lathe.

And, the truth is that they might have a better tool for their mini-lathe than all of the fancy tool profiles. The other truth is that I turned a lot of wood with this tool profile and for a long time before I discovered that I could make life more complicated.

Look at the following article by Roy Child, and the tool profile I am talking about is A or B.


http://www.peterchild.co.uk/info1/sflute.htm

Re: What do you pay to have tools sharpened?

#22

Brad Vietje

Absolutely -- nice link.

Brad Vietje

>I agree completely that we can so easily get all bunched up about special grinds that we forget the basics -- sharp tools and lots of practice.

My gouges all came to me sharpened like example "A", and some I changed to an Ellsworth grind, but my finishing gouge, that I use for a lot of work, is a 1/4" bowl gouge, with a straight-across 45-degree conical bevel, just like example "B". I have another (3/8") with a shorter bevel for working across the bottoms of bowls where a longer bevel loses contact. I still prefer these gouges to have flat bevels that I sharpen on a home-made system built around a 12" sanding disk. The total cost was about 2 hours of messing around with some 3/4" plywood, a V-block cut from scrap, and a few indexing holes, since I already had a 50-year-old Shopsmith with a 12" disk. A very similar system can be mounted right on the lathe, or a $10 used motor shaft.

Money isn't the issue as long as someone wants sharp tools, has a few basic ideas, a few pieces of scrap wood, and some creative spark. Go to it !

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT